膝关节加速MRI:压缩感知的质量与效率
研究纳入20名健康志愿者,在3T扫描仪上比较压缩感知(CS)与SENSE加速的膝关节脂肪饱和质子密度加权2D和3D序列。CS可显著缩短扫描时间,其中2D CS 2缩短34.39%、3D CS 10缩短54.17%,且诊断确信度和整体图像印象与临床参考序列相比未见改变。
要点
- 压缩感知可显著缩短膝关节MRI扫描时间,2D CS 2缩短34.39%,3D CS 10缩短54.17%。
- 在诊断确信度和整体图像印象上,CS序列与临床参考序列相比未见改变。
- 3D CS 8在所有测试标准上非劣效,且优于时间等效的SENSE加速。
核心结论
- 压缩感知可显著缩短膝关节MRI扫描时间(2D CS 2缩短34.39%,3D CS 10缩短54.17%),且诊断确信度和整体图像印象与临床参考序列相比未见改变。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入20名健康志愿者,在3T扫描仪上扫描,所有志愿者均接受标准脂肪饱和2D质子密度加权序列、三种压缩感知加速(CS 2、CS 3、CS 5)以及时间等效的SENSE加速(S 2、S 3、S 5)。
- 脂肪饱和3D质子密度加权序列采用四种压缩感知加速(CS 6、CS 8、CS 10、CS 15)及等效SENSE加速(S 5.72、S 7.69、S 9.57、S 14)采集。
- 由三名独立阅片者进行图像评分;客观评价分析信噪比、对比噪声比、均方根误差和结构相似性指数。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 2D标准序列在诊断确信度和整体图像印象上评分最佳,平均分别为4.97 ± 0.10和4.80 ± 0.24(均p < 0.05),但2D CS 2和2D S 2除外。
- 3D序列中,标准序列在CS 15、S 9.57和S 4(原文此处写作S 4,按上下文应为S 5.72)的整体图像印象上表现更好,S 7.69在整体图像印象上亦优于标准序列;CS 8在所有测试标准上非劣效,CS 10仅在前交叉韧带描绘上劣于标准序列,两者均优于时间等效的SENSE加速。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To evaluate potential clinical acceleration factors of Compressed SENSE (CS)1 in direct comparison with SENSE for fat saturated (fs)2, proton density-weighted (PD)3 2D and 3D sequences of the knee.
METHOD: Twenty healthy volunteers were scanned with a 3 T scanner, all receiving a standard, fs 2D PD, three CS (CS 2, CS 3, CS 5) as well as time-equivalent SENSE accelerations (S 2, S 3, S 5). The fs 3D PD sequence was acquired with four CS (CS 6, CS 8, CS 10, CS 15) and equivalent SENSE (S 5.72, S 7.69, S 9.57, S 14) factors. Three independent readers rated the images. Signal-to-noise, contrast-to-noise, root-mean-square error and structural similarity index were analyzed for objective evaluation.
RESULTS: Scan time decreased with increasing CS factor (2D CS 2: 145 s, 2D CS 3: 95 s, 2D CS 5: 57 s, 3D CS 6: 293 s, 3D CS 8: 220 s, 3D CS 10: 176 s, 3D CS 15: 119 s). The 2D standard sequence was rated best for diagnostic certainty and overall image impression with an average of 4.97 ± 0.10 and 4.80 ± 0.24 (all p < 0.05), except for 2D CS 2 and 2D S 2. For the 3D sequences, the standard sequence performed better for both parameters for CS 15, S 9.57 and S 4, as well as S 7.69 for overall image impression while CS 8 was non-inferior for all tested criteria and CS 10 only inferior for delineation of the anterior cruciate ligament, both outperforming the time-equivalent SENSE accelerations.
CONCLUSION: Compressed SENSE can significantly decrease (34.39 % for 2D CS 2 and 54.17 % for 3D CS 10) scan time in knee imaging with unchanged diagnostic certainty and overall image impression compared to the clinical reference.
引用
- Iuga AI, Abdullayev N, Weiss K, et al. Accelerated MRI of the knee. Quality and efficiency of compressed sensing. Eur J Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32957000. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2020.109273
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。