文献速递神经骨肌MR

基于矢状位T2加权图像的颈椎中央椎管狭窄MRI分级系统的观察者间信度与临床有效性

Inter-observer reliability and clinical validity of the MRI grading system for cervical central stenosis based on sagittal T2-weighted image.
PubMed 文献 · Eur J Radiol · 2020-04-08

研究纳入133例在本院行颈椎MRI的患者,由2名放射科医生、2名受训者和2名临床医生按Kang分级系统测量颈椎中央椎管狭窄(CCSS)最窄处等级,并由一名神经外科医生评估相关神经表现。结果显示受训者间(k=0.890)和放射科医生间(k=0.912)几乎完全一致,临床医生间(k=0.691)显著一致;所有6名阅片者的临床相关性呈中等相关(R值0.380~0.566),各组内分级与临床表现也呈中等相关(R=0.562~0.669)。结论认为该分级系统提供客观、可靠、可重复的评估,临床医生可重复性略低于放射科医生和受训者。

要点

  • Kang分级系统在放射科医生和受训者间信度几乎完全一致(k分别为0.912和0.890),临床医生间信度显著一致(k=0.691)。
  • 分级与阳性临床表现之间呈中等相关,所有阅片者R值为0.380~0.566,各组内R值为0.562~0.669。
  • 该系统基于正中矢状位MRI,评估客观、可重复,不依赖阅片者的专业领域熟练度。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • Kang分级系统用于评估颈椎中央椎管狭窄(CCSS),测量点为最窄处,基于正中矢状位T2加权图像。
  • 受训者间信度k值为0.890,放射科医生间k值为0.912,临床医生间k值为0.691。
  • 所有6名阅片者的分级与阳性临床表现临床相关性R值为0.380~0.566。
  • 各组内分级与临床表现的相关性R值为0.562~0.669。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 在正中矢状位T2加权图像上按Kang分级系统于最窄点测量颈椎中央椎管狭窄等级,放射科医生与受训者间信度几乎完全一致(k=0.912和0.890)。
  • 临床医生间信度显著一致(k=0.691),略低于放射科医生和受训者,但分级与临床表现的相关性在各组内均为中等(R=0.562~0.669)。
  • 图像判读与临床表现的相关性为中等(所有阅片者R=0.380~0.566),与阅片者主要领域无关。

局限性

  • 临床医生的可重复性略低于放射科医生和放射科受训者。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: The aim was to evaluate the inter-observer reliability of the Kang system among radiologists, residents, and clinicians and examine the correlation between radiologic and clinical findings.

METHODS: A total of 133 patients (M:F = 44:89, mean age 56 years) who underwent MRI of the cervical spine at our hospital were included. Two radiologists, two trainees, and two clinicians measured Central cervical spinal stenosis (CCSS) grade at the narrowest point according to the grading system suggested by Kang et al. A different clinician (a neurosurgeon) assessed the associated neurologic manifestations. Kappa statistics were used to analyze the inter-reader agreement among the radiologists, trainees, and clinicians. The clinical correlation (R) between grade and positive clinical manifestations (PCMs) was assessed using nonparametric correlation analysis (Spearman's correlation).

RESULTS: We found almost perfect agreement between trainees (k value = 0.890) and between radiologists (k value = 0.912) and substantial agreement between clinicians (k value = 0.691). Clinical correlations for all six readers suggested moderate correlation with R values ranging from 0.380 to 0.566. There was moderate correlation between grade and clinical manifestation within each group (R = 0.562-0.669).

CONCLUSION: The Kang MRI grading system of CCSS based on mid-sagittal MRI provides objective, reliable, and reproducible assessment regardless of field proficiency of the reader although the reproducibility of the clinician is slightly lower than radiologist and trainee of the radiology department. There was moderate correlation between image interpretation and clinical findings irrespective of the reader's main field of research.

来源:Eur J Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lee KH, Park HJ, Lee SY, et al. Inter-observer reliability and clinical validity of the MRI grading system for cervical central stenosis based on sagittal T2-weighted image. Eur J Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32298959. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2020.108987

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。