儿童膀胱输尿管反流CEVUS检查中远端输尿管及输尿管膀胱连接部显示评估
回顾性分析2018年6月至2019年3月34例CEVUS检出VUR的患儿,两位儿科放射科医师对67个肾单位进行3级评分评估远端输尿管及输尿管膀胱连接部显示情况。结果示反流肾单位中输尿管膀胱连接部清晰显示率仅9.6%~23.1%,远端输尿管清晰显示率26.9%~51.9%,读者间一致性分别为缺乏一致(Kappa -0.29)和中等一致(Kappa 0.43)。
要点
- CEVUS检出VUR时,输尿管膀胱连接部常不能清晰显示,读者1仅5/52(9.6%)清晰,读者2仅12/52(23.1%)清晰。
- 远端输尿管清晰显示率读者1为14/52(26.9%),读者2为27/52(51.9%),读者间一致性中等(Kappa 0.43)。
- 认识CEVUS对远端输尿管及输尿管膀胱连接部显示的局限性很重要,可能影响VUR手术评估。
关键影像表现/征象
- 两位读者均未检出输尿管旁憩室,均检出1个输尿管囊肿。
- 读者1判断52个反流肾单位中肾集合系统重复13个,读者2判断11个。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 采用3级评分(清晰、有限、缺失)评估远端输尿管、输尿管膀胱连接部、输尿管重复、输尿管旁憩室及输尿管囊肿的显示。
- 输尿管膀胱连接部清晰显示:读者1为5/52(9.6%),读者2为12/52(23.1%),清晰与有限或缺失比较的Kappa为-0.29(CI -0.25, 0.21),读者间缺乏一致。
- 远端输尿管清晰显示:读者1为14/52(26.9%),读者2为27/52(51.9%),清晰与有限或缺失比较的Kappa为0.43(CI 0.22, 0.64),读者间中等一致。
- 输尿管重复清晰显示:读者1为9/52(17.3%),读者2为9/52(17.3%),清晰与有限或缺失比较的Kappa为0.87(CI 0.68, 1),读者间高度一致。
临床应用与阅片要点
- CEVUS报告VUR时需注意远端输尿管及输尿管膀胱连接部可能显示不清,阅片时应描述其显示程度。
- 评估VUR手术方案时,应意识到CEVUS对输尿管膀胱连接部解剖细节显示的局限性。
局限性
- 本研究为回顾性研究。
- 输尿管膀胱连接部清晰与有限或缺失比较的Kappa为-0.29(CI -0.25, 0.21),读者间缺乏一致。
- 原文结论指出CEVUS常不能清晰显示远端输尿管及输尿管膀胱连接部,认识这一局限性很重要。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Contrast-enhanced voiding urosonography (CEVUS) uses intravesically administered microbubble contrast to detect vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) and urethral anomalies with ultrasound. Multiple studies have suggested CEVUS can replace voiding cystourethrogram (VCUG) as a radiation-free alternative. Analysis of the ureterovesical junction and ureters on VCUG documenting the ureterovesical junction position, ureteral duplication, periureteral diverticula and ureteroceles is important as anatomical variations may affect management and surgical approach.
OBJECTIVE: Our purpose was to assess distal ureteral and ureterovesical junction region visualization in children with VUR detected on CEVUS.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: CEVUS studies performed between June 2018 and March 2019 with reported VUR were retrospectively reviewed by two pediatric radiologists to confirm VUR and to qualitatively assess the ureterovesical junction region for each renal moiety using a 3-point scale for clear, limited or absent visualization of the distal ureter, ureterovesical junction, ureteral duplication, periureteral diverticula and ureteroceles.
RESULTS: Thirty-four studies with VUR on CEVUS were identified. Sixty-seven renal moieties were evaluated including a solitary kidney in one child. VUR was detected in 52 moieties by reader 1 and in 53 by reader 2. A single moiety with discrepancy between readers regarding VUR was excluded from statistical analysis. No diverticula were detected by either reader and one ureterocele was detected by both readers. Visualization of the ureterovesical junction was described as clear in 5/52, limited in 14/52 and absent in 33/52 refluxing renal moieties by reader 1 and as clear in 12/52, limited in 20/52 and absent in 20/52 by reader 2. The ureterovesical junction was clearly visualized in 5/52 (9.6%) by reader 1 and 12/52 (23.1%) by reader 2. The Kappa value of -0.29 (confidence interval [CI] -0.25, 0.21) reveals a lack of agreement between the readers for clear versus limited or absent ureterovesical junction visualization. Distal ureteral visualization was described as clear in 14/52, limited in 16/52 and absent in 22/52 refluxing renal moieties by reader 1 and as clear in 27/52, limited in 7/52 and absent in 18/52 by reader 2. The distal ureter was clearly visualized in 14/52 (26.9%) by reader 1 and 27/52 (51.9%) by reader 2. The Kappa of 0.43 (CI 0.22, 0.64) reveals moderate agreement between the readers for clear versus limited or absent distal ureteral visualization. Duplication of the renal collecting system was identified in 13/52 refluxing kidneys by reader 1 and 11/52 refluxing kidneys by reader 2. Visualization of ureteral duplication was described as clear in 9, limited in 4 and absent in 39 of 52 refluxing renal moieties by reader 1 and as clear in 9, limited in 2 and absent in 41 by reader 2. Ureteral duplication was clearly visualized in 9/52 (17.3%) by reader 1 and 9/52 (17.3%) by reader 2. Kappa of 0.87 (CI 0.68, 1) reveals high agreement between the readers for clear versus limited or absent identification of ureteral duplication.
CONCLUSION: The distal ureter and ureterovesical junction region frequently are not clearly visualized in refluxing renal moieties on CEVUS. Awareness of this limitation is important as there may be implications when evaluating patients for surgical management of VUR.
引用
- Benya EC, Prendergast FM, Liu DB, et al. Assessment of distal ureteral and ureterovesical junction visualization on contrast-enhanced voiding urosonography. Pediatr Radiol. 2021. PMID: 33576846. doi:10.1007/s00247-021-04979-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。