超声引导靶向任务持续验证:与操作表现的关系
本研究在非随机干预试验中让一年级医学生每周练习超声引导靶向任务1小时、共4周,随后完成模拟羊膜腔穿刺和绒毛膜绒毛取样操作。训练组(n=22)在模拟羊膜腔穿刺多项评分及总体表现上高于对照组(n=15),两组在绒毛膜绒毛取样上无差异。研究为模拟器及配套整体评定量表提供了内容与内部结构效度证据,但靶向任务需修改才能适用于其他操作。
要点
- 训练组模拟羊膜腔穿刺多项评分及总体表现高于对照组,绒毛膜绒毛取样两组无差异。
- 整体评定量表评分者间与评分者内信度范围为0.16–0.89,多数呈良好至优秀一致性。
- 研究为羊膜腔穿刺和绒毛膜绒毛取样模拟器及配套整体评定量表提供效度证据。
核心结论
- 研究为羊膜腔穿刺和绒毛膜绒毛取样模拟器及其配套整体评定量表提供了内容与内部结构领域的效度证据。
- 反复练习靶向任务改善了学生在模拟羊膜腔穿刺中的表现,但需修改才能适用于绒毛膜绒毛取样等其他操作。
研究设计与样本
- 非随机干预试验,一年级医学生分为训练组(n=22)与对照组(n=15)。
- 训练组每周练习先前描述的 dowel 和 straw 靶向任务1小时、共4周,对照组不训练。
- 之后每名学生各完成一次模拟羊膜腔穿刺和绒毛膜绒毛取样操作,用整体评定量表评分并以 Mann-Whitney U 检验组间比较。
- 对两份整体评定量表各条目计算评分者间与评分者内变异的两-way随机效应组内相关系数。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 采用整体评定量表(GRS)对模拟羊膜腔穿刺和绒毛膜绒毛取样操作评分。
- 整体评定量表评分者间与评分者内信度范围为0.16–0.89,多数数值呈良好至优秀一致性。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 训练组在模拟羊膜腔穿刺多项方面及总体表现评分高于对照组。
- 模拟绒毛膜绒毛取样两组间无差异。
- 作者指出靶向任务需修改才能与绒毛膜绒毛取样等其他操作相关。
局限性
- 原文指出需对靶向任务进行修改才能使其适用于绒毛膜绒毛取样等其他操作。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To determine if deliberative practice with novel ultrasound guidance targeting tasks improves simulated procedural skill.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In a nonrandomized interventional trial first year medical students practiced the previous described dowel and straw targeting tasks 1 hour a week for 4 weeks (training group) or had no training (controls). Afterward, they each performed a simulated amniocentesis (AMN) and chorionic villus sampling (CVS) procedure. Procedures were scored using a global rating scale (GRS) and compared between groups with Mann-Whitney U tests. Two-way random effects intraclass correlation coefficients for the inter- and intra-rater variability were calculated for each item in both GRS's.
RESULTS: The training group (n = 22) had higher scores on several aspects and overall performance of AMN compared to controls (n = 15). There were no differences between groups for CVS. The inter-rater and intra-rater reliability of the GRS's for both AMN and CVS ranged from 0.16 to 0.89 with most values demonstrating good to excellent agreement.
CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates validity evidence in the content and internal structure domains for the AMN and CVS simulators and their accompanying GRS's. Repetitive practice of the targeting tasks improved student performance in simulated AMN, but modifications are needed for it to be relevant to other procedures such as CVS.
引用
- Nitsche JF, Conrad S, Hoopes S, et al. Continued Validation of Ultrasound Guidance Targeting Tasks: Relationship with Procedure Performance. Acad Radiol. 2020. PMID: 33036898. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2020.08.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。