COVID-19肺炎患者高分辨率计算机断层扫描表现的阅片者间一致性:一项多阅片者研究
回顾性纳入77例轻症COVID-19肺炎患者的HRCT,由3名放射科医师独立评估磨玻璃影、实变和铺路石征的范围评分及机化性肺炎模式。多数特征的一致性为中等到高度,总肺评分>6是短期进展为重症的独立预测因子(OR 9-53.19),实变和机化性肺炎模式的一致性受阅片者经验影响。
要点
- 总肺评分>6的阅片者间一致性为高度(k=0.69),且为短期重症的独立预测因子。
- 实变总特征评分>2和机化性肺炎模式仅在两名胸部影像专科医师间呈现高度和中度一致性。
- 实变评分>2和机化性肺炎模式分别对R2和R1是重症的独立预测因子。
关键影像表现/征象
- 多数HRCT特征显示高度阅片者间一致性,包括总肺评分>6(k=0.69)。
- 实变总特征评分>2仅在R1与R2之间呈高度一致性,机化性肺炎模式仅在R1与R2之间呈中度一致性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 总肺评分>6为短期发生重症的独立预测因子,不受阅片者影响(OR 9-53.19)。
- 实变总特征评分>2对R2是重症的独立预测因子(OR 4.87)。
- 机化性肺炎模式对R1是重症的独立预测因子(OR 6)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 总肺评分>6在不同经验阅片者间一致性高度(k=0.69),可作为报告COVID-19肺炎肺部受累范围的可靠指标。
- 实变和机化性肺炎模式的判读一致性依赖阅片者经验,报告时需注意阅片者资历对判断的影响。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To investigate the inter-reader agreement in assessing high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) features of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pneumonia.
METHOD: Seventy-seven consecutive patients (mean age, 64 ± 15 years) with mild COVID-19 pneumonia that underwent HRCT were retrospectively included. Three radiologists [two devoted to thoracic imaging (R1, R2), and one generalist (R3)] on a per-examination basis independently assessed ground-glass opacity (GGO), consolidation, and crazy-paving pattern. The extent of each feature (total feature score, TFS) was semi-quantitatively assessed, and each TFS summed up to obtain total lung score (TLS). Presence of organizing pneumonia (OP) pattern was also recorded. The inter-reader agreement was calculated with Cohen's Kappa (k) and Free-Marginal Multirater k. Multivariable analysis was run to determine whether imaging features were predictive of short-term evolution to severe disease (need for ventilation).
RESULTS: Most features showed substantial inter-reader agreement, including TLS > 6 (k = 0.69), which was an independent predictor of short-term occurrence of severe disease, regardless of the reader (OR 9-53.19). Consolidation TFS > 2 and OP pattern showed substantial and moderate agreement, respectively, only when comparing R1 and R2. Consolidation TFS > 2 and OP pattern were independent predictors of severe disease for R2 (OR 4.87) and R1 (OR 6), respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: The inter-reader agreement for most HRCT features of COVID-19 pneumonia ranges moderate-to-substantial, though it depends on readers' experience in the case of consolidation and OP pattern.
引用
- Cereser L, Girometti R, Da Re J, et al. Inter-reader agreement of high-resolution computed tomography findings in patients with COVID-19 pneumonia: A multi-reader study. Radiol Med. 2021. PMID: 33389557. doi:10.1007/s11547-020-01320-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。