乳腺筛查钼靶阅片量的最优标准:来自英国国家乳腺筛查项目的证据
该研究基于英国国家乳腺筛查项目2014年4月至2017年3月的常规记录,分析759名阅片者每年阅片量与筛查性能的关系。结果显示,年阅片量从2000例增至10000例时,召回阳性预测值从12.9%升至17.0%,召回率从5.8%降至4.5%,癌症检出率无变化。结论认为阳性预测值随年阅片总量增加而提高,源于召回减少而癌症检出数不变。
要点
- 年阅片量2000、5000、10000例对应的召回阳性预测值分别为12.9%、14.4%、17.0%。
- 年阅片量增加时召回率从5.8%降至4.5%,癌症检出率无变化(7.6%至7.7%)。
- 咨询放射技师较咨询放射科医生召回率更高、阳性预测值更低(未校正OR 1.105,p=0.012;OR 0.874,p=0.002)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 年阅片2000、5000、10000例的阅片者召回阳性预测值分别为12.9%、14.4%、17.0%。
- 年阅片2000、5000、10000例的阅片者召回率分别为5.8%、5.3%、4.5%。
- 年阅片2000、5000、10000例的阅片者癌症检出率分别为7.6%、7.6%、7.7%。
- 咨询放射技师较咨询放射科医生召回率更高(未校正OR 1.105,p=0.012),阳性预测值更低(未校正OR 0.874,p=0.002)。
- 癌症检出率在不同阅片者职业组间无差异。
局限性
- 咨询放射技师与咨询放射科医生在召回率和阳性预测值上的差异未校正阅片经验年限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Minimum caseload standards for professionals examining breast screening mammograms vary from 480 (US) to 5000 (Europe). We measured the relationship between the number of women's mammograms examined per year and reader performance.
METHODS: We extracted routine records from the English NHS Breast Screening Programme for readers examining between 1000 and 45,000 mammograms between April 2014 and March 2017. We measured the relationship between the volume of cases read and screening performance (cancer detection rate, recall rate, positive predictive value of recall (PPV) and discrepant cancers) using linear logistic regression. We also examined the effect of reader occupational group on performance.
RESULTS: In total, 759 eligible mammography readers (445 consultant radiologists, 235 radiography advanced practitioners, 79 consultant radiographers) examined 6.1 million women's mammograms during the study period. PPV increased from 12.9 to 14.4 to 17.0% for readers examining 2000, 5000 and 10000 cases per year respectively. This was driven by decreases in recall rates from 5.8 to 5.3 to 4.5 with increasing volume read, and no change in cancer detection rate (from 7.6 to 7.6 to 7.7). There was no difference in cancer detection rate with reader occupational group. Consultant radiographers had higher recall rate and lower PPV compared to radiologists (OR 1.105, p = 0.012; OR 0.874, p = 0.002, unadjusted).
CONCLUSION: Positive predictive value of screening increases with the total volume of cases examined per reader, through decreases in numbers of cases recalled with no concurrent change in numbers of cancers detected.
KEY POINTS: • In the English Breast Screening Programme, readers who examined a larger number of cases per year had a higher positive predictive value, because they recalled fewer women for further tests but detected the same number of cancers. • Reader type did not affect cancer detection rate, but consultant radiographers had a higher recall rate and lower positive predictive value than consultant radiologists, although this was not adjusted for length of experience.
引用
- Cornford E, Cheung S, Press M, et al. Optimum screening mammography reading volumes: evidence from the NHS Breast Screening Programme. Eur Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33630161. doi:10.1007/s00330-021-07754-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。