卢旺达农村非放射科临床医生诊断性乳腺超声培训:知识与技能影响
在卢旺达农村医院,对2名全科医生和5名护士进行9周面授加20个月远程辅导的乳腺超声培训,以放射科医生评估为金标准。书面知识正确率从57.7%升至98.1%(P=0.03);识别中或高怀疑度实性肿块的敏感度从79.2%升至96.3%(P=0.03),其余指标无显著差异。
要点
- 培训后书面知识正确率从57.7%升至98.1%(P=0.03)。
- 识别中或高怀疑度实性肿块的敏感度从79.2%升至96.3%(P=0.03)。
- 识别实性肿块的敏感度与特异度在培训前后无显著差异。
核心结论
- 非放射科临床医生(医生和护士)经23个月面授加远程辅导,建立了较强的诊断性乳腺超声技能。
- 学员识别可疑恶性肿块的敏感度在持续辅导后提高。
- 对患者诊疗和结局影响的评估正在进行中。
研究设计与样本
- 培训效果评估研究,纳入卢旺达2名全科医生和5名护士,由4名乳腺放射科医生培训。
- 培训方式为9周面授加20个月远程辅导,远程辅导采用电子图像审阅并邮件反馈。
- 以放射科医生评估为金标准,比较学员独立记录的评估,并比较培训前半段与后半段的表现。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 书面知识评估正确率:培训后57.7% vs 98.1%,P=0.03。
- 识别实性乳腺肿块的敏感度:培训前半段(第1阶段)90.6%(SD 4.2%)vs 后半段(第2阶段)94.0%(SD 6.7%),P=0.32。
- 识别实性乳腺肿块的特异度:第1阶段94.7%(SD 5.4%)vs 第2阶段100.0%(SD 0),P=0.10。
- 识别中或高怀疑度实性肿块的敏感度:第1阶段79.2%(SD 11.0%)vs 第2阶段96.3%(SD 6.4%),P=0.03。
- 识别中或高怀疑度实性肿块的特异度:第1阶段84.4%(SD 15.0%)vs 第2阶段96.7%(SD 5.8%),P=0.31。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 对患者诊疗和结局影响的评估仍在进行中,原文未报告该部分结果。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To assess the effectiveness of diagnostic breast ultrasound training provided for general practitioners and nurses in Rwanda via intensive in-person and subsequent online supervision and mentorship.
METHODS: Four breast radiologists from Brigham and Women's Hospital trained two general practitioner physicians and five nurses in Rwanda over 9 total weeks of in-person training and 20 months of remote mentorship using electronic image review with emailed feedback. Independently recorded assessments were compared to calculate the sensitivity and specificity of trainee assessments, with radiologist assessments as the gold standard. We compared performance in the first versus second half of the training.
RESULTS: Trainees' performance on written knowledge assessments improved after training (57.7% versus 98.1% correct, P = .03). Mean sensitivity of trainee-performed ultrasound for identifying a solid breast mass was 90.6% (SD 4.2%) in the first half of the training (period 1) and 94.0% (SD 6.7%) in period 2 (P = .32). Mean specificity was 94.7% (SD 5.4%) in period 1 and 100.0% (SD 0) in period 2 (P = .10). Mean sensitivity for identifying a medium- or high-suspicion solid mass increased from 79.2% (SD 11.0%) in period 1 to 96.3% (SD 6.4%) in period 2 (P = .03). Specificity was 84.4% (SD 15.0%) in period 1 and 96.7% (SD 5.8%) in period 2 (P = .31).
DISCUSSION: Nonradiologist clinicians (doctors and nurses) in a rural sub-Saharan African hospital built strong skills in diagnostic breast ultrasound over 23 months of combined in-person training and remote mentorship. The sensitivity of trainees' assessments in identifying masses concerning for malignancy improved after sustained mentorship. Assessment of impact on patient care and outcomes is ongoing.
引用
- Raza S, Frost E, Kwait D, et al. Training Nonradiologist Clinicians in Diagnostic Breast Ultrasound in Rural Rwanda: Impact on Knowledge and Skills. J Am Coll Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32916158. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2020.08.013
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。