放射科住院医师模拟培训应包含的技术操作共识:一项欧洲范围的需求评估
本研究采用改良德尔菲法,收集来自27个欧洲国家的71名教育利益相关者对放射科住院医师应掌握技术操作的共识;首轮提出831项操作,归并为34项,第三轮剔除8项后最终纳入26项,其中超声类操作排名靠前。作者认为这些操作适合模拟培训,应成为放射科医师教育不可或缺的部分。
要点
- 最终共识纳入26项适合模拟培训的技术操作,按优先级排序。
- 超声类操作排名靠前,包括探头操作等基本技能及腹部、肾、腹膜后、肠道、阴囊超声。
- 该需求评估是开发标准化模拟培训项目、促进欧洲教育培训协调的第一步。
核心结论
- 该优先级操作清单代表欧洲放射学教育利益相关者达成的共识文件,这些操作适合模拟培训,应成为放射科医师教育不可或缺的部分。
研究设计与样本
- 欧洲范围需求评估研究,采用改良德尔菲法从教育利益相关者收集共识,共71名来自27个欧洲国家的关键教育利益相关者参与。
- 第一轮为头脑风暴阶段,识别新晋专科放射科医师应能完成的所有操作;第二轮评估每项操作对模拟培训的需求,参与者判定频率、执行该操作的放射科医师数量、对患者舒适度和安全的影响及模拟可行性;结果返回参与者进行最终评估和优先级排序。
- 第二、三轮应答率分别为72%和82%;第一轮提出的831项操作经归并分类为34项并在第二轮预排序,第三轮剔除8项后最终纳入26项。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 最终纳入26项适合模拟培训的技术操作;超声类操作排名靠前,包括探头操作等基本技能、腹部超声及肾、腹膜后、肠道和阴囊超声。
局限性
- 该需求评估仅是开发标准化模拟培训项目、支持欧洲教育培训协调的第一步。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To identify and prioritize technical procedures for simulation-based training that should be part of the education of residents in radiology.
METHODS: This European-wide needs assessment study used a modified Delphi technique to gather consensus from different key education stakeholders in the field. The first round was a brainstorming phase to identify all procedures that a newly specialized radiologist should potentially be able to do. In the second round, each procedure was explored for the need for simulation training; the participants determined frequency, number of radiologists performing the procedure, impact on patient comfort and safety, and feasibility of simulation. The result of this round was sent back to the participants for final evaluation and prioritization.
RESULTS: Seventy-one key education stakeholders from 27 European countries agreed to participate and were actively involved in the Delphi process: response rates were 72% and 82% in the second and third round, respectively. From 831 suggested procedures in the first round, these were grouped and categorized into 34 procedures that were pre-prioritized in the second round according to the need for simulation-based training. In the third round, 8 procedures were eliminated resulting in final inclusion of 26 procedures. Ultrasound procedures were highly ranked including basic skills such as probe handling; abdominal ultrasound; and ultrasound of kidneys, retroperitoneum, intestines, and scrotum.
CONCLUSION: The prioritized list of procedures represents a consensus document decided upon by educational stakeholders in radiology across Europe. These procedures are suitable for simulation and should be an integral part of the education of radiologists.
KEY POINTS: • The 26 identified procedures are listed according to priority and should be included as an integral part of simulation-based training curricula of radiologists across Europe. • This needs assessment is only the first step towards developing standardized simulation-based training programs that support the harmonization of education and training across Europe.
引用
- Nayahangan LJ, Albrecht-Beste E, Konge L, et al. Consensus on technical procedures in radiology to include in simulation-based training for residents: a European-wide needs assessment. Eur Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32725331. doi:10.1007/s00330-020-07077-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。