在韩国肺癌筛查项目基线CT筛查数据中外部验证并比较Brock模型与Lung-RADS对肺癌的筛查效能
基于韩国肺癌筛查项目(K-LUCAS)全国多中心前瞻性队列的二次分析,纳入4578名受试者、9929个肺结节(含40例肺癌),比较Brock模型2a/2b与Lung-RADS对基线低剂量CT检出结节的判别与校准效能。Brock模型2a、2b与Lung-RADS的AUC分别为0.96、0.96与0.95,差异无统计学意义(p=0.32和p=0.34);在等效5%阈值下Brock模型2b与Lung-RADS的敏感度均为87.5%、特异度分别为93.6%和93.3%,效能相近;Brock模型校准较差(均p<0.001)。
要点
- Brock模型2a与2b的AUC均为0.96,Lung-RADS为0.95,三者判别效能差异无统计学意义。
- 在5%阈值下Brock模型2b敏感度87.5%、特异度93.6%,Lung-RADS敏感度87.5%、特异度93.3%。
- 去除Lung-RADS中基于视觉评估的类别后,其特异度和阳性预测值低于Brock模型2b。
核心结论
- 对于基线CT筛查,Lung-RADS在结合基于视觉评估的类别时,诊断效能与Brock模型相似。
- Brock模型2a与2b的校准性能均较差(均p<0.001)。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为韩国肺癌筛查项目(K-LUCAS;ClinicalTrials.gov,NCT03394703)的二次分析,该队列为全国多中心前瞻性队列研究。
- 2017年4月至2018年12月对高危受试者行低剂量CT筛查,13,150名受试者中4578名符合纳入条件(中位年龄62岁;4458名男性;9929个结节,含40例肺癌)。
- 评估Brock模型2a(不含分叶征的全模型)与2b(含分叶征的全模型)的判别与校准,并与采用主观评估类别2b(b代表良性)和4X的Lung-RADS比较判别效能。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 受试者工作特征曲线下面积:Brock模型2a为0.96(IQR 0.92-0.99),Brock模型2b为0.96(IQR 0.92-0.99),Lung-RADS为0.95(IQR 0.91-0.99);Brock模型2a与Lung-RADS比较p=0.32,Brock模型2b与Lung-RADS比较p=0.34。
- 在等效5%阈值下,Brock模型2b敏感度87.5%(35/40)、特异度93.6%(9259/9889)、阳性预测值5.3%(35/665)、阴性预测值99.9%(9259/9264)。
- 在等效5%阈值下,Lung-RADS敏感度87.5%(35/40)、特异度93.3%(9222/9889)、阳性预测值5.0%(35/702)、阴性预测值99.9%(9222/9227);Brock模型2b与Lung-RADS各项比较均p>0.05。
- 去除Lung-RADS中基于视觉评估的类别后,其特异度和阳性预测值低于Brock模型2b(分别为p=0.001和p=0.02)。
- Brock模型2a与2b的校准性能均较差(均p<0.001)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文结论认为,结合视觉评估类别的Lung-RADS对基线CT筛查的诊断效能与Brock模型相似。
- 原文结论指出Brock模型校准较差(均p<0.001)。
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To validate and compare the performance of the Brock model and Lung CT Screening Reporting and Data System (Lung-RADS) on nodules detected by baseline CT screening.
METHODS: We performed a secondary analysis of the Korean Lung Cancer Screening Project (K-LUCAS; ClinicalTrials.gov , NCT03394703), a nationwide, multicenter, prospective cohort study. From April 2017 to December 2018, low-dose CT screening was performed on high-risk subjects. Discrimination and calibration of Brock models 2a and 2b (i.e., full model without and with spiculation, respectively) were assessed, and discrimination was compared with that of Lung-RADS, which utilized subjective assessment categories 2b (b stands for benign) and 4X.
RESULTS: Of the 13,150 subjects, 4578 were eligible (median age 62 years; 4458 men; 9929 nodules including 40 lung cancers). Areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve were 0.96 (IQR 0.92-0.99) for Brock model 2a, 0.96 (IQR 0.92-0.99) for Brock model 2b, and 0.95 (IQR 0.91-0.99) for Lung-RADS (p = 0.32 and p = 0.34, respectively). At an equivalent cutoff of 5%, Brock model 2b (sensitivity 87.5% [35/40]; specificity 93.6% [9259/9889]; positive predictive value [PPV] 5.3% [35/665]; negative predictive value [NPV] 99.9% [9259/9264]) and Lung-RADS (sensitivity 87.5% [35/40]; specificity 93.3% [9222/9889]; PPV 5.0% [35/702]; NPV 99.9% [9222/9227]) performed similarly well (all p > 0.05). The calibration performance of both Brock models 2a and 2b was poor (both p < 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS: Lung-RADS, when reinforced with visual assessment-based categories, has a similar diagnostic performance to the Brock model for baseline CT scans.
KEY POINTS: • Brock model 2b and Lung CT Screening Reporting and Data System (Lung-RADS) demonstrated a similar discrimination performance for lung cancer in the baseline CT screening (areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.96 vs. 0.95; p = 0.34). • When visual assessment-based categories were removed from Lung-RADS, specificity and positive predictive value were lower than those of Brock model 2b (p = 0.001 and p = 0.02, respectively). • The Brock model showed poor calibration (p < 0.001).
引用
- Kim H, Kim HY, Goo JM, et al. External validation and comparison of the Brock model and Lung-RADS for the baseline lung cancer CT screening using data from the Korean Lung Cancer Screening Project. Eur Radiol. 2020. PMID: 33241512. doi:10.1007/s00330-020-07513-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。