不同经验水平观察者间三种膝骨关节炎影像学分类系统的可靠性
本研究以112例后续行初次全膝关节置换术患者的术前X线为对象,由4名不同经验观察者按IKDC、Kellgren-Lawrence和Ahlbäck分类法各判读两次。观察者间可靠性Ahlbäck与Kellgren-Lawrence为「基本一致」(AC 0.79与0.85),IKDC为「几乎完全一致」(AC 0.97);经验越丰富者观察者内可靠性越好。
要点
- IKDC观察者间一致性最高(AC 0.97),Ahlbäck为0.79、Kellgren-Lawrence为0.85。
- 两名经验较丰富观察者对三种分类系统的观察者内可靠性均为「好」或「优」。
- 两名经验较少观察者对三种分类系统的观察者内可靠性均为「中等」。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 观察者间可靠性:IKDC的AC为0.97,属「几乎完全一致」。
- 观察者间可靠性:Kellgren-Lawrence的AC为0.85,属「基本一致」。
- 观察者间可靠性:Ahlbäck的AC为0.79,属「基本一致」。
- 观察者内可靠性:两名经验较丰富观察者对三种分类系统均为「好」或「优」。
- 观察者内可靠性:两名经验较少观察者对三种分类系统均为「中等」。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To assess the intra- and inter-observer reliability of three commonly referenced radiographic classification systems for knee osteoarthritis in a cohort of arthroplasty candidates.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Pre-operative radiographs of 112 patients who subsequently underwent primary total knee arthroplasty were evaluated by four independent observers of varying experience. Each x-ray was de-identified, randomised, and classified according to the International Knee Documentation Committee, Kellgren-Lawrence, and Ahlbäck classifications. After a 2-week interval period, each x-ray was again randomised and re-classified.
RESULTS: Regarding inter-observer reliability, the Ahlbäck and Kellgren-Lawrence classifications were shown to have 'substantial agreement' (AC 0.79 and 0.85 respectively), and the IKDC was shown to have 'almost perfect agreement' (AC 0.97). Regarding intra-observer reliability, the two more experienced observers demonstrated 'good' or 'excellent' reliability for all classification systems, and the two less experienced observers demonstrated 'moderate' intra-observer reliability for all classification systems.
CONCLUSION: The International Knee Documentation Committee, Kellgren-Lawrence, and Ahlbäck radiographic classifications demonstrated adequate intra- and inter-observer reliability, supporting their potential implementation in surgical practice, or in epidemiological and clinical studies of knee osteoarthritis in a comparable cohort of patients. Clinical experience was positively correlated with intra-observer reliability. Whilst the International Knee Documentation Committee classification demonstrated the greatest reliability, this is likely due to its conservative definitions, and the Ahlbäck and Kellgren-Lawrence classifications are likely more reflective of the spectrum of disease severity encountered in an older patient cohort.
引用
- Wing N, Van Zyl N, Wing M, et al. Reliability of three radiographic classification systems for knee osteoarthritis among observers of different experience levels. Skeletal Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32780155. doi:10.1007/s00256-020-03551-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。