V/Q SPECT与CT血管造影诊断慢性血栓栓塞性肺动脉高压的比较
前瞻性研究纳入150例疑似慢性血栓栓塞性肺动脉高压(CTEPH)患者,以数字减影肺动脉造影为参考标准,比较V/Q SPECT、V/Q平面显像与CT肺动脉造影(CT PA)的诊断效能。三种方法在个体水平敏感度和特异度均较高且差异无统计学意义,但节段分析中V/Q显像敏感度更高、特异度更低。
要点
- 个体水平诊断:V/Q SPECT敏感度98%、特异度89%,CT PA敏感度94%、特异度96%,差异无统计学意义。
- 节段分析:V/Q SPECT敏感度85%、V/Q平面83%,均高于CT PA的67%;特异度V/Q平面51%、V/Q SPECT 42%,均低于CT PA的60%。
- 节段水平AUC:V/Q平面0.67、V/Q SPECT 0.64、CT PA 0.64,V/Q平面与V/Q SPECT差异有统计学意义(P=0.02)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 个体分析:V/Q SPECT敏感度98%、特异度89%;V/Q平面显像敏感度98%、特异度91%;CT PA敏感度94%、特异度96%(所有P>.05)。
- 节段分析:V/Q SPECT敏感度85%(P<.001 vs CT PA)、V/Q平面显像敏感度83%(P<.001 vs CT PA)、CT PA敏感度67%。
- 节段分析特异度:V/Q平面显像51%(P=.03 vs CT PA)、V/Q SPECT 42%(P<.01 vs CT PA)、CT PA 60%。
- 个体分析AUC:CT PA 0.95、V/Q平面显像0.95、V/Q SPECT 0.94(所有P>.05)。
- 节段分析AUC:CT PA 0.64、V/Q平面显像0.67、V/Q SPECT 0.64(V/Q平面 vs V/Q SPECT P=.02;V/Q平面 vs CT PA P=.08;V/Q SPECT vs CT PA P=.94)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Background Accurate methods for identifying obstructions in both large and small vessels are crucial for diagnosis and treatment of chronic thromboembolic pulmonary hypertension (CTEPH). Purpose To compare the performance of ventilation-perfusion (V/Q) scanning, V/Q SPECT, and CT pulmonary angiography (PA) in CTEPH by using digital subtraction PA as the reference standard. Materials and Methods This prospective study was conducted from January 2016 to January 2018. A total of 229 participants suspected of having CTEPH were evaluated with V/Q SPECT, V/Q planar scintigraphy, CT PA, and digital subtraction PA. Participants underwent all four procedures within 1 week. Differences in the diagnostic performance of V/Q SPECT, V/Q planar scintigraphy, and CT PA were evaluated with areas under the curve receiver operator curve, the McNemar test, and generalized estimating equations analysis. Results A total of 150 participants (mean age, 42 years ± 15 [standard deviation]; 99 women) were enrolled. Digital subtraction PA assessments confirmed CTEPH in 51 participants and indicated that 602 of 1020 lung segments (20 segments per participant) were obstructed. The three imaging methods showed high sensitivity (V/Q SPECT, 98%; V/Q planar scintigraphy, 98%; CT PA, 94%) and specificity (V/Q SPECT, 89%; V/Q planar scintigraphy, 91%; CT PA, 96%) (all P > .05). However, both V/Q scanning techniques were more sensitive (V/Q SPECT: 85%, P < .001 vs CT PA: 67%; V/Q planar scintigraphy: 83%, P < .001 vs CT PA: 67%), and less specific (V/Q planar scintigraphy: 51%, P = .03 vs CT PA: 60%; V/Q SPECT: 42%, P < .01 vs CT PA: 60%) than was CT PA for segmental analysis. Areas under the curve for CT PA, V/Q planar scintigraphy, and V/Q SPECT were 0.95, 0.95, and 0.94, respectively (all P > .05), for individual analysis, and 0.64, 0.67, and 0.64, respectively, by segment (V/Q planar scintigraphy vs V/Q SPECT, P = .02; V/Q planar scintigraphy vs CT PA, P = .08; V/Q SPECT vs CT PA, P = .94). Conclusion Ventilation-perfusion scanning was more sensitive and less specific than was CT pulmonary angiography for detecting vascular obstructions at the segmental pulmonary arterial level. © RSNA, 2020 See also the editorial by Swift and Rajaram in this issue.
引用
- Wang M, Wu D, Ma R, et al. Comparison of V/Q SPECT and CT Angiography for the Diagnosis of Chronic Thromboembolic Pulmonary Hypertension. Radiology. 2020. PMID: 32427559. doi:10.1148/radiol.2020192181
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。