指南与共识腹部MR

LI-RADS v2018培训可提升MRI判读与专家共识的一致性及阅片者间一致性

Does Training in LI-RADS Version 2018 Improve Readers' Agreement with the Expert Consensus and Inter-reader Agreement in MRI Interpretation?
指南 / 共识 · J Magn Reson Imaging · 2021-05-08

培训后LR-1至LR-5、LR-M和LR-TIV的AUC及阅片者间一致性均显著提高(LR-1的AUC除外),其中LR-TIV、LR-M和LR-2提升最明显。

要点

  • 培训可显著提升LI-RADS各最终分类的阅片者间一致性,LR-TIV和LR-M提升最大。
  • LR-1的AUC培训前后无显著改善(P=0.25),提示该类别培训效果有限。
  • 日常报告应关注LR-M和LR-TIV等培训后一致性提升明显的类别。

核心结论

  • LI-RADS培训可提高阅片者与专家共识的一致性及阅片者间一致性,对最终分类判读有正面效果。

研究设计与样本

  • 采用1.5T或3T MRI,序列包括双回波T1WI、快速自旋回波T2WI、SE-EPI DWI和动态多期快速梯度回波T1WI。
  • 以三位放射科医师共识判定的LI-RADS分类(LR1-LR5、LR-M、LR-TIV各10例)为标准参考,由第三位放射科医师实施培训。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 培训前后AUC:LR-1为0.898 vs 0.913(P=0.25),LR-2为0.711 vs 0.876,LR-3为0.747 vs 0.860,LR-4为0.724 vs 0.815,LR-5为0.844 vs 0.895,LR-M为0.688 vs 0.873,LR-TIV为0.720 vs 0.948,除LR-1外均显著提高(P<0.05)。
  • 培训前后阅片者间一致性:LR-1为0.725 vs 0.751,LR-2为0.325 vs 0.607,LR-3为0.330 vs 0.559,LR-4为0.284 vs 0.488,LR-5为0.447 vs 0.648,LR-M为0.229 vs 0.589,LR-TIV为0.362 vs 0.852,均显著提高(P<0.05)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 对LR-M和LR-TIV等培训后一致性提升明显的类别,判读时应更自信并规范报告。
  • LR-1的AUC无显著改善,提示该类别可能需额外培训或结合其他信息。
  • 培训可缩小阅片者间差异,有助于多中心或多人判读时统一标准。

局限性

  • 参考标准为三位专家共识而非病理金标准。
  • 仅评估培训前后短期效果,未评估长期保留。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: The Liver Imaging Reporting and Data System (LI-RADS) was established for noninvasive diagnosis for hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). However, whether training can improve readers' agreement with the expert consensus and inter-reader agreement for final categories is still unclear.

PURPOSE: To explore training effectiveness on readers' agreement with the expert consensus and inter-reader agreement.

STUDY TYPE: Prospective.

SUBJECTS: Seventy lesions in 61 patients at risk of HCC undergoing liver MRI; 20 visiting scholars.

FIELD STRENGTH/SEQUENCE: 1.5 T or 3 T, Dual-echo T1 WI, Fast spin-echo T2 WI, SE-EPI DWI, and Dynamic multiphase fast gradient-echo T1 WI.

ASSESSMENT: Seventy lesions assigned LI-RADS categories of LR1-LR5, LR-M, and LR-TIV by three radiologists in consensus were randomly selected, with 10 cases for each category. The consensus opinion was the standard reference. The third radiologist delivered the training. Twenty readers reviewed images independently and assigned each an LI-RADS category both before and after the training.

STATISTICAL TESTS: Accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value, positive likelihood ratio, negative likelihood ratio, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis, simple and weighted kappa statistics, and Fleiss kappa statistics.

RESULTS: Before and after training: readers' AUC (areas under ROC) for LR-1-LR-5, LR-M, and LR-TIV were 0.898 vs. 0.913, 0.711 vs. 0.876, 0.747 vs. 0.860, 0.724 vs. 0.815, 0.844 vs. 0.895, 0.688 vs. 0.873, and 0.720 vs. 0.948, respectively, and all improved significantly (P < 0.05), except LR-1(P = 0.25). Inter-reader agreement between readers for LR-1-LR-5, LR-M, LR-TIV were 0.725 vs. 0.751, 0.325 vs. 0.607, 0.330 vs. 0.559, 0.284 vs. 0.488, 0.447 vs. 0.648, 0.229 vs. 0.589, and 0.362 vs. 0.852, respectively, and all increased significantly (P < 0.05). For training effectiveness on both AUC and inter-reader agreement, LR-TIV, LR-M, and LR-2 improved most, and LR-1 made the least.

DATA CONCLUSION: This study shows LI-RADS training could improve reader agreement with the expert consensus and inter-reader agreement for final categories.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2 TECHNICAL EFFICACY STAGE: 2.

来源:J Magn Reson Imaging,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Zhang N, Xu H, Ren AH, et al. Does Training in LI-RADS Version 2018 Improve Readers' Agreement with the Expert Consensus and Inter-reader Agreement in MRI Interpretation? J Magn Reson Imaging. 2021. PMID: 33963801. doi:10.1002/jmri.27688

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。