盆腔MRI诊断子宫内膜异位症:经验不足放射科医生的诊断挑战——多少经验才足够?
这项前瞻性研究比较了不同经验水平放射科医生(住院医师至专家)对盆腔MRI诊断子宫内膜瘤和深部盆腔子宫内膜异位症(DPE)的诊断性能,以手术病理为参考标准。结果显示,专家在子宫内膜瘤和DPE总体评估中AUC最高, fellow在部分区域接近专家,但住院医师在多个区域显著低于专家,结论认为DPE的MRI判读应由专科医生完成。
要点
- 专家对子宫内膜瘤和DPE总体评估的AUC分别为0.983和0.914,诊断性能高。
- fellow对DPE后盆腔 compartment的AUC为0.805,显著低于专家的0.921(p=0.001)。
- junior resident对DPE总体评估AUC为0.721,显著低于专家(p<0.001)。
核心结论
- 作者认为,DPE的盆腔MRI判读应由专科医生完成,因为即使女性影像经验达2年的放射科医生,其诊断性能在统计学上仍低于专家。
- 子宫内膜瘤诊断在各经验组间差异较小,但DPE总体及后盆腔 compartment诊断性能随经验增加而提高。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入2016年12月至2017年8月因盆腔子宫内膜异位症行盆腔MRI检查的患者,最终59例有手术病理参考标准。
- 由不同经验水平判读者(junior resident:0-6周女性影像经验;senior resident:7-24周;fellow:6-24个月;expert:10年)评估子宫内膜瘤和DPE,并与手术病理比较。
- 采用受试者工作特征曲线及曲线下面积(AUC)比较各经验组与专家的诊断性能。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 专家判读者:子宫内膜瘤AUC 0.983,DPE后盆腔AUC 0.921,DPE前盆腔AUC 0.615,直肠乙状结肠DPE AUC 0.862,总体评估AUC 0.914。
- fellow判读者:子宫内膜瘤AUC 0.966(p=0.178),DPE后盆腔AUC 0.805(p=0.001),DPE前盆腔AUC 0.605(p=0.91),直肠乙状结肠DPE AUC 0.872(p=0.317),总体评估AUC 0.849(p=0.0009)。
- senior resident判读者:子宫内膜瘤AUC 0.877(p=0.002),DPE后盆腔AUC 0.757(p<0.001),DPE前盆腔AUC 0.585(p=0.761),直肠乙状结肠DPE AUC 0.744(p=0.239),总体评估AUC 0.787(p<0.001)。
- junior resident判读者:子宫内膜瘤AUC 0.861(p=0.177),DPE后盆腔AUC 0.649(p<0.001),DPE前盆腔AUC 0.648(p=0.774),直肠乙状结肠DPE AUC 0.862(p=1),总体评估AUC 0.721(p<0.001)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,DPE的盆腔MRI判读应由专科医生完成。
- 作者指出,即使女性影像经验达2年的放射科医生,其诊断性能在统计学上仍低于专家。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to investigate the impact of radiologist experience on diagnostic performance of pelvic magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) for the evaluation of endometriomas and different localisations of deep pelvic endometriosis (DPE).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this prospective study all pelvic MRI examinations performed for pelvic endometriosis from December 2016 to August 2017 were evaluated by readers with different experience levels; junior resident (0-6 weeks of experience in female imaging), senior resident (7-24 weeks), fellow (6-24 months), and expert (10 years) in female imaging for the presence of endometriomas and DPE. Their evaluations were compared with surgery confirmed with pathology. Diagnostic performances of readers with different levels of experience were studied by the means of receiving operating characteristic curves and areas under the curve (AUC) were compared with the ones of the expert reader.
RESULTS: Of 174 patients evaluated, the standard of reference was available for 59, consisting the final population of the study. The AUC for endometriomas, DPE for the posterior and anterior pelvic compartment, for rectosigmoid DPE and for overall evaluation were 0.983, 0.921, 0.615, 0.862, and 0.914 for the expert reader, 0.966 (p = 0.178), 0.805 (p = 0.001), 0.605 (p = 0.91), 0.872 (p = 0.317), and 0.849 (p = 0.0009) for the fellow level, 0.877 (p = 0.002), 0.757 (p < 0.001), 0.585 (p = 0.761), 0.744 (p = 0.239), and 0.787 (p = < 0.001) for the senior resident level and 0.861 (p = 0.177), 0.649 (p < 0.001), 0.648 (p = 0.774), 0.862 (p = 1), and 0.721 (p < 0.001) for the junior resident level.
CONCLUSIONS: According to our results, interpretation of pelvic MRI for DPE should be performed by specialists as; even the performance of radiologists with up to 2 years of experience in female imaging was statistically inferior to that of experts.
引用
- Bruyere C, Maniou I, Habre C, et al. Pelvic MRI for Endometriosis: A Diagnostic Challenge for the Inexperienced Radiologist. How Much Experience Is Enough? Acad Radiol. 2020. PMID: 32241715. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2020.02.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。