螺旋三维T1加权Turbo Field Echo:用于磁化准备梯度回波脑磁共振成像的提速
在41例临床患者中比较四种各向同性三维T1加权TFE序列(螺旋1.0、螺旋0.85、笛卡尔压缩感知CS 2.5及传统SENSE)的脑成像质量。螺旋1.0在多数定性类别中评分显著优于SENSE,并被最频繁选为首选序列,扫描时间2分16秒,较SENSE的5分52秒缩短61.4%。作者结论为螺旋T1w TFE序列可能提供高质量临床脑成像,性能匹配传统并行成像加速T1w TFE。
要点
- 螺旋1.0序列扫描时间2分16秒,较SENSE的5分52秒缩短61.4%,且在10/9个(有/无对比剂)定性类别中评分显著优于SENSE。
- 螺旋1.0在4个定量指标(白质灰质CNR、灰质-CSF对比率、白质-CSF对比率、白质CV)上显著优于SENSE。
- 螺旋1.0被三位读者最频繁选为首选序列(有/无对比剂分别为10/15、9/12、11/13次)。
核心结论
- 螺旋T1w TFE序列可能提供高质量临床脑成像,性能匹配传统并行成像加速T1w TFE。
- 成像扫描时间可短至每序列2分16秒,较SENSE缩短61.4%。
- 螺旋成像可选地提高空间分辨率,同时保持笛卡尔采集方案的扫描时间。
研究设计与样本
- 在41例患者(20例使用对比剂、21例未使用对比剂)中采集四种三维T1加权TFE序列,比较两种原型螺旋TFE序列(螺旋1.0和螺旋0.85)、笛卡尔压缩感知加速TFE序列(CS 2.5,加速因子2.5)与常规笛卡尔并行成像加速TFE序列(SENSE,加速因子1.8)。
- SENSE(5分52秒)、CS 2.5(3分17秒)和螺旋1.0(2分16秒)具有相同的空间分辨率(1.0 mm);螺旋0.85(3分47秒)具有更高的空间分辨率(0.85 mm)。
- 三位读者对12个定性图像质量类别进行评分并为每位患者选择首选序列;两位读者进行定量分析,得出6项指标:白质和灰质的对比噪声比(CNRWM/GM)、灰质-CSF对比率(CRGM/CSF)、白质-CSF对比率(CRWM/CSF)、灰质变异系数(CVGM)、白质变异系数(CVWM)和CSF变异系数(CVCSF)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 定性分析中,CS 2.5在有/无对比剂时分别于4/1个类别显著优于SENSE;螺旋1.0和螺旋0.85分别于10/9和7/7个类别评分显著提高(P<0.001-0.039)。
- 读者间一致性范围为中等至几乎完美(Krippendorff alpha=0.615-0.997)。
- 定量分析中,与SENSE相比,CS 2.5在2个类别(CVWM、CVCSF)显著更优、在2个类别(CRGM/CSF、CRWM/CSF)更差;螺旋1.0在4个类别(CNRWM/GM、CRGM/CSF、CRWM/CSF、CVWM)显著改善;螺旋0.85在2个类别(CRGM/CSF、CRWM/CSF)显著更优。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 螺旋1.0序列在1.5 T脑成像中可提供与SENSE相当的定性图像质量,且扫描时间显著缩短。
- 螺旋0.85序列可在3分47秒内提供0.85 mm各向同性分辨率,高于其他序列的1.0 mm。
- 压缩感知CS 2.5序列在部分定量噪声指标上更优,但在灰质-CSF及白质-CSF对比率上差于SENSE。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Spiral magnetic resonance imaging acquisition may enable improved image quality and higher scan speeds than Cartesian trajectories. We tested the performance of four 3D T1-weighted (T1w) TFE sequences (magnetization-prepared gradient echo magnetic resonance sequence) with isotropic spatial resolution for brain imaging at 1.5 T in a clinical patient cohort based on qualitative and quantitative image quality metrics. Two prototypical spiral TFE sequences (spiral 1.0 and spiral 0.85) and a Cartesian compressed sensing technology accelerated TFE sequence (CS 2.5; acceleration factor of 2.5) were compared with a conventional (reference standard) Cartesian parallel imaging accelerated TFE sequence (SENSE; acceleration factor of 1.8).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The SENSE (5:52 minutes), CS 2.5 (3:17 minutes), and spiral 1.0 (2:16 minutes) sequences all had identical spatial resolutions (1.0 mm). The spiral 0.85 (3:47 minutes) had a higher spatial resolution (0.85 mm). The 4 TFE sequences were acquired in 41 patients (20 with and 21 without contrast media). Three readers rated qualitative image quality (12 categories) and selected their preferred sequence for each patient. Two readers performed quantitative analysis whereby 6 metrics were derived: contrast-to-noise ratio for white and gray matter (CNRWM/GM), contrast ratio for gray matter-CSF (CRGM/CSF), and white matter-CSF (CRWM/CSF); and coefficient of variations for gray matter (CVGM), white matter (CVWM), and CSF (CVCSF). Friedman tests with post hoc Nemenyi tests, exact binomial tests, analysis of variance with post hoc Dunnett tests, and Krippendorff alphas were computed.
RESULTS: Concerning qualitative analysis, the CS 2.5 sequence significantly outperformed the SENSE in 4/1 (with/without contrast) categories, whereas the spiral 1.0 and spiral 0.85 showed significantly improved scores in 10/9and 7/7 categories, respectively (P's < 0.001-0.039). The spiral 1.0 was most frequently selected as the preferred sequence (reader 1, 10/15 times; reader 2, 9/12 times; reader 3, 11/13times [with/without contrast]). Interreader agreement ranged from substantial to almost perfect (alpha = 0.615-0.997). Concerning quantitative analysis, compared with the SENSE, the CS 2.5 had significantly better scores in 2 categories (CVWM, CVCSF) and worse scores in 2 categories (CRGM/CSF, CRWM/CSF), the spiral 1.0 had significantly improved scores in 4 categories (CNRWM/GM, CRGM/CSF, CRWM/CSF, CVWM), and the spiral 0.85 had significantly better scores in 2 categories (CRGM/CSF, CRWM/CSF).
CONCLUSIONS: Spiral T1w TFE sequences may deliver high-quality clinical brain imaging, thus matching the performance of conventional parallel imaging accelerated T1w TFEs. Imaging can be performed at scan times as short as 2:16 minutes per sequence (61.4% scan time reduction compared with SENSE). Optionally, spiral imaging enables increased spatial resolution while maintaining the scan time of a Cartesian-based acquisition schema.
引用
- Sartoretti T, Sartoretti E, van Smoorenburg L, et al. Spiral 3-Dimensional T1-Weighted Turbo Field Echo: Increased Speed for Magnetization-Prepared Gradient Echo Brain Magnetic Resonance Imaging. Invest Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32816415. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000000705
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。