超低剂量CT与X线摄影在轻度脊柱与骨盆创伤中的准确性:贝叶斯分析
前瞻性纳入连续急诊轻度创伤患者,在2个月工作时间内对脊柱、骨盆环或髋部疑似骨折行超低剂量CT(ULD CT)并加做X线摄影,由两名盲法放射科医师独立评估,采用最佳有效比较标准(BVC)和贝叶斯潜类别模型(BLCM)估计敏感度与特异度,并记录有效剂量。ULD CT检测骨折的敏感度高于X线摄影,脊柱和髋部有效剂量与X线摄影相近。
要点
- 在轻度脊柱与骨盆创伤中,ULD CT检测骨折的敏感度高于X线摄影。
- 脊柱和髋部ULD CT的有效剂量与X线摄影相近;腰椎ULD CT有效剂量高于X线摄影。
- 作者认为在日常实践中以ULD CT替代X线摄影是可供考虑的选择,并应通过随机试验评估。
核心结论
- ULD CT检测骨折的敏感度高于X线摄影,且有效剂量与X线摄影相当。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,连续纳入急诊科轻度创伤患者,在2个月工作时间内行ULD CT并加做X线摄影。
- 共分析69例患者的80个部位,包括22个胸椎、28个腰椎和30个骨盆环/髋部。
- 由两名盲法放射科医师独立评估近期骨折是否存在;以最佳有效比较标准(BVC)为参考,并采用贝叶斯推断的潜类别模型(BLCM)估计敏感度和特异度。
- 记录剂量学指标,并使用转换系数计算有效剂量(E)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 应用BVC方法,按部位不同,读者1的ULD CT敏感度为80%至100%,读者2为85%至100%。
- 应用BVC方法,按部位不同,读者1的X线摄影敏感度为60%至85%,读者2为50%至92%。
- 采用BLCM方法,读者2的ULD CT敏感度在所有部位/胸椎/腰椎/骨盆环-髋部分别为87.1%/75.9%/84.2%/76.9%。
- 采用BLCM方法,读者2对应的X线摄影敏感度分别为73.8%、54.8%、80.4%和68.7%。
- 胸椎和髋部ULD CT的有效剂量与X线摄影相近;腰椎ULD CT有效剂量为1.83±0.59 mSv,X线摄影为0.96±0.59 mSv(p<0.001)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,在日常实践中以ULD CT替代X线摄影用于创伤患者是可供考虑的选择,并应通过随机试验评估。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To compare diagnosis performance and effective dose of ultra-low-dose CT (ULD CT) versus radiographs in suspected spinal or pelvic ring or hip fracture for minor trauma.
METHODS: ULD CT, in addition to radiography, was prospectively performed in consecutive patients admitted to the emergency department for minor traumas, during working hours over 2 months. Presence of a recent fracture was assessed by two blind radiologists independently. Sensitivities and specificities were estimated using the best valuable comparator (BVC) as a reference and using a latent class model in Bayesian inference (BLCM). Dosimetric indicators were recorded and effective doses (E) were calculated using conversion coefficient.
RESULTS: Eighty areas were analyzed in 69 patients, including 22 dorsal spine, 28 lumbar spine, and 30 pelvic ring/hip. Thirty-six fractures (45%) were observed. Applying the BVC method, depending on location, ULD CT sensitivity was 80 to 100% for reader 1 and 85 to 100% for reader 2, whereas radiographic sensitivity was 60 to 85% for reader 1 and 50 to 92% for reader 2. With BLCM approach for reader 2, ULD CT sensitivity for all locations/dorsal spine/lumbar spine and pelvic ring-hip was 87.1/75.9/84.2/76.9% respectively. Corresponding radiograph sensitivity was 73.8, 54.8, 80.4, and 68.7%. Effective doses of ULD CT were similar to radiographs for dorsal and hip locations whereas for lumbar spine, ULD CT effective dose was 1.83 ± 0.59 mSv compared with 0.96 ± 0.59 mSv (p < 0.001).
CONCLUSION: Sensitivity for fracture detection was higher for ULD CT compared with radiographs with an effective dose comparable to radiographs.
KEY POINTS: • Ultra-low-dose spine and pelvis CT demonstrates better fracture detection when compared with radiographs. • The effective dose of ultra-low-dose spine and pelvis CT scan and radiographs is comparable. • Replacement of radiographs by ULD CT in daily practice for trauma patients is an option to consider and should be evaluated by a randomized trial.
引用
- Hamard A, Greffier J, Bastide S, et al. Ultra-low-dose CT versus radiographs for minor spine and pelvis trauma: a Bayesian analysis of accuracy. Eur Radiol. 2020. PMID: 33034747. doi:10.1007/s00330-020-07304-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。