儿童阑尾炎临床结局预测因素:一线超声方案中操作者与判读者的作用
本研究纳入9283例疑似急性阑尾炎患儿,评估31名超声操作者和31名放射科医生个体差异对住院和阑尾切除的影响。多变量回归显示,住院和阑尾切除的预测因素包括体温、白细胞计数、男性、超声探头压痛、反跳痛及超声诊断阑尾炎,但操作者或判读者不是独立预测因素。结论认为个体操作者和判读者差异不预测临床重要结局。
要点
- 超声诊断急性阑尾炎是住院和阑尾切除的强预测因素。
- 操作者与判读者个体差异不影响住院或阑尾切除风险。
- 临床变量(体温、白细胞、压痛、反跳痛)比医师因素更重要。
核心结论
- 个体超声操作者和放射科医生的差异不预测疑似急性阑尾炎患儿的住院或阑尾切除等临床重要结局。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入单中心急诊科18岁以下疑似急性阑尾炎并行阑尾超声的患儿,共9283例(平均年龄9.9±4.2岁,男孩5400例[58.2%])。
- 排除研究期间操作或判读少于100例的超声操作者和放射科医生,最终纳入31名操作者(平均检查299±140例,范围115-610)和31名放射科医生(平均判读299±157例,范围101-845)。
- 采用多变量逻辑回归评估操作者、放射科医生、临床变量和系统因素对住院和阑尾切除的影响。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 住院的显著多变量预测因素包括体温(P<.0001)、白细胞计数(P<.0001)、男性(P=.002)、主院区 versus 卫星院区(P=.001)、超声探头按压腹部压痛(P<.0001)、反跳痛(P=.001)及超声诊断急性阑尾炎(P<.0001),操作者或放射科医生不是预测因素。
- 阑尾切除的预测因素包括体重(P<.0001)、白细胞计数(P<.0001)、男性(P=.0004)、超声探头按压腹部压痛(P<.0001)及超声诊断急性阑尾炎(P<.0001),操作者或放射科医生不是预测因素。
- 各操作者平均住院频率34.0%±3.3%(范围27.8%-42.6%),各放射科医生平均住院频率33.5%±3.9%(范围23.7%-41.6%);各操作者平均阑尾切除频率20.3%±2.6%(范围14.9%-27.0%),各放射科医生平均阑尾切除频率20.3%±3.1%(范围15.2%-28.7%)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在疑似儿童阑尾炎的超声报告中,应重点描述超声探头按压压痛、反跳痛及是否可见急性阑尾炎征象,这些因素与住院和手术决策强相关。
- 操作者或判读者个体差异未显示影响临床结局,提示标准化培训和报告模板可能有助于减少变异。
局限性
- 本研究为单中心回顾性设计,结论外推需谨慎。
- 仅纳入操作或判读≥100例的医师,可能低估经验较少医师的变异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To determine if differences between individual sonographers and radiologists performing and interpreting appendix ultrasound affect clinically important outcomes in children with suspected acute appendicitis.
METHODS: Patients <18 years of age who presented to our emergency department (ED) with suspected acute appendicitis and underwent an appendix ultrasound were identified. Sonographers who performed fewer than 100 examinations and radiologists who interpreted fewer than 100 examinations during the study period were excluded. Multivariable logistic regression was performed to assess the effect of sonographer, radiologist, clinical variables, and system factors on key clinical outcomes, including hospital admission and appendectomy.
RESULTS: In all, 9,283 appendix ultrasounds (mean age, 9.9 ± 4.2 years; 5,400 [58.2%] boys) performed by 31 sonographers (mean number of examinations, 299 ± 140 [range, 115-610]) and interpreted by 31 radiologists (mean number of examinations, 299 ± 157 [range, 101-845]) were included. Mean admission frequency per sonographer was 34.0% ± 3.3% (range, 27.8%-42.6%) and per radiologist was 33.5% ± 3.9% (range, 23.7%-41.6%). Mean appendectomy frequency per sonographer was 20.3% ± 2.6% (range, 14.9%-27.0%) and per radiologist was 20.3% ± 3.1% (range, 15.2%-28.7%). Significant multivariable predictors of hospital admission included temperature (P < .0001), white blood cell count (P < .0001), male sex (P = .002), imaging performed at the main hospital (versus satellite hospital) (P = .001), abdominal tenderness with ultrasound transducer compression (P < .0001), presence of rebound tenderness (P = .001), and presence of acute appendicitis by ultrasound (P < .0001), but not sonographer or radiologist. Predictors of appendectomy included weight (P < .0001), white blood cell count (P < .0001), male sex (P = .0004), abdominal tenderness with ultrasound transducer compression (P < .0001), and the presence of acute appendicitis by ultrasound (P < .0001), but not sonographer or radiologist.
CONCLUSION: Differences in individual sonographers and radiologists did not predict clinically important outcomes in children undergoing ultrasound in the ED for suspected acute appendicitis.
引用
- Gilligan LA, Trout AT, Davenport MS, et al. Predictors of Clinical Outcomes in Pediatric Appendicitis: Role of the Individual Sonographer and Radiologist When Using a First-Line Ultrasound Approach. J Am Coll Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33933396. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2021.03.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。