与乳腺影像报告评分相关的阅片者特征和乳腺X线特征
澳大利亚放射科医生对5套乳腺X线测试集(每套含20例癌症和40例正常)共完成117次阅片,采用Tabar BI-RADS分类。38%的含癌乳腺X线被报告为3类,女性、BreastScreen阅片者及完成乳腺阅片 fellowship 者假阴性率更低;离散肿块和非对称致密影多判为3类,毛刺状肿块或星芒状病变多判为5类。
要点
- 38%的含癌乳腺X线被报告为3类,仅16.2%报告为5类。
- 女性、BreastScreen阅片者及完成乳腺阅片 fellowship 者使用1类和2类时假阴性率更低(p<0.01或p<0.05)。
- 离散肿块和非对称致密影多判为3类(47-50%,p=0.005),毛刺状肿块或星芒状病变多判为5类(26%,p=0.001)。
关键影像表现/征象
- 离散肿块和非对称致密影是最常被报告为3类不确定发现的两类异常(47-50%,p=0.005)。
- 毛刺状肿块或星芒状病变最常被选择为5类高度提示恶性(26%,p=0.001)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 38%的含癌乳腺X线被报告为3类,32.3%为4类,16.2%为5类,16.6%被标记为1类,10.3%被标记为2类。
- 女性阅片者使用1类和2类报告癌症病例时的假阴性率低于男性阅片者(p<0.01)。
- BreastScreen阅片者及完成乳腺阅片 fellowship 的阅片者与非BreastScreen及未完成 fellowship 的阅片者相比,呈现与性别分类相似的模式(p<0.05)。
- 每周阅片数量少的放射科医生更倾向于将癌症病例记录为4类,而阅片数量多者更倾向于记录为3类(p<0.01)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: This study aims to explore the reading performances of radiologists in detecting cancers on mammograms using Tabar Breast Imaging Reporting and Data System (BIRADS) classification and identify factors related to breast imaging reporting scores.
METHODS: 117 readings of five different mammogram test sets with each set containing 20 cancer and 40 normal cases were performed by Australian radiologists. Each radiologist evaluated the mammograms using the BIRADS lexicon with category 1 - negative, category 2 - benign findings, category 3 - equivocal findings (Recall), category 4 - suspicious findings (Recall), and category 5 - highly suggestive of malignant findings (Recall). Performance metrics (true positive, false positive, true negative, and false negative) were calculated for each radiologist and the distribution of reporting categories was analyzed in reader-based and case-based groups. The association of reader characteristics and case features among categories was examined using Mann-Whitney U and Kruskal-Wallis tests.
RESULTS: 38% of cancer-containing mammograms were reported with category 3 which decreased to 32.3% with category 4 and 16.2% with category 5 while 16.6 and 10.3% of cancer cases were marked with categories 1 and 2. Female readers had less false-negative rates when using categories 1 and 2 for cancer cases than male readers (p < 0.01). A similar pattern as gender category was also found in Breast Screen readers and readers completed breast reading fellowships compared with non-Breast Screen and non-fellowship readers (p < 0.05). Radiologists with low number of cases read per week were more likely to record the cancer cases with category 4 while the ones with high number of cases were with category 3 (p < 0.01). Discrete mass and asymmetric density were the two types of abnormalities reported mostly as equivocal findings with category 3 (47-50%; p = 0.005) while spiculated mass or stellate lesions were mostly selected as highly suggestive of malignancy with category 5 (26%, p = 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS: Most radiologists used category 3 when reporting cancer mammograms. Gender, working for BreastScreen, fellowship completion, and number of cases read per week were factors associated with scoring selection. Radiologists reported higher Tabar BIRADS category for specific types of abnormalities on mammograms than others.
ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: The study identified factors associated with the decision of radiologists in assigning a BIRADS Tabar score for mammograms with abnormality. These findings will be useful for individual training programs to improve the confidence of radiologists in recognizing abnormal lesions on screening mammograms.
引用
- Trieu PDY, Lewis SJ, Li T, et al. Reader characteristics and mammogram features associated with breast imaging reporting scores. Br J Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32730088. doi:10.1259/bjr.20200363
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。