用于评估数字乳腺X线摄影图像质量的候选工具的开发与内容效度评价:一项混合方法研究
本研究通过访谈五国十五名乳腺影像专家,使用四十五例含有四十四处病灶(三十例癌、十四处良性发现)和五例正常病例的乳腺X线图像,识别受图像质量影响的临床相关特征,并开发候选评估工具。初步形成二十九个条目,经内容效度指数评价后删除九条、修订或合并五条,最终保留十八条。作者认为该候选工具可能用于描述图像质量变化对数字乳腺X线摄影的临床相关影响。
要点
- 候选工具包含十八个条目,覆盖从访谈中提炼的十二个内容领域。
- 十四条目内容效度指数≥0.78(改良Kappa>0.74),一条为良好,十四条为一般或差。
- 工具旨在评估图像质量变化对乳腺结构及病灶可见性的临床相关影响。
核心结论
- 通过混合方法开发了一个候选工具,可能用于描述图像质量变化对数字乳腺X线摄影的临床相关影响。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究:访谈五国十五名乳腺影像专家,展示四十五例乳腺X线病例(含四十四处病灶:三十例癌、十四处良性发现,以及五例正常病例),采用改编的定向内容分析法;初步条目经内容效度指数和改良Kappa指数评价。
关键影像表现/征象
- 访谈识别出十二个内容领域,代表数字乳腺X线摄影图像质量的内容。
- 十二个内容领域转化为二十九个初步条目。
- 二十九个条目中十四条内容效度指数≥0.78(改良Kappa>0.74),一条内容效度指数<0.78(改良Kappa 0.60–0.74),十四条内容效度指数<0.78(改良Kappa≤0.59)。
- 最终删除九条、修订或合并五条,保留十八条。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 内容效度指数≥0.78且改良Kappa>0.74为优秀。
- 内容效度指数<0.78且改良Kappa 0.60–0.74为良好。
- 内容效度指数<0.78且改良Kappa≤0.59为一般或差。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To develop a candidate instrument to assess image quality in digital mammography, by identifying clinically relevant features in images that are affected by lower image quality.
METHODS: Interviews with fifteen expert breast radiologists from five countries were conducted and analysed by using adapted directed content analysis. During these interviews, 45 mammographic cases, containing 44 lesions (30 cancers, 14 benign findings), and 5 normal cases, were shown with varying image quality. The interviews were performed to identify the structures from breast tissue and lesions relevant for image interpretation, and to investigate how image quality affected the visibility of those structures. The interview findings were used to develop tentative items, which were evaluated in terms of wording, understandability, and ambiguity with expert breast radiologists. The relevance of the tentative items was evaluated using the content validity index (CVI) and modified kappa index (k*).
RESULTS: Twelve content areas, representing the content of image quality in digital mammography, emerged from the interviews and were converted into 29 tentative items. Fourteen of these items demonstrated excellent CVI ≥ 0.78 (k* > 0.74), one showed good CVI < 0.78 (0.60 ≤ k* ≤ 0.74), while fourteen were of fair or poor CVI < 0.78 (k* ≤ 0.59). In total, nine items were deleted and five were revised or combined resulting in 18 items.
CONCLUSIONS: By following a mixed-method methodology, a candidate instrument was developed that may be used to characterise the clinically-relevant impact that image quality variations can have on digital mammography.
引用
- Boita J, Bolejko A, Zackrisson S, et al. Development and content validity evaluation of a candidate instrument to assess image quality in digital mammography: A mixed-method study. Eur J Radiol. 2020. PMID: 33307458. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2020.109464
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。