X射线诊断参考水平的变异性研究
该研究基于全国345个医疗中心590台设备2015至2017年收集的胸部、腹部、骨盆和腰椎X射线检查的剂量面积乘积数据,采用自举法评估设备数量与每台设备数据量对诊断参考水平变异性的影响。结果显示DRL变异性随设备数量和数据量在30%至200%间变化,当设备数超过200至400台后稳定在30%左右,且与每台设备数据量无关。作者建议欧盟各国监管机构统一数据收集方法。
要点
- DAP相关DRL并非固定值而是至少存在30%变异性的范围值。
- 设备数低于100时DRL强烈依赖纳入设备数量。
- 设备数超过200至400后DRL变异性不超过30%且与每台设备DAP数据量无关。
核心结论
- DAP相关DRL变异性较高,但仅中等程度受每台设备DAP数据量和设备数量影响,前提是设备数高于200至400台(依检查类型而定)。
- 作者建议欧盟各国监管机构之间统一数据收集方法。
研究设计与样本
- 研究由国家核监管机构从全国345个医疗中心的590台设备收集剂量面积乘积(DAP)数据。
- 2015至2017年间各中心收集的胸部(仅后前位,以及后前位和侧位)、腹部、骨盆和腰椎检查数量范围为23,000至77,000。
- 采用自举法评估设备数量和每台设备DAP数据量对DRL变异性(95%置信区间除以中位数)的影响。
诊断标准与关键数值
- DRL变异性范围为30%至200%,取决于设备数量和每台设备DAP数据量。
- 胸部后前位和腹部检查设备数高于200台、腰椎和骨盆检查高于300台、胸部后前位联合侧位检查高于400台时,DRL变异性稳定在30%,与每台设备DAP数据量无关。
- 外推结果提示需数千台设备才能将DRL变异性降至10%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To estimate the variability of X-ray diagnostic reference levels (DRLs) depending on the number of X-ray devices and data per device.
METHODS: Dose-area products (DAP) were collected by the national nuclear control agency from the 590 devices installed in 345 medical centers in the country. From 2015 to 2017, the number of chest (postero-anterior (PA) view alone, and both postero-anterior and lateral views (PA/LAT)), abdomen, pelvis, and lumbar spine examinations collected in these centers ranged from 23,000 to 77,000. The impact of the number of devices and DAP data per device on DRLs' variabilities (95th confidence intervals divided by medians) is estimated using a bootstrapping method as a function of the number of devices and DAP per device.
RESULTS: The DRLs' variabilities ranged from 30 to 200% depending on the number of devices and DAP data per device but stabilized at 30% when the number of devices was higher than 200 for chest PA and abdomen examinations, 300 for lumbar spine and pelvis examinations, and 400 for chest PA/LAT examinations, regardless of the number of DAP data per device. Extrapolations of our results suggest that thousands of devices are necessary to reduce DRLs' variabilities to 10%.
CONCLUSION: DAP-related DRL variabilities are high but only moderately influenced by the number of DAP data per device and of devices provided this number is higher than 200 to 400 devices according to the type of examination. Harmonization of methods of data collection between the authorities of the EU states should be recommended.
KEY POINTS: • DAP-related DRLs are not fixed values but ranges of values with at least 30% variability. • DAP-related DRLs strongly depend on the number of devices included when lower than 100. • If the number of devices included exceeds 200 to 400, the DRLs' variabilities do not depend on the number of DAP per device and should not exceed 30%.
引用
- Vanaudenhove T, Van Muylem A, Howarth N, et al. Variabilities in X-ray diagnostic reference levels. Eur Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32270316. doi:10.1007/s00330-020-06819-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。