囊性肾肿块Bosniak分类2019版在非亚专科阅片者CT或MR上未提高观察者间一致性,也未增加低Bosniak类别肿块比例
本研究纳入47例患者50个囊性肾肿块(MR与CT各25个),由9名三年级放射科住院医师和9名腹部影像fellow共18名非亚专科阅片者,间隔8周分别用Bosniak分类2019版(BC19)和现行Bosniak分类(CBC)评估。结果显示BC19未提高观察者间一致性,也未增加低Bosniak类别肿块比例,Bosniak类别中位数反呈中度升高。
要点
- BC19在非亚专科阅片者中一致性为fair(CT κ=0.40,MR κ=0.38),CBC为moderate(CT κ=0.43,MR κ=0.42)。
- BC19较CBC使Bosniak类别中位数中度升高(MR Z=-2.058,p=0.040;CT Z=-2.509,p=0.012)。
- 一致性最差出现在IIF类(BC19-CT κ=0.18),最佳在I类和IV类。
核心结论
- BC19与CBC相比,在非亚专科阅片者中未改善观察者间一致性,也未减少被归入较低Bosniak类别的肿块比例。
研究设计与样本
- 评价50个囊性肾肿块(47例患者),MR和CT各25个,18名阅片者(9名三年级放射科住院医师和9名腹部影像fellow)间隔8周分别使用BC19和CBC评估。
- 采用Kappa统计量评估观察者间一致性,并用所有阅片者Bosniak类别平均分评估BC19是否导致病变降级。
诊断标准与关键数值
- BC19在CT上观察者间一致性κ=0.40(fair),在MR上κ=0.38(fair);CBC在CT上κ=0.43(moderate),在MR上κ=0.42(moderate)。
- 最高Kappa值见于fellow使用CBC-MR(κ=0.51),最低见于住院医师使用CBC-MR和fellow使用BC19-MR(均为κ=0.36)。
- 一致性最佳为I类(κ=0.49-0.69)和IV类(κ=0.45-0.51),最差为IIF类(BC19-CT κ=0.18)。
- 从CBC到BC19,Bosniak类别中位数在MR(Z=-2.058,p=0.040)和CT(Z=-2.509,p=0.012)上均呈中度升高。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在非亚专科阅片者中,BC19对CT和MR上囊性肾肿块的一致性均未优于CBC,阅片和报告时不应假定BC19能提高一致性或增加低类别比例。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: In a condition so prevalent as renal cysts, classifications should display satisfactory reproducibility not only among subspecialized readers. We aimed to compare the interobserver agreement of the Bosniak classification version 2019 (BC19) and current Bosniak classification (CBC) for non-subspecialized readers on CT and MRI and to verify whether BC19 leads to a downgrade of renal cystic masses when compared to CBC.
METHODS: We evaluated 50 renal cystic masses in 47 patients on MR and CT (25 per method). Eighteen readers (nine third-year radiology residents and nine abdominal imaging fellows) assessed the images using BC19 and CBC with an eight-week interval. Kappa statistic was used to assess agreement. An average score of Bosniak categories across all raters evaluated if there was downgrading of lesions on BC19.
RESULTS: The highest values of Kappa were found for fellows on CBC-MR (κ = 0.51), and the lowest values were found for residents on CBC-MR and fellows on BC19-MR (both κ = 0.36). On CBC, interobserver agreement was moderate for MR and CT (κ = 0.42 and 0.43, respectively), whereas on BC19, it was fair (κ = 0.38 and 0.40, respectively). The best agreements were in categories I (κ = 0.49-0.69) and IV (κ = 0.45-0.51). The poorest agreements occurred at IIF (κ = 0.18 on BC19-CT). There was a moderate median increase from CBC to BC19 in terms of Bosniak categories for both methods (MR [Z=-2.058, p = 0.040] and CT [Z=-2.509, p = 0.012]).
CONCLUSION: BC19, when compared to CBC, did not improve interobserver agreement nor diminished the proportion of masses categorized into lower Bosniak classes among non-subspecialized readers.
引用
- Pacheco EO, Torres US, Alves AMA, et al. Bosniak classification of cystic renal masses version 2019 does not increase the interobserver agreement or the proportion of masses categorized into lower Bosniak classes for non-subspecialized readers on CT or MR. Eur J Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32947091. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2020.109270
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。