PI-RADS第2版与第2.1版:六名放射科医师在外周带和移行带病变中的观察者间一致性和诊断性能比较
六名不同经验放射科医师回顾性评估80个前列腺病变(外周带40个、移行带40个)的MRI,分别使用PI-RADS v2和v2.1,比较观察者间一致性并在50个有病理数据的病变中比较诊断性能。v2.1在外周带的观察者间一致性高于v2,但移行带相似;诊断性能仅在外周带有经验读者中v2.1更高。
要点
- 外周带PI-RADS≥4类的观察者间一致性v2.1(κ=0.64)高于v2(κ=0.51),移行带两者相似(v2 κ=0.64 vs v2.1 κ=0.60)。
- v2.1的DWI描述词「线样/楔形」一致性(κ=0.52)高于v2的「模糊低信号」(κ=0.18),并带来14例真阴性增加 vs 5例假阴性增加。
- v2.1移行带T2WI类别2的修改描述词一致性为一般(κ=0.21),移行带PI-RADS类别2的一致性v2.1(κ=0.31)低于v2(κ=0.57)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 外周带PI-RADS≥4类的观察者间一致性:v2.1 κ=0.64 vs v2 κ=0.51。
- 移行带PI-RADS≥4类的观察者间一致性:v2 κ=0.64 vs v2.1 κ=0.60。
- DWI描述词一致性:v2.1「线样/楔形」κ=0.52 vs v2「模糊低信号」κ=0.18。
- ADC信号描述词「显著低信号」一致性:v2.1 κ=0.26 vs v2 κ=0.52。
- 移行带修改的T2WI类别2描述词一致性κ=0.21;移行带PI-RADS类别2一致性v2.1 κ=0.31 vs v2 κ=0.57。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. PI-RADS version 2.1 (v2.1) modifications primarily address transition zone (TZ) interpretation. The revisions also impact peripheral zone (PZ) interpretation, which has received less attention. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to compare interobserver agreement of PI-RADS version 2 (v2) and v2.1 in the prostate PZ and TZ and perform a pilot comparison of their diagnostic performance in the two zones. METHODS. Six radiologists with varying experience retrospectively assessed 80 prostate lesions (40 PZ, 40 TZ) on MRI in separate sessions for PI-RADS v2 and v2.1. Interobserver agreement was assessed using Conger kappa (κ). For 50 lesions with pathology data, average AUC for detecting clinically significant cancer was compared between versions using multireader multicase statistical methods. Error variance and covariance results informed post hoc power analysis. RESULTS. Interobserver agreement for PI-RADS category 4 or greater was higher for version 2.1 (κ = 0.64) than version 2 (κ = 0.51) in the PZ, but similar for version 2 (κ = 0.64) and version 2.1 (κ = 0.60) in the TZ. The PI-RADS v2.1 DWI descriptor "linear/wedge-shaped" had higher agreement than its predecessor version 2 descriptor "indistinct hypointense" (κ = 0.52 vs κ = 0.18) and yielded 14 more true-negative versus five more false-negative interpretations. The ADC signal descriptor "markedly hypointense," for which only version 2.1 provides a specific definition, had lower agreement in version 2.1 (κ = 0.26) than version 2 (κ = 0.52). Modified TZ T2-weighted category 2 descriptors in version 2.1 had fair agreement (κ = 0.21), and agreement for PI-RADS category 2 in the TZ was lower in version 2.1 (κ = 0.31) than version 2 (κ = 0.57). DWI upgraded a TZ lesion category from 2 to 3 in four patients, detecting two additional cancers. Average AUC was not different between versions 2 and 2.1 for the PZ (AUC, 0.81 vs 0.85; p = .24) or the TZ (AUC, 0.69 vs 0.69; p = .94), though among experienced readers AUC was higher for version 2.1 than version 2 for the PZ (0.91 vs 0.82; p = .001). Overall performance comparison had sufficient power (0.8) to detect a 0.085 difference in AUC. CONCLUSION. Interobserver agreement improved using PI-RADS v2.1 in the PZ but not the TZ. Diagnostic performance improved using version 2.1 only in the PZ for experienced readers. Specific version 2.1 modifications yielded mixed results. CLINICAL IMPACT. The impact of PI-RADS v2.1 in the PZ is notable given the emphasis on version 2.1 TZ modifications. The findings suggest areas in which additional modification could further improve interobserver agreement and performance.
引用
- Bhayana R, O'Shea A, Anderson MA, et al. PI-RADS Versions 2 and 2.1: Interobserver Agreement and Diagnostic Performance in Peripheral and Transition Zone Lesions Among Six Radiologists. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2020. PMID: 32903060. doi:10.2214/AJR.20.24199
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。