文献速递胸部CT

COVID-19、流感与机化性肺炎的胸部CT表现比较:多阅片者研究

Comparison of Chest CT Findings of COVID-19, Influenza, and Organizing Pneumonia: A Multireader Study.
PubMed 文献 · AJR Am J Roentgenol · 2021-04-14

该回顾性多阅片者研究纳入150例(COVID-19、流感、非感染性机化性肺炎各50例)胸部CT,由6名胸部放射科医师独立评估14种CT征象、RSNA COVID-19分类及倾向诊断。COVID-19与流感在7/14种征象上差异显著,与机化性肺炎在4/14种征象上差异显著;倾向诊断平均正确率COVID-19为44%、流感29%、机化性肺炎39%,诊断准确性COVID-19为70%、流感与机化性肺炎均为68%。结论认为三者CT表现重叠明显,尤其COVID-19与机化性肺炎,放射科医师鉴别诊断准确性低。

要点

  • COVID-19与机化性肺炎CT重叠程度高于与流感,需警惕将机化性肺炎误判为COVID-19。
  • 中心或弥漫分布、单侧分布、非树芽结节及树芽结节在机化性肺炎中更常见。
  • RSNA COVID-19分类中典型表现占比:COVID-19 70%、流感33%、机化性肺炎47%。

关键影像表现/征象

  • COVID-19与流感在14种CT征象中的7种差异显著(p<.05),与机化性肺炎在4种征象上差异显著(p<.05)。
  • 中心或弥漫分布见于10%和7%的COVID-19病例,而机化性肺炎分别为20%和21%。
  • 单侧分布见于1%的COVID-19病例,机化性肺炎为7%。
  • 非树芽结节见于32%的COVID-19病例,机化性肺炎为53%;树芽结节见于6%的COVID-19病例,机化性肺炎为14%。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • RSNA COVID-19分类典型表现占比:COVID-19 70%、流感33%、机化性肺炎47%(p<.001)。
  • 倾向诊断与真实诊断一致的平均百分比:COVID-19 44%、流感29%、机化性肺炎39%。
  • 倾向诊断的平均诊断准确性:COVID-19肺炎70%,流感与机化性肺炎均为68%。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 阅片时需注意COVID-19与机化性肺炎的CT重叠,尤其在肿瘤治疗或自身免疫病等机化性肺炎潜在病因比例较高的临床场景中。
  • 中心或弥漫分布、单侧分布、非树芽结节及树芽结节更倾向机化性肺炎而非COVID-19。
  • 仅凭CT鉴别COVID-19、流感与机化性肺炎准确性有限,应结合临床与实验室检查。

局限性

  • 回顾性研究设计。
  • 样本为三种诊断各50例的等比例选取,可能不完全反映真实临床患病比例。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND. Previous studies compared CT findings of COVID-19 pneumonia with those of other infections; however, to our knowledge, no studies to date have included noninfectious organizing pneumonia (OP) for comparison. OBJECTIVE. The objectives of this study were to compare chest CT features of COVID-19, influenza, and OP using a multireader design and to assess the performance of radiologists in distinguishing between these conditions. METHODS. This retrospective study included 150 chest CT examinations in 150 patients (mean [± SD] age, 58 ± 16 years) with a diagnosis of COVID-19, influenza, or non-infectious OP (50 randomly selected abnormal CT examinations per diagnosis). Six thoracic radiologists independently assessed CT examinations for 14 individual CT findings and for Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) COVID-19 category and recorded a favored diagnosis. The CT characteristics of the three diagnoses were compared using random-effects models; the diagnostic performance of the readers was assessed. RESULTS. COVID-19 pneumonia was significantly different (p < .05) from influenza pneumonia for seven of 14 chest CT findings, although it was different (p < .05) from OP for four of 14 findings (central or diffuse distribution was seen in 10% and 7% of COVID-19 cases, respectively, vs 20% and 21% of OP cases, respectively; unilateral distribution was seen in 1% of COVID-19 cases vs 7% of OP cases; non-tree-in-bud nodules was seen in 32% of COVID-19 cases vs 53% of OP cases; tree-in-bud nodules were seen in 6% of COVID-19 cases vs 14% of OP cases). A total of 70% of cases of COVID-19, 33% of influenza cases, and 47% of OP cases had typical findings according to RSNA COVID-19 category assessment (p < .001). The mean percentage of correct favored diagnoses compared with actual diagnoses was 44% for COVID-19, 29% for influenza, and 39% for OP. The mean diagnostic accuracy of favored diagnoses was 70% for COVID-19 pneumonia and 68% for both influenza and OP. CONCLUSION. CT findings of COVID-19 substantially overlap with those of influenza and, to a greater extent, those of OP. The diagnostic accuracy of the radiologists was low in a study sample that contained equal proportions of these three types of pneumonia. CLINICAL IMPACT. Recognized challenges in diagnosing COVID-19 by CT are furthered by the strong overlap observed between the appearances of COVID-19 and OP on CT. This challenge may be particularly evident in clinical settings in which there are substantial proportions of patients with potential causes of OP such as ongoing cancer therapy or autoimmune conditions.

来源:AJR Am J Roentgenol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Garrana SH, Som A, Ndakwah GS, et al. Comparison of Chest CT Findings of COVID-19, Influenza, and Organizing Pneumonia: A Multireader Study. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2021. PMID: 33852360. doi:10.2214/AJR.21.25640

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。