卷积神经网络自动预测胸片左心腔扩大
研究开发深度学习算法DLCE-LAE和DLCE-LVE,基于胸片检测左房和左室扩大,以同日超声心动图为参考标准。DLCE-LAE外部验证AUROC为0.858,优于五位心胸放射科医师合并表现(0.651),作为第二读者可提升医师表现(0.651至0.722)。在健康筛查队列中,DLCE-LAE检出71.0%中重度左房扩大,假阳性率11.8%。
要点
- DLCE-LAE外部验证AUROC 0.858,优于传统胸片征象(0.535-0.706)。
- 作为第二读者,DLCE-LAE可将放射科医师AUROC从0.651提升至0.722。
- 筛查队列中DLCE-LAE对中重度左房扩大检出率71.0%,假阳性率11.8%。
关键影像表现/征象
- DLCE-LAE在外部验证集上AUROC为0.858。
- DLCE-LVE在内部验证集上AUROC为0.966,外部验证集上AUROC为0.594。
- DLCE-LAE在健康筛查队列中检出71.0%(142/200)中重度左房扩大胸片,其中重度病例检出93.5%(29/31),假阳性率11.8%(492/4,184)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- DLCE-LAE外部验证AUROC 0.858,优于五位心胸放射科医师合并AUROC 0.651(p < .001)。
- DLCE-LAE作为第二读者时,医师AUROC从0.651提升至0.722(p < .001)。
- DLCE-LAE AUROC显著高于传统胸片征象(心胸比、隆突角、双轮廓),AUROC 0.858 vs. 0.535-0.706(所有p < .01)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- DLCE-LAE可作为辅助工具提升左房扩大检出能力,尤其作为第二读者时。
- 在健康筛查人群中,DLCE-LAE对中重度左房扩大有较高检出率,但需注意11.8%的假阳性率。
- DLCE-LVE外部验证性能下降(AUROC 0.594),临床使用时需谨慎评估其泛化能力。
局限性
- 外部验证样本量较小(107张胸片)。
- DLCE-LVE外部验证AUROC仅0.594,泛化性能有限。
- 研究为回顾性设计,参考标准为同日超声心动图,可能存在选择偏倚。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To develop deep learning-based cardiac chamber enlargement-detection algorithms for left atrial (DLCE-LAE) and ventricular enlargement (DLCE-LVE), on chest radiographs METHODS: For training and internal validation of DLCE-LAE and -LVE, 5,045 chest radiographs (CRs; 2,463 normal and 2,393 LAE) and 1,012 CRs (456 normal and 456 LVE) matched with the same-day echocardiography were collected, respectively. External validation was performed using 107 temporally independent CRs. Reader performance test was conducted using the external validation dataset by five cardiothoracic radiologists without and with the results of DLCE. Classification performance of DLCE was evaluated and compared with those of the readers and conventional radiographic features, including cardiothoracic ratio, carinal angle, and double contour. In addition, DLCE-LAE was tested on 5,277 CRs from a healthcare screening program cohort.
RESULTS: DLCE-LAE showed areas under the receiver operating characteristics curve (AUROCs) of 0.858 on external validation. On reader performance test, DLCE-LAE showed better results than pooled radiologists (AUROC 0.858 vs. 0.651; p < .001) and significantly increased their performance when used as a second reader (AUROC 0.651 vs. 0.722; p < .001). DLCE-LAE also showed a significantly higher AUROC than conventional radiographic findings (AUROC 0.858 vs. 0.535-0.706; all ps < .01). In the healthcare screening cohort, DLCE-LAE successfully detected 71.0% (142/200) CRs with moderate-to-severe LAE (93.5% [29/31] of severe cases), while yielding 11.8% (492/4,184) false-positive rate. DLCE-LVE showed AUROCs of 0.966 and 0.594 on internal and external validation, respectively.
CONCLUSION: DLCE-LAE outperformed and improved cardiothoracic radiologists' performance in detecting LAE and showed promise in screening individuals with moderate-to-severe LAE in a healthcare screening cohort.
KEY POINTS: • Our deep learning algorithm outperformed cardiothoracic radiologists in detecting left atrial enlargement on chest radiographs. • Cardiothoracic radiologists improved their performance in detecting left atrial enlargement when aided by the algorithm. • On a healthcare-screening cohort, our algorithm detected 71.0% (142/200) radiographs with moderate-to-severe left atrial enlargement while yielding 11.8% (492/4,184) false-positive rate.
引用
- Nam JG, Kim J, Noh K, et al. Automatic prediction of left cardiac chamber enlargement from chest radiographs using convolutional neural network. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33942138. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-07963-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。