文献速递骨肌儿科影像DR

骨龄评估的现代化:比较人工智能算法与简写骨龄法同Greulich和Pyle法的一致性与可靠性

Modernization of bone age assessment: comparing the accuracy and reliability of an artificial intelligence algorithm and shorthand bone age to Greulich and Pyle.
PubMed 文献 · Skeletal Radiol · 2020-04-23

本研究以213名男性和213名女性为对象,由两名评估者分别用简写骨龄法(SBA)和Greulich-Pyle(GP)法测定骨龄并在3周后重复,同时将去标识化手部X线片上传至多伦多放射科医生团队开发的自动算法;以经验丰富放射科医生用GP法出具的放射学报告为金标准,结果各方法与金标准组内相关系数均在0.8–0.9,多数比较差异有统计学意义但介于0.25–0.5年、可能无临床意义,SBA与自动算法与金标准一致且缩短分析时间。

要点

  • SBA法与自动算法同GP金标准组内相关系数均在0.8–0.9,提示高度一致。
  • 多数比较中新方法与金标准差异有统计学意义,但差异为0.25–0.5年,可能无临床意义。
  • 骨龄超出实际年龄2个标准差视为临床异常,标准差按GP图谱计算提供。

核心结论

  • 简写骨龄法与自动算法所得数值与金标准一致,同时缩短分析时间。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入213名男性和213名女性,由两名独立评估者分别用SBA法和GP法测定骨龄,3周后重复分析并用在线秒表计时。
  • 去标识化手部X线片被安全上传至多伦多一组放射科医生开发的自动算法。
  • 金标准为每张X线片所附的放射学报告,由经验丰富的放射科医生使用GP法撰写。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 各方法与金标准之间的组内相关系数落在0.8–0.9范围内,提示显著一致。
  • 多数比较显示新方法与金标准之间差异有统计学意义,但差异范围为0.25–0.5年,可能无临床意义。
  • 骨龄超出实际年龄2个标准差被视为临床异常,标准差按GP图谱计算并提供。

局限性

  • 多数比较中新方法与金标准的差异虽有统计学意义但仅为0.25–0.5年,原文认为可能无临床意义。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

UNLABELLED: Greulich and Pyle (GP) is one of the most common methods to determine bone age from hand radiographs. In recent years, new methods were developed to increase the efficiency in bone age analysis like the shorthand bone age (SBA) and automated artificial intelligence algorithms.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to evaluate the accuracy and reliability of these two methods and examine if the reduction in analysis time compromises their efficacy.

METHODS: Two hundred thirteen males and 213 females had their bone age determined by two separate raters using the SBA and GP methods. Three weeks later, the two raters repeated the analysis of the radiographs. The raters timed themselves using an online stopwatch. De-identified radiographs were securely uploaded to an automated algorithm developed by a group of radiologists in Toronto. The gold standard was determined to be the radiology report attached to each radiograph, written by experienced radiologists using GP.

RESULTS: Intraclass correlation between each method and the gold standard fell within the range of 0.8-0.9, highlighting significant agreement. Most of the comparisons showed a statistically significant difference between the new methods and the gold standard; however, it may not be clinically significant as it ranges between 0.25 and 0.5 years. A bone age is considered clinically abnormal if it falls outside 2 standard deviations of the chronological age; standard deviations are calculated and provided in GP atlas.

CONCLUSION: The shorthand bone age method and the automated algorithm produced values that are in agreement with the gold standard while reducing analysis time.

来源:Skeletal Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Gerges M, Eng H, Chhina H, et al. Modernization of bone age assessment: comparing the accuracy and reliability of an artificial intelligence algorithm and shorthand bone age to Greulich and Pyle. Skeletal Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32328674. doi:10.1007/s00256-020-03429-5

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。