指南与共识神经技术与安全MR

脑MRI分割与分区质量控制策略:实用方法与建议——来自Maastricht研究的见解

Quality control strategies for brain MRI segmentation and parcellation: Practical approaches and recommendations - insights from the Maastricht study.
指南 / 共识 · Neuroimage · 2021-05-15

基于Maastricht研究259例结构脑MRI,比较12种质量控制策略对减少测量误差的效果。手动编辑脑表面显著改变皮层下体积,手动质控减少相对未解释方差最多,基于Euler数和MRIQC的自动策略是高效可重复的替代方案,而基于全局形态学指标排除离群值反而增加未解释方差。

要点

  • 手动质控最可靠但需防主观性,基于Euler数或MRIQC的自动检测是省时可重复的替代。
  • 手动编辑对皮层下体积影响大,对皮层表面积、厚度和海马体积影响中等。
  • 避免基于全局形态学指标排除离群值,否则相对未解释方差增加。

核心结论

  • 手动质控是脑分割和分区最可靠的质控方案,但需采取措施防止其主观性。
  • 基于Euler数或MRIQC检测不准确分割是省时且可重复的替代方案。
  • 基于全局形态学估计排除离群值应避免,因其增加相对未解释方差。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究使用Maastricht研究259名参与者的结构脑MRI,采用FreeSurfer 6.0自动提取形态学估计。
  • 对不准确分割进行手动编辑,比较编辑前后形态学估计变化,并对全样本应用12种质控策略。
  • 12种策略包括2种手动策略(视觉检查后排除或手动编辑)、5种自动策略(基于MRIQC、Qoala-T、全局形态学指标、Euler数、对比噪声比排除离群值)和5种半自动策略(对上述工具检测的离群值进行视觉检查并手动编辑)。
  • 通过计算每种策略应用后相对总方差的未解释方差比例来量化效果,并比较差异。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 日常阅片中可优先考虑基于Euler数或MRIQC的自动质控检测不准确分割。
  • 手动编辑对皮层下体积影响大,报告这些指标时需注意质控策略的影响。
  • 避免仅依据全局形态学指标排除离群值,以免增加未解释方差。

局限性

  • 研究基于单一队列(Maastricht研究)259名参与者,样本量和人群代表性有限。
  • 手动质控策略存在主观性,可能影响结果的可重复性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

Quality control of brain segmentation is a fundamental step to ensure data quality. Manual quality control strategies are the current gold standard, although these may be unfeasible for large neuroimaging samples. Several options for automated quality control have been proposed, providing potential time efficient and reproducible alternatives. However, those have never been compared side to side, which prevents consensus in the appropriate quality control strategy to use. This study aimed to elucidate the changes manual editing of brain segmentations produce in morphological estimates, and to analyze and compare the effects of different quality control strategies on the reduction of the measurement error. Structural brain MRI from 259 participants of The Maastricht Study were used. Morphological estimates were automatically extracted using FreeSurfer 6.0. Segmentations with inaccuracies were manually edited, and morphological estimates were compared before and after editing. In parallel, 12 quality control strategies were applied to the full sample. Those included: two manual strategies, in which images were visually inspected and either excluded or manually edited; five automated strategies, where outliers were excluded based on the tools "MRIQC" and "Qoala-T", and the metrics "morphological global measures", "Euler numbers" and "Contrast-to-Noise ratio"; and five semi-automated strategies, where the outliers detected through the mentioned tools and metrics were not excluded, but visually inspected and manually edited. In order to quantify the effects of each quality control strategy, the proportion of unexplained variance relative to the total variance was extracted after the application of each strategy, and the resulting differences compared. Manually editing brain surfaces produced particularly large changes in subcortical brain volumes and moderate changes in cortical surface area, thickness and hippocampal volumes. The performance of the quality control strategies depended on the morphological measure of interest. Overall, manual quality control strategies yielded the largest reduction in relative unexplained variance. The best performing automated alternatives were those based on Euler numbers and MRIQC scores. The exclusion of outliers based on global morphological measures produced an increase of relative unexplained variance. Manual quality control strategies are the most reliable solution for quality control of brain segmentation and parcellation. However, measures must be taken to prevent the subjectivity associated with these strategies. The detection of inaccurate segmentations based on Euler numbers or MRIQC provides a time efficient and reproducible alternative. The exclusion of outliers based on global morphological estimates must be avoided.

来源:Neuroimage,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Monereo-Sánchez J, de Jong JJA, Drenthen GS, et al. Quality control strategies for brain MRI segmentation and parcellation: Practical approaches and recommendations - insights from the Maastricht study. Neuroimage. 2021. PMID: 34000406. doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2021.118174

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。