睾丸未降处理中的不适当影像检查:明智选择推荐是否减少了其发生
本研究纳入2007年1月至2018年8月在本院因睾丸未降接受手术的1010例男孩,分析转诊前影像检查的使用情况及相关因素。结果显示25.3%的患儿转诊前接受了影像检查,其中7例为CT或MRI,其余为超声。居住地离医疗中心较近及术中睾丸不在腹股沟管的男孩更可能接受影像检查,而明智选择推荐的发布未影响影像使用率(p=0.61)。
要点
- 睾丸未降患儿转诊前影像检查率仍高达25.3%,其中超声占绝大多数。
- 居住地离医疗中心较近及术中睾丸不在腹股沟管的男孩更可能被安排影像检查。
- 明智选择推荐发布后影像使用率无变化(p=0.61),需加强向初级保健医生传播该指南。
核心结论
- 转诊前诊断影像的使用仍然不恰当地高,尽管有证据表明这些检查无效。
- 居住地离医疗中心较近及术中睾丸不在腹股沟管的男孩更可能接受这些检查,但未发现其他影响因素。
- 明智选择推荐未能改善本转诊区域睾丸未降男孩的不适当影像使用率,作者认为需要加大力度向初级保健医生传播该循证指南。
研究设计与样本
- 研究类型为在本机构开展的回顾性分析,纳入2007年1月至2018年8月由泌尿外科手术治疗的睾丸未降男孩。
- 共1010例男孩纳入分析,收集人口学与临床数据包括身高、体重、种族、保险类型、转诊前影像状态、术中睾丸位置及距医疗中心距离。
- 使用卡方分析比较明智选择推荐前后的影像使用情况,采用卡方和双样本t检验评估其他临床和社会经济因素对影像利用的影响,对在0.2水平显著的因素进行多因素logistic回归,显著性设定为0.05。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 256例(25.3%)有转诊前影像检查,其中7例接受轴位检查(CT或MRI),其余接受超声。
- 居住地离医疗中心较近的儿童更可能接受影像检查(p<0.01)。
- 术中睾丸不在腹股沟管的男孩更可能接受影像检查(p=0.007)。
- 种族、保险状态、首次就诊年龄及体重指数增加未显示有影响。
- 明智选择推荐的发布对影像使用无影响(p=0.61)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文结论指出需要加大力度向初级保健医生传播该循证指南,以促进睾丸未降男孩更经济有效的及时诊疗。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
INTRODUCTION: Cryptorchidism is one of the most common referral diagnoses to pediatric urologists. It is well recognized in the urologic community that diagnostic imaging is unnecessary in the work-up of these patients, and the Choosing Wisely® recommendation (CWR) on this subject re-emphasized this in 2013. Many boys, however, still are sent for testing prior to referral.
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of our study was dual in nature. We pursued, first, to identify any factors that make patients more likely to be sent for imaging prior to referral, and second, to determine if rates of diagnostic imaging for cryptorchidism decreased after the release of the CWR.
STUDY DESIGN: We included all boys who had surgery for cryptorchidism by Urology at our institution between January 2007 and August 2018. Demographics and clinical data were collected including height, weight, race, insurance type, pre-referral imaging status, testis location at time of surgery, and distance from our medical center. Chi-squared analysis was utilized to compare imaging use before and after CWR. Influence of other clinical and socioeconomic factors on imaging utilization was also evaluated using chi-squared and two-sample t tests. Those found to be significant at the 0.2 level were analyzed in multivariate logistic regression. Significance was set at 0.05.
RESULTS: 1010 boys were available for analysis. Of the 256 patients (25.3%) with pre-referral studies, 7 had axial exams (CT or MRI), and the remainder underwent ultrasounds. Children living closer to the medical center were more likely to undergo imaging (p < 0.01) as were boys with testes not found in the inguinal canal at the time of surgery (p = 0.007). Race, insurance status, age at first visit, and increased body mass index were not found to be influential. Similarly, the release of CWR had no impact on the imaging usage (p = 0.61).
CONCLUSION: Utilization of pre-referral diagnostic imaging remains inappropriately high despite evidence demonstrating the ineffectiveness of the studies. Boys living closer to the medical center and those with non-inguinal testes are more likely to undergo these studies, but no other factors were found to have an effect. Further, the Choosing Wisely® recommendation has not improved rates of inappropriate imaging use in boys with cryptorchidism in our referral area. Our findings indicate the need for increased efforts to disseminate this evidence-based guideline more widely to primary care providers in order to promote more cost-effective and timely care of boys with undescended testes.
引用
- Carpenter CP, Johnston D, Tourville E, et al. Inappropriate imaging for management of cryptorchidism: Has the choosing Wisely® recommendation reduced occurrence? J Pediatr Urol. 2020. PMID: 32674979. doi:10.1016/j.jpurol.2020.06.017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。