计算机断层扫描上的结肠粪便负荷与排便习惯无关:一项横断面研究
研究纳入非急诊腹部CT检查患者并发放肠道问卷,患者应答率19%(96/516),另对20例评估阅片者间信度。CT粪便负荷与粪便性状、排便频率、胃肠道症状或功能性便秘诊断均无临床有用关联。医生问卷应答率35%(33/94),42%曾申请腹部X线、18%曾申请CT评估慢性排便习惯。
要点
- CT所示结肠粪便负荷与患者报告的排便习惯及基于标准的便秘诊断均无临床有用关联。
- 医生可能用腹部CT评估患者慢性排便习惯,但客观评估不支持这一做法。
- 评估排便功能时不宜仅凭CT粪便负荷判断便秘,需结合临床问卷与诊断标准。
核心结论
- 医生可能使用腹部CT评估患者慢性排便习惯,但客观评估不支持这一做法。
- 结肠粪便负荷与患者报告症状或基于标准的便秘诊断不相关。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面研究,纳入非急诊腹部CT检查患者,患者应答率19%(96/516)。
- 对20例患者评估CT粪便负荷的阅片者间信度。
- 对开单医生进行在线问卷调查,医生应答率35%(33/94)。
关键影像表现/征象
- CT所示粪便负荷与粪便性状、排便频率、胃肠道症状或便秘诊断之间未发现临床有用关联。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以患者填写肠道问卷(排便频率、粪便性状、胃肠道症状、功能性便秘诊断)与CT粪便负荷进行相关/关联分析。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 医生机会性使用影像数据比刻意使用更常见,但42%的医生曾申请腹部X线、18%曾申请CT以评估患者慢性排便习惯。
- 约30%的医生认为证据支持用腹部影像评估慢性排便习惯。
局限性
- 患者应答率为19%(96/516)。
- 医生应答率为35%(33/94)。
- 阅片者间信度仅在20例患者亚组中评估。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Stool burden on abdominal radiographs is not reflective of constipation, perhaps because of variable fecal shadowing or limited inter-rater agreement. These limitations are hypothetically mitigated by computed tomography (CT). This research aimed (i) to evaluate whether bowel movement frequency, stool form, or a diagnosis of functional constipation correlate or associate with stool burden identified on CT, and (ii) to investigate whether physicians use CT in their assessment of a patients' bowel function.
METHODS: Patients attending for non-emergent abdominal CT imaging were invited to participate by completing a bowel questionnaire. Stool burden identified on imaging was determined and inter-rater reliability was evaluated in a subgroup of patients (n = 20). Descriptive and comparative analyses were performed. An online questionnaire evaluated the use of abdominal imaging in assessing patients' bowel function in a cross-section of ordering physicians.
RESULTS: The patient response rate was 19% (96/516). No clinically useful associations between fecal burden and stool form, bowel motion frequency, gastrointestinal symptoms or a diagnosis of constipation was identified. The physician response rate was 35% (33/94). Opportunistic use of data was more common than deliberate use. However, an abdominal radiograph or CT scan had been requested by 42% and 18% of physicians respectively to assess patient's chronic bowel habit. Approximately 30% of physicians believed evidence supported this practice.
CONCLUSIONS: Physicians may use abdominal CT in their assessment of patients' chronic bowel habits. However, objective assessment does not support this practice. Colonic stool burden does not correlate with patient-reported symptoms or a criteria-based diagnosis of constipation.
引用
- Ferguson D, Holmes RD, Scott R, et al. Colonic stool burden on computed tomography does not correlate with bowel habit: a cross-sectional study. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2020. PMID: 32761405. doi:10.1007/s00261-020-02689-y
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。