量化CT肺血管容积比的最佳衰减阈值
本研究在52例先天性心脏病儿童及年轻成人中,比较固定阈值(80-600 HU)与自适应阈值(肺动脉平均强化值PAavg分别除以2.50、2.00、1.75、1.63、1.50、1.25)对CT右肺血管容积百分比的影响,并以核医学右肺灌注百分比为参考。结果显示固定阈值320-400 HU及自适应阈值PAavg/1.75-1.50为最佳,平均差异≤5%,相关系数分别为0.93和0.91。作者认为两者同样有用,但PAavg范围较宽时自适应阈值可能更合适。
要点
- 固定阈值320-400 HU与自适应阈值PAavg/1.75-1.50均为量化CT肺血管容积比的最佳阈值。
- 最佳阈值下CT与核医学右肺灌注百分比平均差异≤5%,相关系数固定阈值0.93、自适应阈值0.91。
- PAavg范围较宽时,作者认为应用最佳自适应阈值可能比固定阈值更合适。
核心结论
- 量化CT肺血管容积比的最佳固定阈值与自适应阈值似乎同样有用。
- 考虑PAavg范围较宽时,作者认为实际临床实践中应用最佳自适应阈值可能比固定阈值更合适。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入52例先天性心脏病患者,比较CT右肺血管容积百分比与核医学右肺灌注百分比。
- 所选患者均在1年内接受心电图同步心胸CT和肺灌注闪烁显像,期间未行外科或经导管介入治疗。
- CT右肺血管容积百分比分别采用固定阈值(80-600 HU)和自适应阈值(PAavg分别除以2.50、2.00、1.75、1.63、1.50、1.25)计算。
- 最佳阈值定义为平均差异最小、在统计学显著配对比较中P值最低、Pearson相关系数最高。
诊断标准与关键数值
- PAavg为529.5 ± 164.8 HU(范围250.1-956.6 HU)。
- 固定阈值320-400 HU为最佳,平均差异≤5%,配对比较无显著差异(P>0.2),相关系数0.93。
- 自适应阈值PAavg/1.75-1.50为最佳,平均差异≤5%,配对比较无显著差异(P>0.5),相关系数0.91。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 量化CT肺血管容积比时,可采用固定阈值320-400 HU或自适应阈值PAavg/1.75-1.50。
- 当PAavg范围较宽时,作者认为应用最佳自适应阈值可能比固定阈值更合适。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the effects of attenuation threshold on CT pulmonary vascular volume ratios in children and young adults with congenital heart disease, and to suggest an optimal attenuation threshold.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: CT percentages of right pulmonary vascular volume were compared and correlated with percentages calculated from nuclear medicine right lung perfusion in 52 patients with congenital heart disease. The selected patients had undergone electrocardiography-synchronized cardiothoracic CT and lung perfusion scintigraphy within a 1-year interval, but not interim surgical or transcatheter intervention. The percentages of CT right pulmonary vascular volumes were calculated with fixed (80-600 Hounsfield units [HU]) and adaptive thresholds (average pulmonary artery enhancement [PAavg] divided by 2.50, 2.00, 1.75, 1.63, 1.50, and 1.25). The optimal threshold exhibited the smallest mean difference, the lowest p-value in statistically significant paired comparisons, and the highest Pearson correlation coefficient.
RESULTS: The PAavg value was 529.5 ± 164.8 HU (range, 250.1-956.6 HU). Results showed that fixed thresholds in the range of 320-400 HU, and adaptive thresholds of PAavg/1.75-1.50 were optimal for quantifying CT pulmonary vascular volume ratios. The optimal thresholds demonstrated a small mean difference of ≤ 5%, no significant difference (> 0.2 for fixed thresholds, and > 0.5 for adaptive thresholds), and a high correlation coefficient (0.93 for fixed thresholds, and 0.91 for adaptive thresholds).
CONCLUSION: The optimal fixed and adaptive thresholds for quantifying CT pulmonary vascular volume ratios appeared equally useful. However, when considering a wide range of PAavg, application of optimal adaptive thresholds may be more suitable than fixed thresholds in actual clinical practice.
引用
- Goo HW, Park SH. Optimal Attenuation Threshold for Quantifying CT Pulmonary Vascular Volume Ratio. Korean J Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32410414. doi:10.3348/kjr.2019.0789
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。