缩减扫描范围与标准范围腹部盆腔CT诊断阑尾炎的性能与辐射剂量比较
回顾性纳入531例因腹痛或疑似阑尾炎行急诊增强CT的成人,年轻患者采用L2至耻骨联合的缩减范围(181例),年长或鉴别诊断广者采用膈肌至坐骨的标准范围(350例)。缩减范围诊断阑尾炎的敏感度98.2%、特异度99.2%、准确率97.8%,与标准范围(100%、99.6%、97.4%)相仿,平均DLP显著更低(363 vs. 633 mGy·cm)。体模测量显示缩减方案有效剂量降低26%–47%。
要点
- 年轻临床疑似阑尾炎患者可采用L2至耻骨联合的缩减CT范围,诊断性能与标准范围相当。
- 缩减范围显著降低辐射剂量,DLP降低约57%,体模有效剂量降低26%–47%。
- 缩减范围不覆盖膈肌至L2区域,需确保临床高度怀疑阑尾炎且无其他上腹部鉴别诊断。
核心结论
- 对于临床疑似阑尾炎的年轻成人,缩减扫描范围CT与标准范围CT的敏感度、特异度和准确率相仿,且辐射剂量显著更低。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究纳入531例连续成人,2018年7月至2019年3月行急诊增强CT,缩减范围组181例(平均26±6岁,L2至耻骨联合),标准范围组350例(平均55±17岁,膈肌至坐骨)。
- 参考标准为手术病例的组织病理学或非手术病例3个月病历随访。
- 使用体模在有无自动电压选择的CT扫描仪上测量器官剂量并计算有效剂量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 缩减范围组阑尾炎频率31.5%(57/181),标准范围组22.9%(80/350)。
- 缩减范围组敏感度98.2%(95%CI 90.4-99.9%)、特异度99.2%(95%CI 95.6-100.0%)、准确率97.8%。
- 标准范围组敏感度100.0%(95%CI 95.3-100.0%)、特异度99.6%(95%CI 97.9-100.0%)、准确率97.4%。
- 缩减范围组平均DLP 363±191 mGy·cm,标准范围组633±591 mGy·cm(p<0.0001)。
- 体模有效剂量(标准方案 vs 缩减方案):扫描仪1(有自动电压选择)4.64 vs. 2.48 mSv,缩减方案低47%;扫描仪2(无自动电压选择)4.68 vs. 3.45 mSv,缩减方案低26%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对临床高度怀疑阑尾炎的年轻成人,可考虑采用L2至耻骨联合的缩减扫描范围以降低辐射剂量。
- 缩减范围不包含上腹部,若鉴别诊断较广或存在上腹部病变可能,应选择标准范围。
局限性
- 回顾性研究,缩减范围组与标准范围组年龄和临床选择标准不同,可能存在选择偏倚。
- 缩减范围组样本量较小(181例)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare the diagnostic performance and radiation dose of reduced vs. standard scan range CT in diagnosing appendicitis.
METHODS: We retrospectively evaluated 531 consecutive adults who underwent emergency contrast-enhanced CT for abdominal pain or suspected appendicitis between July 2018 and March 2019. One hundred eighty-one young adults (mean age, 26 ± 6 years) were imaged from L2 to the symphysis pubis (reduced protocol). A total of 350 older patients (mean age, 55 ± 17 years) and those with a wider differential diagnosis were imaged from the diaphragm to the ischium (standard protocol). The reference standard was histopathology (surgical cases) or 3 months of medical record follow-up (nonsurgical cases). Sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy were calculated. Mean dose-length products (DLP) were compared (t-test). Using an anthropomorphic phantom, organ doses were measured on CT scanners with (scanner 1) and without (scanner 2) automatic voltage selection; effective radiation doses were calculated.
RESULTS: The frequency of appendicitis was 57/181 (31.5%) and 80/350 (22.9%) in the reduced and standard groups, respectively. Results of the reduced and standard protocols respectively were as follows (95% CI in parentheses): sensitivity, 98.2% (90.4-99.9%) and 100.0 (95.3-100.0%); specificity, 99.2% (95.6-100.0%) and 99.6% (97.9-100.0%); accuracy, 97.8% and 97.4%; mean DLPs, 363 ± 191mGy∙cm and 633 ± 591mGy∙cm (p < 0.0001). Phantom-based measurements of effective dose were 47% lower on scanner 1 (4.64 vs. 2.48 mSv) and 26% lower on scanner 2 (4.68 vs. 3.45 mSv) with the reduced protocol.
CONCLUSION: For young adults with clinically suspected appendicitis, a reduced scan range CT protocol is as sensitive, specific, and accurate as a standard scan range CT and imparts significantly less radiation dose.
KEY POINTS: • A reduced scan range CT protocol in young adults with high suspicion of appendicitis demonstrates similar diagnostic performance as a full-range abdominopelvic CT in undifferentiated adult patients. • The reduced scan range CT protocol imparts significantly less radiation dose: 57% based on dose-length product data and 26-47% based on anthropomorphic phantom data.
引用
- Dowhanik A, Tonkopi E, Crocker CE, et al. Diagnostic performance and radiation dose of reduced vs. standard scan range abdominopelvic CT for evaluation of appendicitis. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33856521. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-07945-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。