文献速递胸部儿科影像DR

英国儿童结核接触者及移民儿童筛查中胸部X线判读肺结核的可靠性

Reliability of chest radiograph interpretation for pulmonary tuberculosis in the screening of childhood TB contacts and migrant children in the UK.
PubMed 文献 · Clin Radiol · 2020-09-30

回顾性分析英国某三级儿童医院148名结核筛查儿童的胸部X线,原报告16%(20/125)有结核特征,专家小组对121例中17%(20例)判定为肺结核,阅片者间一致性仅为中等(kappa 0.4-0.6),作者认为虽筛查有价值但常规推荐X线因可靠性中等而存疑。

要点

  • 儿童结核筛查胸片中肺结核比例较高(原报告16%,专家组17%),提示接触者筛查有价值。
  • 即使儿科影像专家阅片,肺结核判读的观察者间一致性仅为中等(kappa 0.5)。
  • 作者认为因判读可靠性仅中等,常规使用并推荐胸片筛查的做法存疑。

核心结论

  • 儿童结核筛查胸片中肺结核比例较高(原报告16%;专家组17%),提示对儿童结核接触者进行筛查检查是有价值的。
  • 但胸片判读可靠性仅中等(kappa 0.5),即使由专家判读亦然,因此常规使用并推荐胸片筛查的做法存疑。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究,纳入英国某三级儿童医院7年以上电子申请单、病历和胸片。
  • 研究对象为暴露于传染性结核病例的儿童及新入境英国的儿童。
  • 纳入标准为Mantoux/干扰素γ释放试验(IGRA)阳性、培养阳性或临床高度怀疑结核。
  • 胸片报告分为正常、异常但无结核特征、异常伴肺结核特征三类。
  • 3名来自专职儿科放射科的儿科放射医师使用已发表的胸片报告工具评估可用胸片,知晓结核筛查指征,但对初始胸片报告及彼此设盲。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 148名儿童接受胸片结核筛查,125名有可用胸片报告和病历,其中20/125(16%)胸片报告有结核特征。
  • 125名中121名有胸片可供专家组复核,其中20/121(17%)经多数决策判定为肺结核。
  • 所有方面的阅片者间一致性均为中等(kappa 0.4-0.6)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文在结论中自述胸片判读可靠性仅中等(kappa 0.5),即使由专家判读亦然。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

AIM: To determine interobserver agreement between paediatric radiologists interpreting tuberculosis (TB) screening chest radiographs (CXR) in children in the UK, and the TB detection rate.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective review was undertaken of electronic request, notes, and CXRs (>7 years) in children exposed to an infectious case of TB and new entrants to the UK, at a tertiary children's hospital. Included were those with positive Mantoux/interferon gamma release assay (IGRA), positive culture, or high clinical suspicion of TB. CXR reports were categorised as normal, abnormal without features of TB, or abnormal with features of pulmonary TB. Three paediatric radiologists from a dedicated paediatric radiology department evaluated available CXRs, aware of the TB screening indication, using a published CXR reporting tool and blinded to the initial CXR report and to each other. A majority decision was collated, and considered lymphadenopathy and miliary nodules as diagnostic of primary TB. Interobserver agreement was calculated using Cohen's kappa.

RESULTS: One hundred and forty-eight children underwent TB screening with a CXR. One hundred and twenty-five had available CXR reports and case notes, which indicated 20/125 (16%) had CXR features of TB. One hundred and twenty-one of the 125 had CXRs available to for panel review. Twenty of these 121 (17%) yielded a majority decision of pulmonary TB. Inter-reader agreement was moderate in all aspects (kappa 0.4-0.6).

CONCLUSION: The high percentage of pulmonary TB on CXR (16% original reports; 17% by panel review) suggests that it is worthwhile investigating childhood TB contacts; however, the routine use and recommendation for CXR is questionable because of only moderate interpretation reliability (kappa 0.5), even by experts.

来源:Clin Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Andronikou S, Grier D, Minhas K, et al. Reliability of chest radiograph interpretation for pulmonary tuberculosis in the screening of childhood TB contacts and migrant children in the UK. Clin Radiol. 2020. PMID: 33010931. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2020.08.035

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。