文献速递骨肌DR

不同经验水平观察者间三种膝骨关节炎影像学分类系统的可靠性

Reliability of three radiographic classification systems for knee osteoarthritis among observers of different experience levels.
PubMed 文献 · Skeletal Radiol · 2020-08-11

本研究以112例后续行初次全膝关节置换术患者的术前X线为对象,由4名不同经验观察者按IKDC、Kellgren-Lawrence和Ahlbäck分类法各判读两次。观察者间可靠性Ahlbäck与Kellgren-Lawrence为「基本一致」(AC 0.79与0.85),IKDC为「几乎完全一致」(AC 0.97);经验越丰富者观察者内可靠性越好。

要点

  • IKDC观察者间一致性最高(AC 0.97),Ahlbäck为0.79、Kellgren-Lawrence为0.85。
  • 两名经验较丰富观察者对三种分类系统的观察者内可靠性均为「好」或「优」。
  • 两名经验较少观察者对三种分类系统的观察者内可靠性均为「中等」。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 观察者间可靠性:IKDC的AC为0.97,属「几乎完全一致」。
  • 观察者间可靠性:Kellgren-Lawrence的AC为0.85,属「基本一致」。
  • 观察者间可靠性:Ahlbäck的AC为0.79,属「基本一致」。
  • 观察者内可靠性:两名经验较丰富观察者对三种分类系统均为「好」或「优」。
  • 观察者内可靠性:两名经验较少观察者对三种分类系统均为「中等」。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: To assess the intra- and inter-observer reliability of three commonly referenced radiographic classification systems for knee osteoarthritis in a cohort of arthroplasty candidates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: Pre-operative radiographs of 112 patients who subsequently underwent primary total knee arthroplasty were evaluated by four independent observers of varying experience. Each x-ray was de-identified, randomised, and classified according to the International Knee Documentation Committee, Kellgren-Lawrence, and Ahlbäck classifications. After a 2-week interval period, each x-ray was again randomised and re-classified.

RESULTS: Regarding inter-observer reliability, the Ahlbäck and Kellgren-Lawrence classifications were shown to have 'substantial agreement' (AC 0.79 and 0.85 respectively), and the IKDC was shown to have 'almost perfect agreement' (AC 0.97). Regarding intra-observer reliability, the two more experienced observers demonstrated 'good' or 'excellent' reliability for all classification systems, and the two less experienced observers demonstrated 'moderate' intra-observer reliability for all classification systems.

CONCLUSION: The International Knee Documentation Committee, Kellgren-Lawrence, and Ahlbäck radiographic classifications demonstrated adequate intra- and inter-observer reliability, supporting their potential implementation in surgical practice, or in epidemiological and clinical studies of knee osteoarthritis in a comparable cohort of patients. Clinical experience was positively correlated with intra-observer reliability. Whilst the International Knee Documentation Committee classification demonstrated the greatest reliability, this is likely due to its conservative definitions, and the Ahlbäck and Kellgren-Lawrence classifications are likely more reflective of the spectrum of disease severity encountered in an older patient cohort.

来源:Skeletal Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Wing N, Van Zyl N, Wing M, et al. Reliability of three radiographic classification systems for knee osteoarthritis among observers of different experience levels. Skeletal Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32780155. doi:10.1007/s00256-020-03551-4

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。