基于Wave-CAIPI的超快速MPRAGE序列用于视觉分级与脑组织体积自动测量的评估
研究在10名健康志愿者中比较标准MPRAGE与超快速Wave-MPRAGE序列的脑体积重复测量个体内变异性,并在43例连续脑MR检查患者中比较两种序列的自动分割体积和视觉分级。结果显示两序列在健康志愿者中的平均绝对对称化百分比变化无统计学差异,患者中Dice相似系数为0.86–0.95,脑体积和皮层厚度的绝对对称化百分比变化差异<6%,两名放射科医师的视觉评分差异无临床或统计学意义。结论认为超快速Wave-MPRAGE估计的脑体积个体内变异性低,与标准MPRAGE相当。
要点
- 超快速Wave-MPRAGE序列(R=9,TA=1.15分钟,32通道线圈;R=6,TA=1.75分钟,20通道线圈)与标准MPRAGE(R=2,TA=5.2分钟)的脑体积测量个体内变异性无统计学差异。
- 在疑似神经退行性疾病患者中,两序列体积测量的Dice相似系数为0.86–0.95,脑体积和皮层厚度的绝对对称化百分比变化差异<6%。
- 两名放射科医师使用半定量视觉分级量表评估脑萎缩,其评分差异无临床或统计学意义。
核心结论
- 超快速Wave-MPRAGE估计的脑体积个体内变异性低,在疑似神经退行性疾病临床评估患者中与标准MPRAGE相当。
研究设计与样本
- 扫描-再扫描实验纳入10名健康志愿者,评估标准MPRAGE和Wave-MPRAGE序列测量的脑体积个体内变异性。
- 纳入43例连续接受脑MR成像的患者,进行3T脑MR成像,包括标准MPRAGE序列(加速因子R=2,采集时间TA=5.2分钟)和超快速Wave-MPRAGE序列(32通道线圈R=9,TA=1.15分钟;20通道线圈R=6,TA=1.75分钟)。
- 对区域脑体积进行自动分割,并由两名放射科医师使用半定量视觉分级量表评估区域脑萎缩。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 健康志愿者扫描-再扫描实验的平均绝对对称化百分比变化在标准MPRAGE和Wave-MPRAGE序列中任何脑区均无统计学差异。
- 疑似神经退行性疾病患者中,标准MPRAGE与Wave-MPRAGE体积测量的Dice相似系数范围为0.86至0.95。
- 所有脑区的脑体积和皮层厚度绝对对称化百分比变化在两种序列间差异<6%。
- 半定量视觉比较中,两名放射科医师评分差异无临床或统计学意义。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Volumetric brain MR imaging typically has long acquisition times. We sought to evaluate an ultrafast MPRAGE sequence based on Wave-CAIPI (Wave-MPRAGE) compared with standard MPRAGE for evaluation of regional brain tissue volumes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: We performed scan-rescan experiments in 10 healthy volunteers to evaluate the intraindividual variability of the brain volumes measured using the standard and Wave-MPRAGE sequences. We then evaluated 43 consecutive patients undergoing brain MR imaging. Patients underwent 3T brain MR imaging, including a standard MPRAGE sequence (acceleration factor [R] = 2, acquisition time [TA] = 5.2 minutes) and an ultrafast Wave-MPRAGE sequence (R = 9, TA = 1.15 minutes for the 32-channel coil; R = 6, TA = 1.75 minutes for the 20-channel coil). Automated segmentation of regional brain volume was performed. Two radiologists evaluated regional brain atrophy using semiquantitative visual rating scales.
RESULTS: The mean absolute symmetrized percent change in the healthy volunteers participating in the scan-rescan experiments was not statistically different in any brain region for both the standard and Wave-MPRAGE sequences. In the patients undergoing evaluation for neurodegenerative disease, the Dice coefficient of similarity between volumetric measurements obtained from standard and Wave-MPRAGE ranged from 0.86 to 0.95. Similarly, for all regions, the absolute symmetrized percent change for brain volume and cortical thickness showed <6% difference between the 2 sequences. In the semiquantitative visual comparison, the differences between the 2 radiologists' scores were not clinically or statistically significant.
CONCLUSIONS: Brain volumes estimated using ultrafast Wave-MPRAGE show low intraindividual variability and are comparable with those estimated using standard MPRAGE in patients undergoing clinical evaluation for suspected neurodegenerative disease.
引用
- Longo MGF, Conklin J, Cauley SF, et al. Evaluation of Ultrafast Wave-CAIPI MPRAGE for Visual Grading and Automated Measurement of Brain Tissue Volume. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2020. PMID: 32732274. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A6703
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。