EOS 影像系统在膝骨关节炎分级中的准确性与传统 X 线摄影相当吗
本研究纳入 142 例同日行下肢 EOS 与膝关节 X 线摄影的患者,以膝关节前后位传统 X 线摄影为金标准,比较 EOS 图像对膝骨关节炎的 Kellgren 和 Lawrence 评分、OARSI 系统评分及关节间隙测量的准确性。结果显示关节间隙组内相关性很好,KL 评分加权 kappa 优秀,OARSI 骨赘与关节间隙狭窄参数加权 kappa 在 0.9 至 0.96 之间(α<0.001),畸形参数敏感度 93.6%、特异度 100%,硬化参数敏感度 71.3%、特异度 99.3%;作者认为 EOS 前后位图像可像传统 X 线一样可靠地用于 KL 评分和关节间隙定量评估,但股骨内外侧髁或胫骨的软骨下硬化在 EOS 上有时不够明显。
要点
- EOS 前后位图像用于膝骨关节炎 KL 评分和关节间隙宽度定量评估与传统 X 线摄影同样可靠。
- OARSI 骨赘和关节间隙狭窄参数的加权 kappa 为 0.9 至 0.96(α<0.001),一致性优秀。
- 软骨下硬化在 EOS 上有时不够明显,硬化参数敏感度仅 71.3%(特异度 99.3%)。
核心结论
- 使用 KL 评分进行骨关节炎分级以及关节间隙宽度的定量评估,在 EOS 前后位图像上可像传统 X 线摄影一样可靠地完成。
- 股骨内外侧髁或胫骨的软骨下硬化在 EOS 图像上有时不够明显。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入 142 例同日行下肢 EOS 与膝关节 X 线摄影的患者。
- 以膝关节前后位传统 X 线摄影为金标准,比较 EOS 图像的准确性。
- 骨关节炎分级采用 Kellgren 和 Lawrence(KL)评分及骨关节炎研究学会国际(OARSI)系统,并测量和比较两种技术的关节间隙。
关键影像表现/征象
- 关节间隙测量显示组内相关性很好。
- EOS 与 X 线摄影比较的 KL 评分加权 kappa 优秀。
- OARSI 评分中骨赘和关节间隙狭窄参数在 EOS 与 X 线摄影之间的加权 kappa 为 0.9 至 0.96(α<0.001)。
- 畸形参数在 EOS 与 X 线摄影之间一致性良好,敏感度 93.6%、特异度 100%。
- 硬化参数总体敏感度 71.3%、特异度 99.3%。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 骨关节炎分级采用 Kellgren 和 Lawrence(KL)评分及 OARSI 系统,以膝关节前后位传统 X 线摄影为金标准。
- KL 评分 EOS 与 X 线摄影比较的加权 kappa 为优秀。
- OARSI 骨赘和关节间隙狭窄参数加权 kappa 为 0.9 至 0.96(α<0.001)。
- OARSI 畸形参数敏感度 93.6%、特异度 100%;硬化参数敏感度 71.3%、特异度 99.3%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- EOS 前后位图像可用于膝骨关节炎的初步评估。
- 在膝关节置换手术的术前评估中,除下肢全长 EOS 图像外,仍应加做膝关节两个或三个平面的传统 X 线摄影。
局限性
- 股骨内外侧髁或胫骨的软骨下硬化在 EOS 图像上有时不够明显。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The EOS imaging system allows for the acquirement of long-leg radiographic images in a standing position without stitching artifacts or projection bias and at a comparatively low-radiation-dose exposure. The aim of our study was to compare the accuracy of EOS images of the lower limb to conventional radiographs (CR) of the knee in a.p. view for the grading of osteoarthritis (OA).
METHODS: One hundred forty-two patients who had undergone EOS of the lower limb and radiography of the knee on the same day were included. For the grading of OA, the Kellgren and Lawrence score (KL) score and the Osteoarthritis Research Society International (OARSI) system were used. Additionally, the joint space was measured and compared between the two techniques. EOS images were compared to conventional anteroposterior radiographs of the knee which constitute the gold standard.
RESULTS: Measurements of the joint space showed very good intra-class correlation. The calculated weighted kappa for the KL score of EOS versus CR was excellent. The comparison of the different parameters of the OARSI score showed superb weighted kappa scores between 0.9 and 0.96 (α < 0.001) for the parameters osteophytes and joint space narrowing. The parameter deformity showed a good agreement between EOS and radiographs (sensitivity 93.6%; specificity 100%). For the sclerosis parameter, an overall sensitivity of 71.3% and a specificity of 99.3% were calculated.
CONCLUSIONS: The grading of OA using the KL score as well as the quantitative assessment of joint space width can be performed on EOS images in a.p. view as reliably as on CR. Subchondral sclerosis of the lateral and medial femur condyle or tibia is sometimes not as evident on EOS images.
KEY POINTS: • Grading of OA may be performed as reliably with EOS images in a.p. view as with conventional radiographs in a.p. view. • EOS can be safely used for primary assessment of osteoarthritis of the knee. • In the preoperative setting for knee replacement surgery, conventional radiographs in two or three planes of the knee should still be acquired in addition to long-leg EOS images.
引用
- Koliogiannis VKA, Brandlhuber M, Messerschmidt V, et al. Is the EOS imaging system as accurate as conventional radiography in grading osteoarthritis of the knee? Eur Radiol. 2020. PMID: 33119811. doi:10.1007/s00330-020-07187-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。