动态动脉自旋标记MRA与时间分辨对比增强MRA是否适用于伽玛刀放射外科治疗后脑动静脉畸形闭塞的确认
前瞻性研究纳入30例伽玛刀术后行DSA确认闭塞的脑动静脉畸形患者,其中29例同时行动脉自旋标记MRA与对比增强时间分辨MRA,由2名观察者盲法独立评估有无残留畸形血管巢。两种MRA序列单独应用特异度与阳性预测值均为100%,但敏感度分别为88%和77%,联合评估时敏感度与阴性预测值均达100%,AUC=1,κ=1。
要点
- 动脉自旋标记MRA与对比增强时间分辨MRA单独评估残留动静脉畸形的特异度与阳性预测值均为100%。
- 联合两种MRA序列评估时敏感度与阴性预测值均升至100%,AUC=1,κ=1。
- MRA总扫描时间为9分17秒。
诊断标准与关键数值
- DSA检出残留动静脉畸形9例,闭塞率69%。
- 动脉自旋标记MRA:敏感度88%,特异度100%,阳性预测值100%,阴性预测值95%,因1例假阴性。
- 对比增强时间分辨MRA:敏感度77%,特异度100%,阳性预测值100%,阴性预测值90%,因2例假阴性。
- 两种序列联合评估:敏感度100%,阴性预测值100%,AUC=1(P<.001),κ=1(P<.001)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Intra-arterial DSA has been traditionally used for confirmation of cure following gamma knife radiosurgery for AVMs. Our aim was to evaluate whether 4D arterial spin-labeling MRA and contrast-enhanced time-resolved MRA in combination can be an alternative to DSA for confirmation of AVM obliteration following gamma knife radiosurgery.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this prospective study, 30 patients undergoing DSA for confirmation of obliteration following gamma knife radiosurgery for AVMs (criterion standard) also underwent MRA, including arterial spin-labeling MRA and contrast-enhanced time-resolved MRA. One dataset was technically unsatisfactory, and the case was excluded. The DSA and MRA datasets of 29 patients were independently and blindly evaluated by 2 observers regarding the presence/absence of residual AVMs.
RESULTS: The mean time between gamma knife radiosurgery and follow-up DSA/MRA was 53 months (95% CI, 42-64 months; range, 22-168 months). MRA total scanning time was 9 minutes and 17 seconds. Residual AVMs were detected on DSA in 9 subjects (obliteration rate = 69%). All residual AVMs were detected on at least 1 MRA sequence. Arterial spin-labeling MRA and contrast-enhanced time-resolved MRA showed excellent specificity and positive predictive values individually (100%). However, their sensitivity and negative predictive values were suboptimal due to 1 false-negative with arterial spin-labeling MRA and 2 with contrast-enhanced time-resolved MRA (sensitivity = 88% and 77%, negative predictive values = 95% and 90%, respectively). Both sensitivity and negative predictive values increased to 100% if a composite assessment of both MRA sequences was performed. Diagnostic accuracy (receiver operating characteristic) and agreement (κ) are maximized using arterial spin-labeling MRA and contrast-enhanced time-resolved MRA in combination (area under receiver operating characteristic curve = 1, P < .001; κ = 1, P < .001, respectively).
CONCLUSIONS: Combining arterial spin-labeling MRA with contrast-enhanced time-resolved MRA holds promise as an alternative to DSA for confirmation of obliteration following gamma knife radiosurgery for brain AVMs, having provided 100% sensitivity and specificity in the study. Their combined use also enables reliable characterization of residual lesions.
引用
- Rojas-Villabona A, Pizzini FB, Solbach T, et al. Are Dynamic Arterial Spin-Labeling MRA and Time-Resolved Contrast-Enhanced MRA Suited for Confirmation of Obliteration following Gamma Knife Radiosurgery of Brain Arteriovenous Malformations? AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2021. PMID: 33541896. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A6990
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。