颅内动脉瘤外科或血管内治疗的血管造影结果:系统综述与观察者间可靠性研究
本研究通过两项系统综述筛选适用于夹闭与栓塞的简单3分类量表,并让19名不同背景评分者对60例动脉瘤血管造影(夹闭30例、栓塞30例)独立评估闭塞程度及随访管理。评分者间一致性αK=0.76(95%CI 0.67-0.83),闭塞分级与管理决策强相关(Cramer's V 0.80±0.12)。结论为该3点量表可靠性足以用于报告动脉瘤治疗结果或随机对照试验中的疗效评估。
要点
- 系统综述共发现70种分级量表,其可靠性异质(kappa值0.12至1.00)。
- 3点闭塞分级在夹闭与栓塞动脉瘤中评分者间一致性αK=0.76(95%CI 0.67-0.83)。
- 血管造影分级与随访管理决策强相关(Cramer's V 0.80±0.12)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者结论认为该简单3点量表可靠性足以用于报告动脉瘤治疗结果或用于比较性随机试验中的疗效评估。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Results of surgical or endovascular treatment of intracranial aneurysms are often assessed using angiography. A reliable method to report results irrespective of treatment modality is needed to enable comparisons. Our goals were to systematically review existing classification systems, and to propose a 3-point classification applicable to both treatments and assess its reliability.
METHODS: We conducted two systematic reviews on classification systems of angiographic results after clipping or coiling to select a simple 3-category scale that could apply to both treatments. We then circulated an electronic portfolio of angiograms of clipped (n=30) or coiled (n=30) aneurysms, and asked raters to evaluate the degree of occlusion using this scale. Raters were also asked to choose an appropriate follow-up management for each patient based on the degree of occlusion. Agreement was assessed using Krippendorff's α statistics (αK), and relationship between occlusion grade and clinical management was analyzed using Fisher's exact and Cramer's V tests.
RESULTS: The systematic reviews found 70 different grading scales with heterogeneous reliability (kappa values from 0.12 to 1.00). The 60-patient portfolio was independently evaluated by 19 raters of diverse backgrounds (neurosurgery, radiology, and neurology) and experience. There was substantial agreement (αK=0.76, 95%CI, 0.67-0.83) between raters, regardless of background, experience, or treatment used. Intra-rater agreement ranged from moderate to almost perfect. A strong relationship was found between angiographic grades and management decisions (Cramer's V: 0.80±0.12).
CONCLUSION: A simple 3-point scale demonstrated sufficient reliability to be used in reporting aneurysm treatments or in evaluating treatment results in comparative randomized trials.
引用
- Benomar A, Farzin B, Volders D, et al. Angiographic results of surgical or endovascular treatment of intracranial aneurysms: a systematic review and inter-observer reliability study. Neuroradiology. 2021. PMID: 33625550. doi:10.1007/s00234-021-02676-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。