基于共识的痛风病变超声半定量评分系统:OMERACT德尔菲法及网络信度练习结果
风湿病学家通过德尔菲法重新定义痛风石聚合物并制定痛风石、双轨征和聚合物的半定量超声评分系统(0-3分),共识阈值设为>75%同意。基于静态超声图像的网络信度练习显示,聚合物重新定义的组内和组间信度良好(κ值分别为0.71和0.61),评分系统对所有病变的信度良好,组内信度(κ值0.74-0.80)略高于组间信度(κ值0.61-0.67)。
要点
- 痛风石、双轨征和聚合物可采用0-3分半定量超声评分,静态图像信度良好。
- 聚合物重新定义后组内信度κ=0.71、组间信度κ=0.61。
- 评分系统组内信度κ=0.74-0.80,组间信度κ=0.61-0.67。
关键影像表现/征象
- 聚合物重新定义经过三轮德尔菲法达成共识,但需要 overarching principle 用于患者评分。
- 半定量超声评分系统经过两轮德尔菲法制定,涵盖痛风石、双轨征和聚合物,评分范围为0-3分。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 聚合物重新定义的组内信度κ值为0.71,组间信度κ值为0.61。
- 评分系统组内信度κ值为0.74-0.80,组间信度κ值为0.61-0.67。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在静态超声图像上,重新定义的聚合物和半定量评分系统均显示出良好信度,可用于日常阅片和报告评分。
- 评分系统对痛风石、双轨征和聚合物的组内信度(κ值0.74-0.80)略高于组间信度(κ值0.61-0.67)。
局限性
- 信度评估基于静态图像练习,尚未在患者中评分验证,原文指出下一步需在患者中评估评分信度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to develop (1) a new ultrasound definition for aggregates and (2) a semi-quantitative ultrasound scoring system (0-3) for tophus, double contour and aggregates. Furthermore, the intra- and inter-reader reliabilities of both the re-defined aggregates and the semi-quantitative scoring system were assessed using static image exercises.
METHODS: Thirty-seven rheumatologists were invited. A Delphi process was used for re-defining aggregates and for selecting a semi-quantitative scoring system with >75% agreement obligate for reaching consensus. Subsequently, a web-based exercise on static ultrasound images was conducted in order to assess the reliability of both the re-defined aggregates and the semi-quantitative scoring system.
RESULTS: Twenty rheumatologists contributed to all rounds of the Delphi and image exercises. A consensual re-definition of aggregates was obtained after three Delphi rounds but needed an overarching principle for scoring aggregates in patients. A consensus-based semi-quantitative ultrasound scoring system for gout lesions was developed after two Delphi rounds. The re-definition of aggregates showed good intra- and inter-reader reliability (κ-values 0.71 and 0.61). The reliabilities of the scoring system were good for all lesions with slightly higher intra-reader (κ-values 0.74-0.80) than inter-reader reliabilities (κ-values 0.61-0.67).
CONCLUSION: A re-definition of aggregates was obtained with a good reliability when assessing static images. The first consensus-based semi-quantitative ultrasound scoring system for gout-specific lesions was developed with good inter- and intra-reader reliability for all lesions when tested in static images. The next step is to assess the reliabilities when scoring lesions in patients.
引用
- Christiansen SN, Filippou G, Scirè CA, et al. Consensus-based semi-quantitative ultrasound scoring system for gout lesions: Results of an OMERACT Delphi process and web-reliability exercise. Semin Arthritis Rheum. 2021. PMID: 33468347. doi:10.1016/j.semarthrit.2020.11.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。