文献速递骨肌CTDR

膝关节3D打印解剖模型评估髌股关节发育不良:与标准X线摄影和计算机断层扫描的比较

3D-printed anatomic models of the knee for evaluation of patellofemoral dysplasia in comparison to standard radiographs and computed tomography.
PubMed 文献 · Eur J Radiol · 2020-04-18

研究对50例患者CT数据进行分割并打印股骨远端和髌骨3D解剖模型,由专家小组以CR、CT、3D模型及病史综合分类作为参考标准,比较两位阅片者基于3D模型与CR/CT对股骨滑车发育不良(正常或Dejour A-D型)和髌骨(Wiberg A-C型)分类的诊断准确性。结果显示3D模型检测髌股关节发育不良的敏感度/特异度与CR/CT相似,对经验较少的医师有提高诊断的潜力。

要点

  • 3D模型检测股骨滑车发育不良的AUC在阅片者1为0.946、阅片者2为0.982,均不低于CR/CT。
  • Dejour分型在3D模型与CR/CT间无显著差异,但敏感度均偏低(32.1%-57.1%)。
  • Wiberg分型3D模型与CR/CT完全一致率为50%-66%,阅片者间Kappa 0.428-0.92。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 股骨滑车发育不良参考标准为专家小组分类(正常或Dejour A-D型),髌骨为Wiberg A-C型。
  • 3D模型检测股骨滑车发育不良:阅片者1敏感度89.3%、特异度100%、AUC 0.946;阅片者2敏感度96.4%、特异度100%、AUC 0.982。
  • CR/CT检测股骨滑车发育不良:阅片者1敏感度96.4%、特异度68.2%、AUC 0.823;阅片者2敏感度96.4%、特异度90.9%、AUC 0.937。
  • AUC比较:阅片者1 P=0.029,阅片者2 P=0.147。
  • Dejour分型3D模型 vs CR/CT:阅片者1敏感度32.1%/特异度100% vs 敏感度57.1%/特异度68.2%;阅片者2敏感度46.4%/特异度100% vs 敏感度50%/特异度90.9%,无显著差异。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: To evaluate 3D-printed anatomic models of the distal femur and patella for diagnosis and classification of patellofemoral dysplasia in comparison to conventional radiographs (CR) and CT.

METHOD: Following local ethics committee approval, CT-datasets of 50 patients were segmented and 3D-anatomic models of the distal femur and patella were printed. An expert panel reviewed CR, CT, 3D-models and patient history and classified the femoral trochleas into normal or Dejour type A-D and the patellas into Wiberg type A-C, which served as the standard of reference. The same classifications were performed by two readers independently, first based on 3D-models and after 3 weeks based on CR and CT. Descriptive statistics, ROC-analysis and inter-reader reliability were performed.

RESULTS: Trochlear dysplasia was present in 28/50 patients. Evaluations of 3D-models vs. CR/CT for trochlear dysplasia showed a sensitivity/specificity of 89.3 %/100 % vs. 96.4 %/68.2 % for reader 1 and 96.4 %/100 % vs. 96.4 %/90.9 % for reader 2, and an area under the curve of 0.946 vs. 0.823 for reader 1 (p = 0.029) and 0.982 vs. 0.937 for reader 2 (p = 0.147). Evaluations of 3D-models vs. CR/CT for the Dejour classification showed a sensitivity/specificity of 32.1 %/100 % vs. 57.1 %/68.2 % for reader 1 and 46.4 %/100 % vs. 50 %/90.9 % for reader 2 without significant differences. No significant differences existed for Wiberg-classification (50-66 % exact matches) or inter-reader reliabilities between 3D-models and CR/CT for all assessments (Kappa 0.428-0.92).

CONCLUSION: In comparison to radiographs and CT, 3D-models achieve similar diagnostic accuracy for detection of patellofemoral dysplasia and have the potential to improve diagnosis for less experienced physicians.

来源:Eur J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fritz B, Fucentese SF, Zimmermann SM, et al. 3D-printed anatomic models of the knee for evaluation of patellofemoral dysplasia in comparison to standard radiographs and computed tomography. Eur J Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32344295. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2020.109011

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。