文献速递技术与安全

放射学界如何讨论人工智能的益处与局限:系统性话语分析

How does the radiology community discuss the benefits and limitations of artificial intelligence for their work? A systematic discourse analysis.
PubMed 文献 · Eur J Radiol · 2021-01-26

该研究对2020年4月至8月间收集的200条社交媒体帖子进行定性系统性话语分析,旨在分析放射学界如何讨论人工智能概念、感知其益处并反思其局限。结果显示,讨论活跃但常将人工智能作为笼统术语且缺乏对语境和时间焦点的精确性,讨论在乐观与悲观之间有所分裂,后者考虑更广泛的社会、伦理和法律因素。作者结论认为,话语的进一步精确化可能带来更具建设性的对话,乐观与悲观之间的分裂需要两种视角的持续交流与综合。

要点

  • 放射学界社交媒体讨论中人工智能常被当作笼统术语,缺乏对研究或临床等语境及当前或未来等时间焦点的精确界定。
  • 讨论在乐观与悲观之间有所分裂,悲观视角考虑的社会、伦理和法律因素范围比乐观视角更广。
  • 关于商业模式等实践性话题的讨论仍然罕见,但可能对人工智能在临床实践中的有效实施至关重要。

局限性

  • 话语常将人工智能作为笼统术语,缺乏对语境(如研究、临床)和时间焦点(如当前人工智能、未来人工智能)的精确性。
  • 话语在乐观与悲观之间有所分裂,悲观视角考虑的社会、伦理和法律因素范围比乐观视角更广。
  • 实践性对话(如商业模式)仍然罕见。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: We aimed to systematically analyse how the radiology community discusses the concept of artificial intelligence (AI), perceives its benefits, and reflects on its limitations.

METHODS: We conducted a qualitative, systematic discourse analysis on 200 social-media posts collected over a period of five months (April-August 2020).

RESULTS: The discourse on AI is active, albeit often referring to AI as an umbrella term and lacking precision on the context (e.g. research, clinical) and the temporal focus (e.g. current AI, future AI). The discourse is also somewhat split between optimism and pessimism. The latter considers a wider range of social, ethical and legal factors than the former, which tends to focus on concrete technologies and their functionalities.

CONCLUSIONS: Further precision in the discourse could lead to more constructive conversations around AI. The split between optimism and pessimism calls for a constant exchange and synthesis between the two perspectives. Practical conversations (e.g. business models) remain rare, but may be crucial for an effective implementation of AI in clinical practice.

来源:Eur J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Kim B, Koopmanschap I, Mehrizi MHR, et al. How does the radiology community discuss the benefits and limitations of artificial intelligence for their work? A systematic discourse analysis. Eur J Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33556686. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2021.109566

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。