CT转诊指南覆盖所有临床场景吗?EURO-2000与ESR iGuide的比较
该研究回顾性匹配三家医院2018年1月头、胸、腹盆及脊柱CT申请单的临床指征与EURO-2000指南及ESR iGuide,分析6812份申请对应7217次CT检查。EURO-2000覆盖65%的临床场景,ESR iGuide覆盖81%;EURO-2000判定46%为「不合理检查」,ESR iGuide为23%(p < 0.001)。两指南均未覆盖大量常见临床场景,覆盖比例因中心、身体部位和处方者专科而异。
要点
- ESR iGuide覆盖81%的CT转诊临床场景,高于EURO-2000的65%。
- EURO-2000判定46%检查为「不合理」,ESR iGuide为23%(p < 0.001)。
- 两指南对脊柱和头部的场景覆盖优于腹部和胸部,覆盖比例因中心和处方者专科而异。
诊断标准与关键数值
- EURO-2000指南覆盖65%的临床场景,ESR iGuide覆盖81%。
- 按EURO-2000指南判定「不合理检查」的比例为46%,按ESR iGuide为23%(p < 0.001)。
- 指南覆盖的临床场景比例在中心间和身体部位间差异有统计学意义(p < 0.001),并因处方者专科而异(p值范围< 0.001至0.531)。
- 两指南对脊柱和头部的临床场景覆盖优于腹部和胸部。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To investigate the proportion of clinical scenarios covered by EURO-2000 Guidelines and ESR iGuide, and assess compliance with both guidelines.
METHODS: The clinical indication on archived request forms for head, chest, abdomen-pelvis, and spine CT examinations performed in three hospitals in January 2018 was retrospectively matched with EURO-2000 Guidelines and ESR iGuide. For clinical scenarios addressed in the guidelines, the compliance with the guidelines was assessed. Analysis was performed on pooled data from the three centres and further stratified by centre, body region, and prescriber's specialisation. The differences in categorical data distributions between centres, body regions, and prescribers' specialisations were assessed with paired McNemar's χ2 tests.
RESULTS: A total of 6,812 requests for 7,217 CT examinations were analysed. Sixty-five percent of clinical situations that lead to prescribing CT examinations were addressed in EURO-2000 Guidelines compared with 81% for ESR iGuide. Proportions of clinical scenarios covered by the guidelines were statistically different between centres and body regions (p < 0.001) and varied according to prescribers' specialisations (p ranging from < 0.001 to 0.531). Both EURO-2000 Guidelines and ESR iGuide encompassed more clinical scenarios in certain body regions, favouring, e.g. spine and head over abdomen and chest. The proportion of "unjustified examinations" was greater according to EURO-2000 Guidelines (46%) than ESR iGuide (23%) (p < 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS: Both EURO-2000 Guidelines and ESR iGuide do not address numerous common clinical scenarios. The proportions of scenarios addressed differ according to the centre, body region, and prescribers' specialisation. Any estimation of compliance with referral guidelines is therefore of relative significance.
KEY POINTS: • ESR iGuide performs better than earlier EURO-2000 Guidelines for the coverage of all possible clinical scenarios leading to CT referrals. • Differences in coverage of clinical scenarios by both referral guidelines are observed for different body regions and/or prescribers' subspecialties. • As referral guidelines are incomplete, any estimation of justified or unjustified CT requests is of relative significance.
引用
- Appiah V, Taylor S, Vaulet T, et al. Are referral guidelines for CT examinations addressing all clinical scenarios? A comparison of EURO-2000 Guidelines and ESR iGuide. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33569623. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-07736-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。