人工智能在乳腺X线筛查中的应用:女性人群偏好调查
该研究调查了922名16至75岁荷兰女性对人工智能用于筛查乳腺X线诊断解读的态度。77.8%的受访者认为必须有人类复核,41.7%反对将人工智能作为二次读片的筛选工具。讨论指出,尽管人工智能算法诊断表现有突破,但一般人群目前不支持完全独立使用此类系统而不涉及放射科医生,放射科医生作为第一读片者与人工智能作为第二读片者的组合获得最多支持。
要点
- 77.8%的受访女性认为人工智能解读筛查乳腺X线时必须有人类复核。
- 41.7%反对将人工智能作为二次读片的筛选工具,31.5%同意,26.9%持中立。
- 放射科医生第一读片联合人工智能第二读片的组合目前获得最多支持。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 77.8%的参与者同意必须有人类复核。
- 人工智能作为二次读片筛选工具:41.7%不同意,31.5%同意,26.9%回答「既不同意也不反对」。
- 人工智能作为第二读片者:37.1%回答「既不同意也不反对」,37.6%同意。
- 开发者对错误负责:44.6%回答「既不同意也不反对」。
- 放射科医生对错误负责:39.2%回答「既不同意也不反对」。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the general population's view on the use of artificial intelligence (AI) for the diagnostic interpretation of screening mammograms.
METHODS: Dutch women aged 16 to 75 years were surveyed using the Longitudinal Internet Studies for the Social sciences panel, representative for the Dutch population. Attitude toward AI in mammography screening was measured by means of five items: necessity of a human check; AI as a selector for second reading; AI as a second reader; developer is responsible for error; and radiologist is responsible for error.
RESULTS: Of the 922 participants included, 77.8% agreed with the necessity of a human check, whereas the item AI as a selector for a second reading was more heterogeneously answered, with 41.7% disagreement, 31.5% agreement, and 26.9% responding with "neither agree nor disagree." The item AI as a second reader was mostly responded with "neither agree nor disagree" (37.1%) and "agree" (37.6%), whereas the two last items on developer's and radiologist' responsibilities were mostly answered with "neither agree nor disagree" (44.6% and 39.2%, respectively).
DISCUSSION: Despite recent breakthroughs in the diagnostic performance of AI algorithms for the interpretation of screening mammograms, the general population currently does not support a fully independent use of such systems without involving a radiologist. The combination of a radiologist as a first reader and an AI system as a second reader in a breast cancer screening program finds most support at present. Accountability in case of AI-related diagnostic errors in screening mammography is still an unresolved conundrum.
引用
- Ongena YP, Yakar D, Haan M, et al. Artificial Intelligence in Screening Mammography: A Population Survey of Women's Preferences. J Am Coll Radiol. 2020. PMID: 33058789. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2020.09.042
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。