混合方法研究预测乳腺X线摄影中导管原位癌升级为浸润性疾病
本研究纳入2010至2015年间因导管原位癌钙化行立体定向活检的病例,随机生成两个队列各150例(每队列120例纯导管原位癌、30例手术后升级为浸润性疾病)。9名乳腺放射科医生在第一队列中盲法评分升级概率,经焦点小组讨论形成共识标准后,在第二队列中再次盲法评分。第一轮平均AUC为0.623,第二轮显著提高至0.765(p = .045),表明放射科医生可经训练更好地预测导管原位癌升级。
要点
- 伴肿块、不对称或结构扭曲时,导管原位癌升级为浸润性疾病的预测更好。
- 密集钙化范围较大、聚焦最可疑特征而非最常见特征,有助于预测升级。
- BI-RADS描述词不足以充分表征浸润风险,微浸润和小范围导管原位癌预测估计较差。
关键影像表现/征象
- 伴肿块、不对称或结构扭曲时,升级为浸润性疾病预测更好。
- 密集钙化延伸范围较大时,升级预测更好。
- 聚焦最可疑特征而非最常见特征时,升级预测更好。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 第一轮阅读者预测升级的平均AUC为0.623(范围0.514-0.684)。
- 第二轮阅读者预测升级的平均AUC为0.765(范围0.617-0.852),较第一轮显著提高(p = .045)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 乳腺放射科医生可经训练更好地预测导管原位癌升级为浸润性疾病,可能有助于与患者及转诊提供者讨论。
- 放射科医生一致认为BI-RADS描述词不足以充分表征浸润风险。
- 放射科医生一致认为微浸润性疾病和小范围导管原位癌的预测估计较差。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. The incidence of ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) has steadily increased, as have concerns regarding overtreatment. Active surveillance is a novel treatment strategy that avoids surgical excision, but identifying patients with occult invasive disease who should be excluded from active surveillance is challenging. Radiologists are not typically expected to predict the upstaging of DCIS to invasive disease, though they might be trained to perform this task. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study was to determine whether a mixed-methods two-stage observer study can improve radiologists' ability to predict upstaging of DCIS to invasive disease on mammography. METHODS. All cases of DCIS calcifications that underwent stereotactic biopsy between 2010 and 2015 were identified. Two cohorts were randomly generated, each containing 150 cases (120 pure DCIS cases and 30 DCIS cases upstaged to invasive disease at surgery). Nine breast radiologists reviewed the mammograms in the first cohort in a blinded fashion and scored the probability of upstaging to invasive disease. The radiologists then reviewed the cases and results collectively in a focus group to develop consensus criteria that could improve their ability to predict upstaging. The radiologists reviewed the mammograms from the second cohort in a blinded fashion and again scored the probability of upstaging. Statistical analysis compared the performances between rounds 1 and 2. RESULTS. The mean AUC for reader performance in predicting upstaging in round 1 was 0.623 (range, 0.514-0.684). In the focus group, radiologists agreed that upstaging was better predicted when an associated mass, asymmetry, or architectural distortion was present; when densely packed calcifications extended over a larger area; and when the most suspicious features were focused on rather than the most common features. Additionally, radiologists agreed that BI-RADS descriptors do not adequately characterize risk of invasion, and that microinvasive disease and smaller areas of DCIS will have poor prediction estimates. Reader performance significantly improved in round 2 (mean AUC, 0.765; range, 0.617-0.852; p = .045). CONCLUSION. A mixed-methods two-stage observer study identified factors that helped radiologists significantly improve their ability to predict upstaging of DCIS to invasive disease. CLINICAL IMPACT. Breast radiologists can be trained to better predict upstaging of DCIS to invasive disease, which may facilitate discussions with patients and referring providers.
引用
- Grimm LJ, Neely B, Hou R, et al. Mixed-Methods Study to Predict Upstaging of DCIS to Invasive Disease on Mammography. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2021. PMID: 32783550. doi:10.2214/AJR.20.23679
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。