文献速递妇产影像儿科影像技术与安全US

六种出生体重与估计胎儿体重标准预测不良围产结局的性能:一项为期10年的全国性人群研究

Performance of six birth-weight and estimated-fetal-weight standards for predicting adverse perinatal outcome: a 10-year nationwide population-based study.
PubMed 文献 · Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol · 2021-01-01

结果显示不同标准间分类差异显著且预测性能均较差(AUC 0.49-0.62),作者提示采用通用标准时需谨慎。

要点

  • INTERGROWTH-21st出生体重与估计胎儿体重标准将足月小于胎龄儿分类减少约一半,大于胎龄儿分类增加约一倍。
  • 足月小于胎龄儿(第3百分位以下)使用INTERGROWTH-21st标准时围产期死亡相对风险最高达其他标准的1.5倍。
  • 所有出生体重与估计胎儿体重标准预测不良结局的AUC均较低(0.49-0.62),性能相似且差。

核心结论

  • 六种出生体重与估计胎儿体重标准在小于胎龄儿和大于胎龄儿分类及不良结局风险上存在显著差异。
  • 所有标准预测不良结局的性能均相似且较差,复合结局AUC范围为0.49-0.62。
  • 作者认为,为通用采纳而构建的规范性国际标准是否适用于澳大利亚等多族裔人群存疑,临床和流行病学使用通用标准时需谨慎。

研究设计与样本

  • 评估三种出生体重标准(澳大利亚人群标准、Fenton、INTERGROWTH-21st)和三种估计胎儿体重标准(Hadlock、INTERGROWTH-21st、WHO)。
  • 按分娩孕周分层(<37+0周与≥37+0周),以小于胎龄儿和大于胎龄儿分类、相对风险及受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUC)评价对死产、新生儿死亡、围产期死亡、复合发病率及围产期死亡与发病率复合结局的预测性能。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 小于胎龄儿定义为出生体重或估计胎儿体重低于第10百分位,大于胎龄儿定义为高于第90百分位;部分分析采用第3百分位阈值。
  • 足月组中,INTERGROWTH-21st出生体重与估计胎儿体重标准分类的小于胎龄儿(<第10百分位)为3-4%,其他标准为7-11%。
  • 足月组中,INTERGROWTH-21st出生体重与估计胎儿体重标准分类的大于胎龄儿(>第90百分位)为24-25%,其他标准为8-15%。
  • 早产组中,WHO-估计胎儿体重和Hadlock-估计胎儿体重标准识别的小于胎龄儿分类率为18-19%,其他标准为10-11%。
  • 足月小于胎龄儿(<第3百分位)使用两种INTERGROWTH-21st标准时围产期死亡相对风险比其他标准(包括WHO-估计胎儿体重和Hadlock-估计胎儿体重)最高高1.5倍。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 不同出生体重与估计胎儿体重标准对小于胎龄儿和大于胎龄儿的分类差异显著,阅片和报告时需明确所用标准。
  • 各标准预测不良围产结局的AUC均较低(0.49-0.62),提示单凭这些标准预测不良结局能力有限。
  • 作者认为采用通用生长标准用于临床和流行病学需谨慎。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate three birth-weight (BW) standards (Australian population-based, Fenton and INTERGROWTH-21st ) and three estimated-fetal-weight (EFW) standards (Hadlock, INTERGROWTH-21st and WHO) for classifying small-for-gestational age (SGA) and large-for-gestational age (LGA) and predicting adverse perinatal outcomes in preterm and term babies.

METHODS: This was a nationwide population-based study conducted on a total of 2.4 million singleton births that occurred from 24 + 0 to 40 + 6 weeks' gestation between 2004 and 2013 in Australia. The performance of the growth charts was evaluated according to SGA and LGA classification, and relative risk (RR) and diagnostic accuracy based on the areas under the receiver-operating-characteristics curves (AUCs) for stillbirth, neonatal death, perinatal death, composite morbidity and a composite of perinatal death and morbidity outcomes. The analysis was stratified according to gestational age at delivery (< 37 + 0 vs ≥ 37 + 0 weeks).

RESULTS: Following exclusions, 2 392 782 singleton births were analyzed. There were significant differences in the SGA and LGA classification and risk of adverse outcomes between the six BW and EFW standards evaluated. For the term group, compared with the other standards, the INTERGROWTH-21st BW and EFW standards classified half the number of SGA (< 10th centile) babies (3-4% vs 7-11%) and twice the number of LGA (> 90th centile) babies (24-25% vs 8-15%), resulting in a smaller cohort of term SGA at higher risk of adverse outcome and a larger LGA cohort at lower risk of adverse outcome. For term SGA (< 3rd centile) babies, the RR of perinatal death using the two INTERGROWTH-21st standards was up to 1.5-fold higher than those of the other standards (including the WHO-EFW and Hadlock-EFW), while the INTERGROWTH-21st -EFW standard indicated a 12-26% reduced risk of perinatal death for LGA cases across centile thresholds. Conversely, for the preterm group, the WHO-EFW and Hadlock-EFW standards identified a higher SGA classification rate than did the other standards (18-19% vs 10-11%) and a 20-65% increased risk of perinatal death in term LGA babies. All BW and EFW charts had similarly poor performance in predicting adverse outcomes, including the composite outcome (AUC range, 0.49-0.62) for both preterm (AUC range, 0.58-0.62) and term (AUC range, 0.49-0.50) cases and across centiles. Furthermore, specific centile thresholds for identifying adverse outcomes varied markedly by chart between BW and EFW standards.

CONCLUSIONS: This study addresses the recurrent problem of identifying fetuses at risk of morbidity and perinatal mortality associated with growth disorders and provides new insights into the applicability of international growth standards. Our findings of marked variation in classification and the similarly poor performance of prescriptive international standards and the other commonly used standards raise questions about whether the prescriptive international standards that were constructed for universal adoption are indeed applicable to a multiethnic population such as that of Australia. Thus, caution is needed when adopting universal standards for clinical and epidemiological use. © 2020 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.

来源:Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Choi SKY, Gordon A, Hilder L, et al. Performance of six birth-weight and estimated-fetal-weight standards for predicting adverse perinatal outcome: a 10-year nationwide population-based study. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2021. PMID: 32672406. doi:10.1002/uog.22151

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。