北美放射学会(RSNA)关于COVID-19胸部CT表现的专家共识声明与CO-RADS的比较:胸部放射科医师报告系统性能与最终用户偏好
回顾性分析279例疑似COVID-19并接受RT-PCR检测患者的胸部CT,由3名胸部放射科医师独立按RSNA与CO-RADS系统判读。两系统观察者间/内一致性几乎完美(Fleiss kappa 0.871–0.876与0.90–0.92),CO-RADS特异度更高(68–73% vs RSNA 52–58%)。60名临床医生调查中多数偏好RSNA报告系统(66.7–76.7%,P<0.05)。
要点
- RSNA与CO-RADS两系统观察者间一致性几乎完美(Fleiss kappa 0.871与0.876,P<0.0001)。
- CO-RADS特异度68–73%,高于RSNA的52–58%;两系统阴性预测值相似(0.573–0.585与0.573–0.58)。
- 60名调查参与者中多数对所有选项均偏好RSNA报告系统(66.7–76.7%,P<0.05)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 观察者间一致性:RSNA Fleiss kappa 0.871(P<0.0001),CO-RADS Fleiss kappa 0.876(P<0.0001)。
- 观察者内一致性(两评分系统等效类别间):Fleiss kappa 0.90–0.92(P<0.001)。
- 阳性预测值:RSNA 0.798–0.818,CO-RADS 0.891–0.903。
- 阴性预测值:RSNA 0.573–0.585,CO-RADS 0.573–0.58。
- 特异度:CO-RADS 68–73%,RSNA 52–58%,CO-RADS特异度更高。
临床应用与阅片要点
- RSNA与CO-RADS报告系统均可提供标准化描述,观察者间/内一致性几乎完美且阳性预测值高。
- CO-RADS特异度68–73%高于RSNA的52–58%,两系统阴性预测值相似(0.573–0.585与0.573–0.58)。
- 60名调查参与者中多数对所有选项均偏好RSNA报告系统(66.7–76.7%,P<0.05)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The RSNA expert consensus statement and CO-RADS reporting system assist radiologists in describing lung imaging findings in a standardized manner in patients under investigation for COVID-19 pneumonia and provide clarity in communication with other healthcare providers. We aim to compare diagnostic performance and inter-/intra-observer among chest radiologists in the interpretation of RSNA and CO-RADS reporting systems and assess clinician preference.
METHODS: Chest CT scans of 279 patients with suspected COVID-19 who underwent RT-PCR testing were retrospectively and independently examined by 3 chest radiologists who assigned interpretation according to the RSNA and CO-RADS reporting systems. Inter-/intra-observer analysis was performed. Diagnostic accuracy of both reporting systems was calculated. 60 clinicians participated in a survey to assess end-user preference of the reporting systems.
RESULTS: Both systems demonstrated almost perfect inter-observer agreement (Fleiss kappa 0.871, P < 0.0001 for RSNA; 0.876, P < 0.0001 for CO-RADS impressions). Intra-observer agreement between the 2 scoring systems using the equivalent categories was almost perfect (Fleiss kappa 0.90-0.92, P < 0.001). Positive predictive values were high, 0.798-0.818 for RSNA and 0.891-0.903 CO-RADS. Negative predictive value were similar, 0.573-0.585 for RSNA and 0.573-0.58 for CO-RADS. Specificity differed between the 2 systems, 68-73% for CO-RADS and 52-58% for RSNA with superior specificity of CO-RADS. Of 60 survey participants, the majority preferred the RSNA reporting system rather than CO-RADS for all options provided (66.7-76.7%; P < 0.05).
CONCLUSIONS: RSNA and CO-RADS reporting systems are consistent and reproducible with near perfect inter-/intra-observer agreement and excellent positive predictive value. End-users preferred the reporting language in the RSNA system.
引用
- O' Neill SB, Byrne D, Müller NL, et al. Radiological Society of North America (RSNA) Expert Consensus Statement Related to Chest CT Findings in COVID-19 Versus CO-RADS: Comparison of Reporting System Performance Among Chest Radiologists and End-User Preference. Can Assoc Radiol J. 2020. PMID: 33138634. doi:10.1177/0846537120968919
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。