医学影像中患者野外接触屏蔽的使用:现行指南、推荐与立法文件综述
该综述在EURADOS第12工作组框架下,系统检索32个国家、6个国际组织过去39年的83份文件,评估X线成像中野外接触屏蔽的推荐与立法现状。总体推荐仅在不影响诊断任务和操作性能或能安抚患者及陪护时使用屏蔽,各文件立场差异大,亟需循证共识。
要点
- 野外接触屏蔽仅在不影响诊断任务和操作性能,或能安抚患者及陪护时推荐使用。
- 针对特定成像模态使用屏蔽的法规要求极少,多作为良好放射实践或防护工具可及性要求。
- 各国及国际组织文件对野外屏蔽立场差异大,缺乏一致性与循证共识。
核心结论
- 总体推荐仅在不影响诊断任务和操作性能,或能安抚患者及陪护时使用野外接触屏蔽。
- 针对特定成像模态使用屏蔽的法规要求极少,多作为良好放射实践或防护工具可及性要求。
- 各文件对野外屏蔽的推荐立场差异大,亟需循证共识以确保最佳且一致的实践。
研究设计与样本
- 综述在EURADOS第12工作组框架下进行,检索32个国家、6个国际组织过去39年的83份文件。
- 覆盖成人、孕妇及儿科患者在全景X线摄影、透视、CT、乳腺X线摄影及牙科放射学中的接触屏蔽推荐。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 使用野外屏蔽前应评估是否影响诊断任务和操作性能,避免因屏蔽遮挡而遗漏诊断信息。
- 可基于安抚患者及陪护的考量使用屏蔽,但需确保其不干扰成像过程。
- 注意不同指南与立法文件对屏蔽的立场不一致,报告或操作中应参考所在机构与最新共识。
局限性
- 综述纳入文件立场差异大且缺乏统一标准,难以形成一致推荐。
- 原文未报告系统评价的偏倚风险评估或证据分级方法。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
The use of patient contact-shielding has become a topic of intensive scientific debate. While it has been common practice during the last decades, some studies have questioned the efficiency of using such shielding while others have highlighted the inconsistencies in its application. The objective of this work is to review current recommendations and legislative documents on the use of out-of-field shielding in X-ray imaging, including those from national authorities and from international and national organisations and professional bodies. The review, performed within the framework of the activities of EURADOS Working Group 12, covers available recommendations on use of contact shielding in adult, pregnant and paediatric patients in general radiography, fluoroscopy, computed tomography, mammography and dental radiology. It includes a comprehensive search of 83 documents from 32 countries and 6 international organisations over the last 39 years. In general, using shielding is recommended only under two conditions: if it does not compromise the diagnostic task and the performance of the procedure and/or if it reassures the patient and comforters that they are appropriately protected against potentially harmful effects of radiation. There are very few specific regulatory requirements to use shielding in a particular imaging modality, although they may consider use of shielding either as part of good radiological practice or as requirements for availability of protective or ancillary tools, without further specification of their use. There is a wide variety of positions among documents that recommend out-of-field shielding, those that do not recommend it and those that are not specific. Therefore, evidence-based consensus is still needed to ensure best and consistent practice.
引用
- Candela-Juan C, Ciraj-Bjelac O, Sans Merce M, et al. Use of out-of-field contact shielding on patients in medical imaging: A review of current guidelines, recommendations and legislative documents. Phys Med. 2021. PMID: 34052671. doi:10.1016/j.ejmp.2021.05.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。