深度学习去噪算法与迭代重建及滤波反投影的体模研究:12名阅片者对比
该研究以100例腹部CT图像训练深度学习去噪算法(DLA),输入FBP图像、以ADMIRE图像为参考标准;用Catphan体模在不同辐射剂量下随机重复扫描,12名放射科医师以5点置信度量表评估低对比度可检测性,并计算多阅片者多病例AUC。结果显示DLA的低对比度可检测性非劣于ADMIRE(p<.001)且优于FBP(p<.001);在ACR体模上,DLA较两厂商FBP改善所有物理测量指标,物理测量轮廓与ADMIRE相似。
要点
- DLA去噪图像的低对比度可检测性非劣于ADMIRE、优于FBP。
- DLA在ACR体模上较两厂商FBP改善所有物理测量指标。
- DLA的物理测量轮廓与ADMIRE相似,阅片时可参考ADMIRE经验。
核心结论
- DLA的低对比度可检测性非劣于ADMIRE且优于FBP。
- DLA较FBP改善图像质量,物理测量轮廓与ADMIRE相似。
研究设计与样本
- 体模研究,用100例腹部CT图像训练DLA,输入FBP图像、以ADMIRE图像为参考标准。
- 用Catphan体模在不同辐射曝光条件下随机重复扫描,12名放射科医师以5点置信度量表评估目标存在与否。
- 计算多阅片者多病例AUC并行非劣效检验,另用美国放射学会CT认证体模计算CNR、TTF、噪声幅度和d'。
诊断标准与关键数值
- DLA低对比度可检测性AUC非劣于ADMIRE(p<.001)且优于FBP(p<.001)。
- DLA较两厂商FBP改善所有物理测量指标,物理测量轮廓与ADMIRE相似。
- 物理测量包括对比噪声比、目标传递函数、噪声幅度和可检测性指数d'。
临床应用与阅片要点
- DLA去噪图像的低对比度检测能力可替代ADMIRE,优于FBP。
- DLA物理特性接近ADMIRE,日常阅片可沿用ADMIRE的窗宽窗位与判读经验。
局限性
- 体模研究,未在患者图像上验证诊断性能。
- DLA以ADMIRE为训练参考标准,性能上限受参考算法制约。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: (1) To compare low-contrast detectability of a deep learning-based denoising algorithm (DLA) with ADMIRE and FBP, and (2) to compare image quality parameters of DLA with those of reconstruction methods from two different CT vendors (ADMIRE, IMR, and FBP).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Using abdominal CT images of 100 patients reconstructed via ADMIRE and FBP, we trained DLA by feeding FBP images as input and ADMIRE images as the ground truth. To measure the low-contrast detectability, the randomized repeat scans of Catphan® phantom were performed under various conditions of radiation exposures. Twelve radiologists evaluated the presence/absence of a target on a five-point confidence scale. The multi-reader multi-case area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) was calculated, and non-inferiority tests were performed. Using American College of Radiology CT accreditation phantom, contrast-to-noise ratio, target transfer function, noise magnitude, and detectability index (d') of DLA, ADMIRE, IMR, and FBPs were computed.
RESULTS: The AUC of DLA in low-contrast detectability was non-inferior to that of ADMIRE (p < .001) and superior to that of FBP (p < .001). DLA improved the image quality in terms of all physical measurements compared to FBPs from both CT vendors and showed profiles of physical measurements similar to those of ADMIRE.
CONCLUSIONS: The low-contrast detectability of the proposed deep learning-based denoising algorithm was non-inferior to that of ADMIRE and superior to that of FBP. The DLA could successfully improve image quality compared with FBP while showing the similar physical profiles of ADMIRE.
KEY POINTS: • Low-contrast detectability in the images denoised using the deep learning algorithm was non-inferior to that in the images reconstructed using standard algorithms. • The proposed deep learning algorithm showed similar profiles of physical measurements to advanced iterative reconstruction algorithm (ADMIRE).
引用
- Kim Y, Oh DY, Chang W, et al. Deep learning-based denoising algorithm in comparison to iterative reconstruction and filtered back projection: a 12-reader phantom study. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33885958. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-07810-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。