美国多机构研究:COVID-19胸部X线敏感性的决定因素
回顾性多机构研究纳入254例RT-PCR确诊COVID-19+患者与254例年龄性别匹配的COVID-19-对照,评估胸部X线和CT随时间变化的敏感性、特异性及假阴性决定因素。COVID-19+患者X线敏感性和病变严重度随时间增加,特异性随时间下降;连续X线的AUC升高并接近CT。正常和轻度严重度的X线表现是假阴性的最大因素。
要点
- COVID-19+患者胸部X线敏感性随时间增加,≤2天为55%,>11天为79%。
- 连续X线检查AUC从第一次0.79升至第二次0.87,第二次接近CT的0.92。
- 假阴性X线中40%为正常表现,87%为正常或轻度严重度表现。
关键影像表现/征象
- COVID-19+患者胸部X线病变严重度随时间增加(p<0.001)。
- COVID-19+患者胸部X线敏感性随时间增加(从≤2天的55%到>11天的79%,p<0.001)。
- COVID-19-对照胸部X线特异性随时间下降(从83%到70%,p=0.02)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 胸部X线敏感性:≤2天为55%,>11天为79%。
- 胸部X线特异性:随时间从83%下降至70%。
- 第一次胸部X线、第二次胸部X线和胸部CT的COVID-19敏感性分别为73%、83%和88%,特异性分别为80%、73%和77%。
- 连续胸部X线AUC:第一次0.79,第二次0.87(p=0.02);第二次胸部X线与CT的AUC(0.92)比较p=0.11。
- 假阴性胸部X线中40%为正常表现,87%为正常或轻度严重度表现;年轻年龄和非洲裔美国人种族增加假阴性率。
局限性
- 原文未述局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To evaluate the sensitivity, specificity, and severity of chest x-rays (CXR) and chest CTs over time in confirmed COVID-19+ and COVID-19- patients and to evaluate determinants of false negatives.
METHODS: In a retrospective multi-institutional study, 254 RT-PCR verified COVID-19+ patients with at least one CXR or chest CT were compared with 254 age- and gender-matched COVID-19- controls. CXR severity, sensitivity, and specificity were determined with respect to time after onset of symptoms; sensitivity and specificity for chest CTs without time stratification. Performance of serial CXRs against CTs was determined by comparing area under the receiver operating characteristic curves (AUC). A multivariable logistic regression analysis was performed to assess factors related to false negative CXR.
RESULTS: COVID-19+ CXR severity and sensitivity increased with time (from sensitivity of 55% at ≤2 days to 79% at >11 days; p<0.001 for trends of both severity and sensitivity) whereas CXR specificity decreased over time (from 83% to 70%, p=0.02). Serial CXR demonstrated increase in AUC (first CXR AUC=0.79, second CXR=0.87, p=0.02), and second CXR approached the accuracy of CT (AUC=0.92, p=0.11). COVID-19 sensitivity of first CXR, second CXR, and CT was 73%, 83%, and 88%, whereas specificity was 80%, 73%, and 77%, respectively. Normal and mild severity CXR findings were the largest factor behind false-negative CXRs (40% normal and 87% combined normal/mild). Young age and African-American ethnicity increased false negative rates.
CONCLUSION: CXR sensitivity in COVID-19 detection increases with time, and serial CXRs of COVID-19+ patients has accuracy approaching that of chest CT.
引用
- Stephanie S, Shum T, Cleveland H, et al. Determinants of Chest X-Ray Sensitivity for COVID- 19: A Multi-Institutional Study in the United States. Radiol Cardiothorac Imaging. 2020. PMID: 33778628. doi:10.1148/ryct.2020200337
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。