文献速递胸部CT

基于法国多中心急诊队列的远程放射科医师诊断COVID-19的准确性

The accuracy of teleradiologists in diagnosing COVID-19 based on a French multicentric emergency cohort.
PubMed 文献 · Eur Radiol · 2020-10-29

这项前瞻性多中心研究纳入2020年3月13日至4月14日15家医院连续疑似COVID-19的成人患者,均行RT-PCR和胸部CT,由值班远程放射科医师即时判读并由资深放射科医师盲法复核,采用5分法分类;结果显示胸部CT诊断准确性高,值班远程放射科医师与资深放射科医师间观察者一致性极好(加权kappa=0.87)。

要点

  • 胸部CT判读采用5分法:1正常、2非感染性、3感染性但不符COVID-19、4符合COVID-19、5典型COVID-19表现。
  • RT-PCR阳性患者中225/244(92%)首次判读评分为4或5分,RT-PCR阴性患者中201/269(74.7%)评分为1至3分。
  • 以「典型表现」预测RT-PCR阳性时,值班远程放射科医师判读敏感度0.75-0.79、特异度0.92-0.97、NPV 0.80-0.83、PPV 0.89-0.96。

核心结论

  • 胸部CT显示出高诊断准确性,且值班远程放射科医师(经验程度不一)与资深放射科医师之间在研究期间观察者一致性很强。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性研究,纳入2020年3月13日至4月14日15家医院连续疑似COVID-19的成人患者,均行RT-PCR和胸部CT。
  • 胸部CT由值班远程放射科医师即时判读,并由资深放射科医师系统盲法复核,采用5分法分类。
  • 共纳入513例患者,其中244/513(47.6%)RT-PCR阳性。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 5分法:1正常;2非感染性表现;3感染性表现但不符COVID-19感染;4符合COVID-19感染;5典型COVID-19感染表现。
  • 首次判读评分为4或5分者占RT-PCR阳性患者的225/244(92%),评分为1至3分者占RT-PCR阴性患者的201/269(74.7%)。
  • 加权kappa=0.87,与RT-PCR相关(p<0.001),AUC首次判读=0.89、AUC第二次判读=0.93。
  • 评分为4或5分的阴性预测值为0.91-0.92,评分为5分的阳性预测值在首次和第二次判读分别为0.89-0.96。
  • 基于「典型表现」预测RT-PCR阳性,值班远程放射科医师判读相对资深放射科医师复核的敏感度0.75-0.79、特异度0.92-0.97、NPV 0.80-0.83、PPV 0.89-0.96。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the accuracy of diagnoses of COVID-19 based on chest CT as well as inter-observer agreement between teleradiologists during on-call duty and senior radiologists in suspected COVID-19 patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: From March 13, 2020, to April 14, 2020, consecutive suspected COVID-19 adult patients who underwent both an RT-PCR test and chest CT from 15 hospitals were included in this prospective study. Chest CTs were immediately interpreted by the on-call teleradiologist and were systematically blind reviewed by a senior radiologist. Readings were categorised using a five-point scale: (1) normal; (2) non-infectious findings; (3) infectious findings but not consistent with COVID-19 infection; (4) consistent with COVID-19 infection; and (5) typical appearance of COVID-19 infection. The diagnostic accuracy of chest CT and inter-observer agreement using the kappa coefficient were evaluated over the study period.

RESULTS: In total, 513 patients were enrolled, of whom 244/513 (47.6%) tested positive for RT-PCR. First readings were scored 4 or 5 in 225/244 (92%) RT-PCR+ patients, and between 1 and 3 in 201/269 (74.7%) RT-PCR- patients. The data were highly consistent (weighted kappa = 0.87) and correlated with RT-PCR (p < 0.001, AUC1st-reading = 0.89, AUC2nd-reading = 0.93). The negative predictive value for scores of 4 or 5 was 0.91-0.92, and the PPV for a score of 5 was 0.89-0.96 at the first and second readings, respectively. Diagnostic accuracy was consistent over the study period, irrespective of a variable prevalence rate.

CONCLUSION: Chest CT demonstrated high diagnostic accuracy with strong inter-observer agreement between on-call teleradiologists with varying degrees of experience and senior radiologists over the study period.

KEY POINTS: • The accuracy of readings by on-call teleradiologists, relative to second readings by senior radiologists, demonstrated a sensitivity of 0.75-0.79, specificity of 0.92-0.97, NPV of 0.80-0.83, and PPV of 0.89-0.96, based on "typical appearance," as predictive of RT-PCR+. • Inter-observer agreement between the first reading in the emergency setting and the second reading by the senior emergency teleradiologist was excellent (weighted kappa = 0.87).

来源:Eur Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Nivet H, Crombé A, Schuster P, et al. The accuracy of teleradiologists in diagnosing COVID-19 based on a French multicentric emergency cohort. Eur Radiol. 2020. PMID: 33123790. doi:10.1007/s00330-020-07345-z

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。