Bosniak分类2019版对囊性肾肿块的CT与MRI分类比较
本研究回顾性分析45例患者共68个囊性肾肿块,由3名腹部放射科医生分别独立使用Bosniak分类2019版及原版对CT和MRI进行判读。结果显示2019版CT与MRI在多数病例中分类一致,因检查方式导致的分类变化无统计学意义,两种检查方式的观察者间一致性均为实质性。
要点
- Bosniak分类2019版在CT与MRI之间多数病例分类一致,因检查方式导致的分类变化无统计学意义。
- MRI较CT显示更多分隔,三种放射科医生间差异均有统计学意义。
- MRI导致分类升级最常见原因为仅MRI可见的突起、分隔数目增多及新分类「T1加权不均匀高信号」。
核心结论
- 使用Bosniak分类2019版时,CT与MRI在多数囊性肾肿块病例中分类一致,因检查方式导致的分类变化无统计学意义(p=0.502)。
- CT与MRI的观察者间一致性均为实质性(CT κ=0.745,MRI κ=0.655),且均略高于原版系统(CT κ=0.707,MRI κ=0.623)。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,3名腹部放射科医生独立判读45例患者的68个连续囊性肾肿块,所有肿块均在2005年至2019年间一年内接受CT和MRI肾脏肿块方案检查。
- CT与MRI分别独立、分次判读,同时使用Bosniak分类原版和2019版。
关键影像表现/征象
- MRI较CT显示更多分隔,三种放射科医生间差异均有统计学意义(p<0.001,p=0.046,p=0.005;McNemar检验)。
- CT与MRI显示的突起数目无显著差异(p=0.823,p=1.0,p=0.302),最大分隔及壁厚度亦无显著差异(p=1.0,p=1.0,p=0.145)。
- 2019版分类不一致病例中,MRI使12个肿块分类升高,最常见原因为仅MRI可见的突起(n=4)、分隔数目增多(n=3)及新分类「T1加权不均匀高信号」(n=3)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- Bosniak分类2019版CT分类结果:I类12个、II类19个、IIF类13个、III类4个、IV类20个。
- Bosniak分类2019版MRI分类结果:I类8个、II类15个、IIF类23个、III类9个、IV类13个。
- 2019版总体观察者间一致性:CT κ=0.745,MRI κ=0.655;原版:CT κ=0.707,MRI κ=0.623。
- 因检查方式导致分类变化的可能性在2019版(p=0.502)和原版(p=0.823)均无统计学意义(McNemar检验)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- Bosniak分类2019版应用于囊性肾肿块时具有实质性观察者间一致性,且CT或MRI均不导致系统性分类升级。
- MRI可显示更多分隔,判读时需注意;仅MRI可见的突起、分隔数目增多及T1加权不均匀高信号是MRI导致分类升高的常见原因。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND. Bosniak classification version 2019 proposed refinements for cystic renal mass characterization and now formally incorporates MRI, which may improve concordance with CT. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study is to compare concordance of CT and MRI in evaluation of cystic renal masses using Bosniak classification version 2019. METHODS. Three abdominal radiologists retrospectively reviewed 68 consecutive cystic renal masses from 45 patients assessed with both CT and MRI renal mass protocols within a year between 2005 and 2019. CT and MRI were reviewed independently and in separate sessions, using both the original and 2019 versions of Bosniak classification systems. RESULTS. Using Bosniak classification version 2019, cystic renal masses were classified into 12 category I, 19 category II, 13 category IIF, four category III, and 20 category IV by CT and eight category I, 15 category II, 23 category IIF, nine category III, and 13 category IV by MRI. Among individual features, MRI showed more septa (p < 0.001, p = 0.046, p = 0.005; McNemar test) for all three radiologists, although both CT and MRI showed a similar number of protrusions (p = 0.823, p = 1.0, p = 0.302) and maximal septa and wall thickness (p = 1.0, p = 1.0, p = 0.145). Of the discordant cases with version 2019, MRI led to a higher categorization in 12 masses. The reason for upgrade was most commonly because of protrusions identified only on MRI (n = 4), an increased number of septa (n = 3), and a new category: heterogeneously T1-weighted hyperintensity (n = 3). Neither modality was more likely to lead to a categorization change for either version 2019 (p = 0.502; McNemar test) or the original (p = 0.823) Bosniak classification system. Overall interrater agreement was substantial for both CT (κ = 0.745) and MRI (κ = 0.655) using version 2019 and was slightly higher than that of the original system for CT (κ = 0.707) and MRI (κ = 0.623). CONCLUSION. CT and MRI were concordant in the majority of cases using Bosniak classification version 2019, and category changes by modality were not statistically significant. Interrater agreements were substantial for both CT and MRI. CLINICAL IMPACT. Bosniak classification version 2019 as applied to cystic renal masses has substantial interrater agreement and does not lead to systematic category upgrades with either CT or MRI.
引用
- Tse JR, Shen J, Shen L, et al. Bosniak Classification of Cystic Renal Masses Version 2019: Comparison of Categorization Using CT and MRI. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2020. PMID: 32755181. doi:10.2214/AJR.20.23656
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。