低资源环境下床旁产科超声远程医疗质量保证方法的验证
研究验证了低资源地区床旁产科超声的远程质量保证与改进方案,以美国产科超声标准为参照。经最少培训人员采集的压缩电影片段由受过产科超声培训的医师判读,比较读者间及读者与金标准间的一致性。胎盘前壁和后壁位置、胎儿数目、胎方位及孕龄推算的一致性良好,其他胎盘位置一致性较低。
要点
- 胎盘前壁和后壁位置判读的读者间及与金标准一致性极好(Cohen κ 0.81–0.88 和 0.77–0.9)。
- 胎儿数目一致性极好(Cohen κ 0.82–1,敏感度 0.83–1,特异度 0.99–1)。
- 超过 94% 的产科扫查方案超声孕龄与金标准孕龄相差在 7 天内。
核心结论
- 电影片段超声图像可为远程读者提供足够信息,以可靠确定胎盘位置、胎儿数目、胎方位和孕龄推算。
研究设计与样本
- 远程质量保证与改进方案验证研究,以美国产科超声标准诊疗为参考标准。
- 由接受最少培训的人员采集压缩电影片段超声图像(产科扫查方案),由受过产科超声培训的医师判读。
- 比较读者间及每名读者与金标准超声扫描报告之间的一致性,采用描述性统计进行分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 胎盘前壁和后壁位置:读者间 Cohen κ 0.81–0.88,读者与金标准间 Cohen κ 0.77–0.9,一致性极好。
- 其他胎盘位置(左侧、右侧、宫底、低置):Cohen κ 为轻微或轻微/一般,敏感度和特异度范围宽。
- 胎儿数目:读者间及与金标准间 Cohen κ 0.82–1,敏感度 0.83–1,特异度 0.99–1,一致性极好。
- 胎方位:读者间 Cohen κ 0.79–0.85,读者与金标准间 Cohen κ 0.43–0.49。
- 生物学参数及基于参数的孕龄推算:除股骨长外,读者间信度 0.79–0.85;超过 94% 的产科扫查方案超声孕龄在对应金标准孕龄 7 天内。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: A remote quality assurance and improvement protocol for point-of-care obstetric ultrasound in low-resource areas was validated against the standard of care for obstetric ultrasound in the United States.
METHODS: Compressed movie clip ultrasound images (obstetric sweep protocol) obtained by minimally trained personnel were read and interpreted by physicians with training in obstetric ultrasound. Observed findings were compared among readers and between each reader and the gold standard ultrasound scan report. Descriptive statistics were used for the analysis.
RESULTS: The agreements among readers and between readers and the gold standard, for the anterior and posterior variables of the placental location were excellent, with Cohen κ values of 0.81 to 0.88 and 0.77 to 0.9, respectively. Cohen κ values were slight or slight/fair for other placental locations (left, right, fundal, and low), and the sensitivity and specificity ranged widely. The agreement among readers and between readers and the gold standard for fetal number comparisons was also excellent, with Cohen κ values ranging from 0.82 to 1, sensitivity from 0.83 to 1, and specificity from 0.99 to 1. The agreement among readers for fetal presentation comparisons, according to the Cohen κ, ranged from 0.79 to 0.85 and between readers and the gold standard had values of 0.43 to 0.49. For biometric parameters and estimated gestational age calculations based on these parameters, inter-reader reliability ranged from 0.79 to 0.85 for all parameters except femur length. Greater than 94% of obstetric sweep protocol ultrasound ages were within 7 days of the corresponding gold standard age.
CONCLUSIONS: Movie clip ultrasound images provided adequate information for remote readers to reliably determine the placental location, fetal number, fetal presentation, and pregnancy dating.
引用
- Dougherty A, Kasten M, DeSarno M, et al. Validation of a Telemedicine Quality Assurance Method for Point-of-Care Obstetric Ultrasound Used in Low-Resource Settings. J Ultrasound Med. 2020. PMID: 32770709. doi:10.1002/jum.15429
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。