牙髓病病例中CBCT检查的临床决策及AAE/AAOMR立场声明的重要性
在单中心牙髓病研究生项目中,比较传统X线与CBCT对128例检查的发现,并按AAE/AAOMR联合立场声明归类CBCT开具原因。CBCT较根尖片显著更多显示根尖周病变、遗漏根管、垂直根折和复杂解剖,且使初始诊断和治疗计划发生显著改变;CBCT主要用于辅助手术治疗计划而非诊断。
要点
- CBCT较根尖片显著更多发现根尖周病变(P=0.002)、遗漏根管(P<0.001)、垂直根折(P=0.004)和复杂解剖(P=0.008)。
- CBCT开具原因以辅助手术治疗计划最多(62%),其次为确认诊断(29%),用于生成诊断最少(9%)。
- CBCT提供的额外信息使128例中59例的初始诊断和治疗计划发生改变。
核心结论
- CBCT检查主要用于辅助治疗计划而非诊断,多数检查针对既往已行根管充填的牙齿。
- CBCT额外获得的信息(如新根尖周病变、遗漏根管或颊/舌侧皮质骨受累)使初始诊断和治疗计划发生显著改变,128例中59例改变。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心、不列颠哥伦比亚大学牙髓科研究生项目中的临床CBCT扫描回顾性比较研究?原文未明确写回顾性,只写reviewed;共110例患者、128次CBCT检查,同一牙齿未重复CBCT。
- 将CBCT与相应根尖片比较,评估根尖周病变、遗漏/额外根管、根折、复杂解剖、钙化根管和牙根吸收。
- CBCT开具原因分为3组:形成初步诊断、确认临床检查和传统X线所得诊断、辅助治疗计划;统计采用卡方检验和McNemar检验。
关键影像表现/征象
- CBCT较根尖片显著更多显示根尖周病变(P=0.002)、遗漏根管(P<0.001)、垂直根折(P=0.004)和复杂解剖(P=0.008)。
- CBCT额外信息包括新根尖周病变、遗漏根管或颊/舌侧皮质骨受累。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 参考AAE/AAOMR联合立场声明,CBCT开具原因以辅助手术治疗计划为主(62%),确认诊断占29%,生成诊断占9%。
- CBCT可改变基于根尖片的初始诊断(P=0.001)和治疗计划(P=0.005)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To compare conventional radiographic and cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) findings with reference to the American Association of Endodontics and American Academy of Oral and Maxillofacial Radiology (AAE/AAOMR) joint position statement and to determine the effect of the CBCT on the initial diagnoses and treatment plans in a single-centre Postgraduate Endodontic Programme.
METHODOLOGY: The clinical CBCT scans of patients, treated at the Endodontic Department of the University of British Columbia, were reviewed for CBCT referrals by comparing them with corresponding radiographs. The features considered were periapical lesions, missed/extra canals, root fractures, complex anatomy, calcified canals and root resorption of tooth/teeth in question. Reasons for the CBCT prescriptions were assigned to 3 groups: to formulate the primary diagnosis, to confirm the diagnosis achieved by clinical examination and conventional radiographs, and to assist in treatment planning. Variables were compared statistically using chi-square and McNemar tests.
RESULTS: A total of 128 CBCT examinations were performed on 110 patients. No CBCT examination was performed more than once on the same tooth. Overall, 76% of CBCT examinations were performed on previously root filled teeth. CBCT images revealed a significantly higher incidence of periapical lesions (P = 0.002), missed canals (P < 0.001), vertical root fractures (P = 0.004) and complex anatomy (P = 0.008) than periapical radiographs. CBCT was prescribed most frequently to assist surgical treatment planning (62%) rather than for generating a diagnosis (9%) or confirming diagnoses (29%). Both the diagnosis (P = 0.001) and the treatment plan (P = 0.005) initially made by examining periapical radiographs were altered significantly by the subsequent CBCT examination by revealing information such as new periapical lesions, missed canals or involvement of buccal or lingual cortical bone.
CONCLUSION: CBCT examinations were prescribed mainly to assist treatment planning rather than for diagnosis. The majority of CBCT examinations were performed on previously root filled teeth. The additional information obtained from CBCT scans resulted in the alteration of the initial diagnoses as well as subsequent treatment plans in 59 out of 128 cases.
引用
- Bhatt M, Coil J, Chehroudi B, et al. Clinical decision-making and importance of the AAE/AAOMR position statement for CBCT examination in endodontic cases. Int Endod J. 2020. PMID: 32964475. doi:10.1111/iej.13397
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。