文献速递心血管胸部CT

基于动脉的冠脉钙化序数分级方法在低剂量胸部CT上的比较

Comparison of artery-based methods for ordinal grading of coronary artery calcium on low-dose chest computed tomography.
PubMed 文献 · Eur Radiol · 2021-04-22

回顾性纳入120例同日行低剂量胸部CT与心电门控钙化积分CT的无症状受试者,由三名心胸放射科医师采用三种基于动脉的序数分级方法评估冠脉钙化严重程度。基于长度的方法在观察者间一致性和与心电门控钙化积分CT的一致性上均最高,可能最适合用于非心电门控低剂量胸部CT上的冠脉钙化评估。

要点

  • 基于长度的方法在非心电门控低剂量胸部CT上评估冠脉钙化严重程度最可靠。
  • 1.25mm与2.5mm层厚下,基于长度方法的观察者间一致性均最高。
  • 三种分级方法在同一观察者内的一致性仅为差至中等,方法间不可互换。

核心结论

  • 在三种基于动脉的序数分级方法中,基于长度的方法在非心电门控低剂量胸部CT上评估冠脉钙化最为可靠。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性纳入120例同日行低剂量胸部CT和心电门控钙化积分CT的无症状受试者。
  • 由三名心胸放射科医师独立在1.25mm和2.5mm层厚的低剂量胸部CT上评估冠脉钙化严重程度。
  • 采用基于范围评分、Weston评分和基于长度评分三种基于动脉的序数分级方法,将钙化分为无、轻度、中度、重度四类。
  • 以心电门控钙化积分CT为参考标准,用Fleiss kappa评估观察者间和观察者内一致性,用加权kappa评估各方法与参考标准的一致性。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 基于范围评分、Weston评分和基于长度评分均将冠脉钙化严重程度分为无、轻度、中度、重度四类。
  • 观察者间一致性:1.25mm层厚下Fleiss kappa分别为基于范围法0.735、Weston评分0.801、基于长度法0.813;2.5mm层厚下分别为基于范围法0.755、Weston评分0.776、基于范围法0.833(原文如此)。
  • 同一观察者内三种分级方法间的一致性:1.25mm层厚下Fleiss kappa为0.379-0.441(差至中等),2.5mm层厚下为0.427-0.461(中等)。
  • 与心电门控钙化积分CT的一致性:基于长度法在1.25mm层厚下加权kappa为0.773-0.786,在2.5mm层厚下为0.794-0.825,均为三种方法中最高。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 在非心电门控低剂量胸部CT上评估冠脉钙化时,可优先考虑基于长度的序数分级方法以提高可重复性。
  • 三种分级方法在同一观察者内的一致性仅为差至中等,报告时应注明所用方法,避免跨方法直接比较。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: To identify the optimal artery-based method for ordinal grading of coronary artery calcium (CAC) on non-electrocardiogram (ECG)-gated low-dose chest computed tomography (LDCT) among three methods.

METHODS: A total of 120 asymptomatic subjects who underwent both LDCT and ECG-gated calcium scoring CT on the same day were retrospectively enrolled. Three cardiothoracic radiologists independently assessed CAC severity on LDCT (1.25-mm and 2.5-mm slice thickness) and classified it into four categories (none, mild, moderate, or severe) using three artery-based ordinal scoring methods (extent-based scoring, Weston scoring, and length-based scoring). Inter- and intra-observer CAC severity agreements of each method were assessed by Fleiss kappa statistics. Agreements between each method and ECG-gated calcium scoring CT were assessed by weighted kappa statistics.

RESULTS: The inter-observer agreement was highest with length-based method for both 1.25-mm (Fleiss kappa 0.735 for extent-based method, 0.801 for Weston score, and 0.813 for length-based method) and 2.5-mm slice thickness evaluation (Fleiss kappa 0.755 for extent-based method, 0.776 for Weston score, and 0.833 for extent-based method). Agreement across the three grading methods for the same observer was poor to moderate on 1.25-mm (Fleiss kappa 0.379-0.441) and moderate on 2.5-mm thickness evaluation (Fleiss kappa 0.427-0.461). Agreement of CAC severity between each method and ECG-gated calcium scoring CT was highest with the length-based method for all three observers on both 1.25-mm (weighted kappa 0.773-0.786) and 2.5-mm (weighted kappa 0.794-0.825) LDCT images.

CONCLUSION: Among the three artery-based ordinal grading methods, the length-based method appears to be the most reliable for evaluating CAC on non-ECG-gated LDCT.

KEY POINTS: • The length-based method showed the highest inter-observer agreement and the highest agreement with the ECG-gated calcium scoring CT, compared with the extent-based method and the Weston score.

来源:Eur Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lee S, Suh YJ, Nam K, et al. Comparison of artery-based methods for ordinal grading of coronary artery calcium on low-dose chest computed tomography. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33885959. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-07987-7

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。